Editor:

Should you step up and stop your friend from an oncoming train and save his/her life? Or should you mind your own business and let him/her get crushed?

Should we allow our friends in Barre to be run over by the Apex train? Allow a few people to chase the Golden Goose and blow caution to the wind?

Let the construction and devastation begin and not warn them? Once the damage is done and the sad residents file for lawsuits, we can tell them that we knew, but decided to remain quiet?

Some residents of Arkwright in Chautauqua County are unable to live on their own property due to ill-placed industrial wind factories. Check out the lawsuits and testimonies from people who unfortunately have first-hand experiences on what happens when “Big Wind” wins.

Agnes LaPorte

Barker

Editor:

We’ve abandoned allies before. When we realized we were going to lose the Vietnam War we convinced many South Vietnamese to continue working with us. We gave most of those who were most closely aligned with us assurances we’d get them out of Vietnam if North Vietnam won.

At the very end our ambassador at the time wouldn’t implement the in-place plans to evacuate those Vietnamese c-workers because that would be admitting we were going to lose.

Remember those pictures of the helicopters leaving the US embassy roofs? We helped few get out and of those stuck there, many were tortured and killed by the North Vietnamese. It was morally and ethically despicable to abandon those Vietnamese. History repeats itself.

Dennis Seekins

Lyndonville

Editor:

The Holy Family Social Justice Committee asks: “Do we believe in human rights? And justice for all? Then how do we respond to the plight of the Kurds?”

The HF Social Justice meets each 3rd Tuesday, 10 a.m. in the McCabe Room, Holy Family School, Albion. All are welcome.

We volunteer for and try to raise awareness on local and national concerns involving children, elderly, ill, poor and needy.

Bob Golden

Waterport

Chairman of Holy Family Social Justice Committee

Editor:

I recently wrote you lamenting the US bugging out of northern Syria on abandoning our allies, the Kurds, in their fight against ISIS. The Hub thereafter published a response which was so incorrect and personally insulting that it demands a response!

That offensive letter in effect claimed that because I am not a supporter of President Trump that I was willing (or wanted) American boys to die in a “Syrian Civil War.” Nothing can be further from the truth!

ISIS is an international group composed of twisted people whose goal is to take over the world. They have been fought back by local troops – some with US military in support roles – in various countries all over the Mideast.

At the same time ISIS was expanding, Syria was undergoing a civil war. ISIS became the strongest insurgency in that nation. Our allies, the Kurds, have lost 10,000 or more men beating ISIS back. But because the US did not directly get involved in the “Syrian Civil War,” Russia in large measure stood on the sidelines, too.

Six Americans have sadly lost their lives in Syria. Several Russians have lost theirs, too. But both countries and the Central Syrian government – in fact, everyone – wanted ISIS gone forever.  The world was disgusted by a beheading on TV.

What is correct is that the United States kept the Russians and hostile regimes at bay in the Mideast for over 70 years. Yes, there have been setbacks but:

1) ISIS was almost defeated and many countries in which it was operating are rebuilding.

2) Because the US ran away – with no plan and no notice – the Central Syrian regime is back in control, now along with its new Iranian and Russian friends.

3) Decades of work keeping the Russians and hostile regimes at bay went down the drain in days. Russia was not a major player in the Mideast. Now it is. Iran is stronger.

4) Our allies everywhere now know they cannot depend on us – even when they are doing out bidding and been promised our support.

The writer of that letter should know his facts before he tries to spin history, facts, and politics.

Respectfully,

Conrad F. Cropsey

Albion

Editor:

The Kurds in Syria, Iraq, Iran and Turkey have been trying to establish a homeland station (and declare their independence) for a very long time. They have done so with their blood as a persecuted minority for as long as I can recall.

Their losses have come at the direction of people such as Ayatollah Khomeini, Bashar al-Assad and Saddam Hussein and their successors. Kurdish forces have fought alongside our service members and died supporting our interests in the Middle East for decades.

But now we have decided to desert them and leave them to the mercy of people who despise the United States and work to undermine us throughout the region. In the process, Islamic State in Syria (ISIS) fighters may be turned loose to attack everything “Western” in the region and beyond.

In other words, Islamic extremists may be on the verge of getting another opportunity to wreak havoc on us and our dwindling “fan base” in the area adjacent to the Persian Gulf, the Arabian Sean and the Eastern Mediterranean.

Who is determining U.S. foreign policy as we near 2020?

Gary Kent

Albion

Editor:

My name is Aidan Gamet and I have been a member of the 4-H Program in Orleans County for two years and I was a cloverbud exhibitor before that.

I have participated in different activities throughout the years and most of all I have enjoyed getting to know some great kids and volunteers that are always willing to lend a helping hand. I have been a member of the Goat Busters 4-H Club and the Hearts and HoofBeats Horse Club.

I enjoy working with my animals and taking care of them every day to get them ready for the fair. I have made projects and exhibited them in the Trolley Building, showed goats, a rabbit and a variety of chickens. I have volunteered my time helping out during judging and always glad to step in when needed.

I am proud to tell other people that I am a part of the 4-H Program and to share with them all the different types of things that they can learn about. I have done community service projects and planted gardens in memory of my Great Grandma Janice Giltner, who was a 4-H Leader for 43 years. She taught my grandpa, my mom and many other people the joys of making projects and demonstrating their skills for others. My mom says that she inspired them to be their better selves.

My mom, 4-H and the people in our local program have helped me to stand up for myself. They have told me to be proud of who I am. They have also given me the strength to face my fears and bullies at school. I feel safe and able to express my thoughts with others.

This year I shared my poem titled “Bullied” at the County Fair and it received a “Best in Show” Award for a communication exhibit and it was selected to go to State Fair. I was excited to learn that at State Fair my poem received a blue ribbon and a rosette as a “Special Recognition Award.”

I was happy to know that they liked it, and I hope that it will help other people that are being bullied know that they are not alone. I have taken my exhibit to my school for Bullying Awareness and the teachers want to share it with the other students.

I want to thank everyone for what they have taught me, and I will continue to enjoy making projects, many new friends and inspiring others to discover the joys that the Orleans County 4-H Program can hold for them.

Aidan C. Gamet

Medina

(Aidan is 10, and a member of Goat Buster 4-H Club)

Editor:

I am surprised to see Mr. Cropsey would like to involve our country in Syria’s Civil War. Does it make sense to sacrifice U.S. soldiers in a conflict which has been raging since the beginning of time?

We don’t need death messengers from Syria knocking on our families’ doors. Trump derangement syndrome has turned pacifists into war hawks.

Edward Urbanik

Lyndonville

Editor:

The last National Catholic Reporter said that Bishop Richard Malone will not resign. That’s good news to us, and I believe for the Buffalo Diocese and the Catholic Church overall.

If there were compelling action reasons for calling for Bishop Malone’s resignation, fine. But so far, from published reports, we haven’t seen justification for singling out this Buffalo Bishop, late to this likely 100-year-old-plus problem. He’s been most forthcoming with admitting the problem, seeking and activating hopeful solutions and revealing suspects.

A priest, who’s revealed himself as a victim of clergy abuse, acted as the Bishop’s secretary. This aggrieved priest stated publicly, “Bishop Malone does not like victims.” “He should resign.”

We find that assumption hard to believe.

More importantly, it’s not about liking victims and disliking perpetrators. It’s about doing justice for victims and to perpetrators. Having sex with pre-adolescent children and with adolescents under their charge or responsibility are severely criminal, severely evil and need to be punished severely.

Covering up such evil, especially in a fashion that endangers other children, is also grievous evil, crime and sin.

Bishop Malone is charged with none of these.

What he is, is compassionate, energetic, highly intelligent and educated, a Bible scholar, an outstanding public speaker and educator, and a faithful and good priest. (Our belief is based on hearing him speak as main speaker on Refugees and Immigrants at Christ the King Seminary, in a panel discussion with nationally known authority on immigrants Atty. Michael Marszalkowski, in an hour-long meeting with the Bishop and Congressional representatives, brief personal conversations and faithfully reading his published utterances.)

If he didn’t perform perfectly in this sexual abuse crisis, who did?

We can’t afford to lose this man as Bishop or as a priest or for that matter any priest, based on personal preference.

Most of us Catholics have been incredulous and reluctant to acknowledge the depth of this problem. Rather we saw it more as an individual tragic fall from grace (literally) by a priest, we’ve known and loved. We, unfortunately focused on each single tragedy, rather than the tragedy to so many young children, high school altar servers and students and seminarians.

We didn’t accept that priests among us could behave so cruelly, so destructively, so selfishly. Their behavior is compounded by the fact that they had graces, beyond the rest of us. Instead they utilized their special position to seduce children. But, remember, according to various estimates and the extensive research of John Jay University in 2004, 96% of priests are not sexual abusers of children/adolescents. On the other hand, no priest (nor anyone) should abuse children.

It’s against everything we Catholics profess. We profess concern about the life of all children, born and unborn. Yet, a significant number of our priests, whom we revered and supported, have victimized and damaged the lives of many, many children.

Unfortunately, victims’ plight has been contaminated by a lawsuit-happy world, where multiple lawyers advertise getting rich in these matters. This naturally makes us suspicious. Further the false accusations and then recantations by some, hurts the just claims of the multitude of victims.

However and finally, we Catholics can’t allow ourselves to be divided and ready to react against our own interests in this time of crisis. It’s fair to raise criticism, but it should be done constructively, with charity, forthrightly, and not played out in the media, some of which tends to seek controversy.

Margaret and Robert Golden

Waterport

Editor:

It’s been Turkey’s goal to kill the 2 million Kurds who live in Syria just as they have the ones who used to live in Turkey. These Kurds, our steadfast allies, will die because in the middle of the night – and with no consultation –  the President tweeted a new policy turning the Mideast over to Turkey.

Commentators say that Russia and Iran will become the dominant powers there.

After I got over the horror of the scale of death one tweet can cause, I realized that I never dreamt that the United States would ever be the enemy of the free world. It was simply something I could never imagine.

But here we are. Spin it however you have to in order to live with the guilt but in real life everything bad is turning out to be true.

Sadly,

Conrad F. Cropsey

Albion

Editor:

We see signs going up all over our town implying lower taxes. Well the first question on everybody’s mind is, “How much?”

When we ask this question we don’t get any answers, either from Apex Energy or the any of our current town board members. All we get is more signs.

Next, the citizenry wants to ask how much will Heritage Wind put in a bond to cover the diminished real estate values of our homes if a project is approved by our board or New York State? Strangely enough, no answer to that question either.

Then we ask how much real tax revenue would the our town’s people receive without a PILOT program? No answer to that one either.

Next I would like to ask why would Apex want to give more money to the school district when it is well known the district is already bursting at the seams with taxpayer money, how much more do they really need?

How much money has each of the board members already made by signing one of the most one-sided contracts I’ve ever read? How much did all of the board members pay the attorneys to advise on that issue?

How much longer will the turbine people continue to attack the watchdogs of this community? How much longer will the Town Board ignore our letters that ask if a project is completed here that any proceeds (bonded by the way by Apex) that all the pie in the sky or PILOT monies go to each home owner in Barre in the form of a tax rebate every year? How much will you guarantee?

How much more rhetoric will we hear from our town supervisor about his trip to Europe and how many people he spoke to there and how much you talk about their current love affair with industrial monoliths called turbines?

John Metzler

Barre

Editor:

This letter is in response to Elizabeth Wolanyk’s letter on October 3. Her letter contained a lot of misinformation regarding the financial benefits Barre and Orleans County will receive from Heritage Wind.

With this inability to understand elementary facts and with the distortion of fundamental realities, it is not surprising that the poorly informed author of the previous letter to the editor and members of Clears Skies oppose the Heritage project.

First off, a PILOT, or Payment in Lieu of Taxes, is nothing new and is not unique to wind energy projects. A PILOT is primarily a vehicle to establish tax certainty for municipalities and a project. Unlike tax payments, which will decrease with depreciation, the PILOT will increase over time. Also, with a PILOT there is no risk of a reassessment that may require expensive challenges by our town or county.

Ms. Wolanyk correctly points out that PILOTS are shared among taxing jurisdictions, but fails to understand that the majority of the payments that will go to Barre will be made through a Host Community Agreement (HCA), not the PILOT, and those moneys come directly to the town.

In the case of Heritage Wind, both the PILOT and the HCA are still in negotiations, but the project has released that it will pay enough money every year to the town of Barre to about double its current tax revenue. Based on the current proposal before the town, Barre would receive more than (possibly much more than) $20 million in payments, directly to the town for town uses. The PILOT and HCA will be for a term of 20 or more years, not 15 years as Ms. Wolanyk suggested.

Ms. Wolanyk claims, “The Orleans County IDA lists pilot payments to both villages and towns with the villages taking a greater share of PILOT payments than the towns. Whether any villages will receive any PILOT payments from Heritage Wind is unknown but must be considered.” It is apparent that she does not live in or near Barre, because there is no village there to account for.

I am curious as to why Ms. Wolanyk is so concerned about the town of Barre when she lives in Barker, about 30 miles away. Since this letter was published, SOS also paid for an ad in the Pennysaver, trying to push their misinformation about wind turbines onto Barre residents. They are trying to interfere and take away money from a town they do not live in.

If they were truly concerned for our well-being as a town, they would do proper research before releasing false information. I easily found all of my information on the Heritage Wind website and asked Apex questions to learn more about the subject. I have lived in Barre my whole life, and I want my town to get the best deal possible. Heritage Wind is proposing a lot of money that can transform our town, and I don’t think it is wise for Barre to pass that up.

Alice Mathes

Barre

Editor:

How sad is it that we have to go to Monroe County and pay a fee to dispose of hazardous waste?

I’m cleaning out a garage that has chemicals from two homeowners ago, including lots of paint, stripper and other things you would find in a household garage. I call my local Orleans County office only to find out that they do this only once a year and that I have to go to Monroe County and pay a fee?

It was suggested to hang on to these until they have the pick up next August. Really? Are we really such a diminutive little town that we can only provide services once a year? What does our taxes pay for if not for services for the taxpayers?

Regards,

Stacey Keon

Albion

Editor:

The numbers tell the story. The Latino contribution to the US economy would make this group the eighth largest economy in the world (LDC – US Latino GDPReport).

There is good news but there are two glaring exceptions. First, the deficit is exploding in excess of GDP. That debt needs to be paid. Second, while our 3.6 unemployment rate looks good, it is not. In fact, the job force is losing 300,000 baby boomers a month and we do not have the workers to sustain even our less than 2 percent growth in GDP rate or, worse, service the deficit.

We need a 1/3 increase in our economy to do that. What this means is that we have to solve our immigration problems or our economy will collapse for want of workers.

Conrad Cropsey

Albion

Editor:

In late June an Albion resident found an injured stray cat with a wound on his face and appeared to be blind and deaf.

The woman in Albion contacted Hope for Cats, an all-volunteer cat rescue organization, and she surrendered Sonny to us. After a visit to a veterinarian, Sonny received medication for his wound, surgery for one eye condition, and he was neutered and vaccinated.

Provided photo: Sonny the cat remains friendly despite being a target of cruelty.

We made an appointment with a veterinary eye specialist who confirmed that he had no vision in either eye, and recommended removal of his right eye, which was visibly damaged, in order to avoid possible later development of a malignant sarcoma which can develop in cats with lens damage.

During this surgery eight birdshot pellets were recovered from Sonny’s right eye, and a skull X-ray found 28 more pellets lodged throughout his face and head. So, we received the shocking news that Sonny’s facial wound, his blindness, and probably his deafness, were caused by an intentional act of cruelty toward this perfectly friendly young cat.

Based on the pellets visible in the skull X-ray, the veterinarian advised removal of his left eye also, again to prevent future malignancy. This surgery was performed during which the veterinarian did confirm that two more of the pellets were actually lodged in his left eye.

Sonny is now recovering from this surgery and he is amazing in that he remains friendly, curious, affectionate, loves catnip toys and has no problem finding his litterbox, food and water. He has a safe and loving home waiting for him, and we look forward to a long and comfortable life for him, in spite of the abilities which have been senselessly taken away from him forever.

It is incomprehensible that someone could look this handsome guy in the face and shoot him. However, we have confidence that this person is not representative of Albion residents. This weekend some churches are having pet blessing events.

Sonny is among the many animals who are deserving of kind wishes and actions. If you would like to help with Sonny’s veterinary expenses, please visit our website (www.hopeforcatsinc.org) and use the “Donate” button or find us on Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/hopeforcatsinc/), where we have his story, photos, and an opportunity to donate. Thank you for your attention to this letter and please be kind to our animal friends!

Karen Waible

Hope for Cats, Inc.

Hamburg, NY

Editor:

I sincerely hope that the residents of the Town of Barre do not believe the ads bought by Apex promoting how much money the town will have by accepting Heritage Wind into the community.

Apex is very adept at misleading the public and Town Boards. The term PILOT is Payment in Lieu of Taxes. PILOT payments generally pay only 25 percent of the value of a project. That is why companies like PILOTs so much and will often not move forward without a PILOT. So, from the outset there is a huge loss of taxes for the town. But that is only the beginning.

Apex makes it seem that all of the funds will benefit the town but that is not so. PILOTs are negotiated by the county’s Economic Development Agency (EDA) or Industrial Development Agency (IDA) and that is how they fund their staff and offices. So they take a large chunk of any PILOT.

The school district, or perhaps school districts, take a large portion of the PILOT money because students from the town of Barre attend one of four districts. (The Heritage Wind documentation (PSS) indicates school districts – plural.) However, PILOTs mess up limitations set by the state tax cap and will cause additional problems if and when it goes into effect and when it ends. So the New York State School boards Association has taken a stand against schools accepting PILOT payments.

The Orleans County IDA lists pilot payments to both villages and towns with the villages taking a greater share of PILOT payments than the towns. Whether any villages will receive any PILOT payments from Heritage Wind is unknown but must be considered.

In the 2018 Orleans County Economic Development Agency’s IDA report of PILOT payments, the schools received almost half of the PILOT monies (48%), the county received almost a quarter of the PILOT monies (23%), towns received just less than 10 percent of PILOT payments and villages were paid almost a fifth of the PILOT monies (19%). So, the town gets the last and smallest share of a PILOT payment.

But that is not the end of the Apex deception. This payment is over the life of the project – proposed to be 15 years or so. So instead of considering the advertised $35 million benefit to the town, consider $2.33 million each year divided among the EDA, school districts and the town [(and or village(s)].

How much will be left each year for the town’s benefit? It will certainly be less than a third perhaps much less and what will you be trading away to get it? And why does the Heritage Wind logo only show a tractor – not a wind turbine in sight?

Elizabeth Wolanyk

Barker