Town Board sees benefits of appointed officials; issue could go to voters in November referendum

Photos by Tom Rivers: Nadine Hanlon, the Orleans County clerk, speaks during a public hearing on Tuesday evening at the Shelby Town Hall. The Town Board held public hearings about changing the town clerk and highway superintendent positions from elected to appointed. Hanlon, who was also the Kendall town clerk and an elected Kendall Board of Education member, spoke in favor of keeping the positions as elected. She said the town clerk as an elected official is independent of the Town Board and answers to the people.

SHELBY – The Town Board is considering putting a referendum out to the community in November that would allow Shelby to change from having the town clerk and highway superintendent both be appointed rather than elected.

Town Supervisor Jim Heminway believes the town would be better assured of getting qualified people in those important jobs. Right now, the Republican Committee’s choices for the jobs typically get elected to positions around Orleans County, where Republicans have a 2-to-1 enrollment advantage over Democrats.

Town Clerk Darlene Rich is a rare Democrat holding an elected post in the county. She has been the town clerk for 18 ½ years and has held off Republican challengers in the past. Rich will be retiring after 2027.

Heminway says he is concerned her successor may not be the most qualified candidate if left to the political process. He would prefer the Town Board take job applications from the community for both town clerk and highway superintendent, with the board picking the person in those roles.

That didn’t go over well with many of the speakers during public hearings on Tuesday evening. There were separate hearings about changing the town clerk to an appointed position, and then another hearing about doing the same for highway superintendent.

James A. Dussing, president of New York State Association of Town Superintendents of Highways and Clarence town highway superintendent, speaks during a public hearing on Tuesday.

He said 90 percent of the town highway superintendents are elected among the 933 towns in the state.

He said there is more voter accountability with elected highway superintendents, over appointed ones.

“We are accountable 24-7 to the people who elect us,” he said. “If we are not doing our jobs they let us know. If we’re not doing our jobs they call us or vote us out of office.”

Dussing said he suspects appointed officials would be paid more, with more time off and benefits, and may be hard to remove if they aren’t meeting their job standards.

If the town puts the issue to a public vote, Dussing said he can nearly guarantee it will be rejected by the voters who will wait to keep the right to directly elect their highway superintendent. He said the Shelby Town Board is wasting a lot of time and energy by pursuing the issue.

Pictured from left include Shelby Town Clerk Darlene Rich, Town Councilman John Pratt, Town Councilman Larry Waters and Town Supervisor Jim Heminway.

Heminway said his preference to appoint the town clerk and highway superintendent is part of an overall effort to make the town government more cost effective.

He also wants to see the process for people in those positions opened up to more people in the community.

He said the Town Board would take written comments for two more weeks before deciding whether to put the issue to a referendum. All five board members said they favor going to appointments.

They noted the local Village Boards all appoint the village clerks and department of public works superintendents. The County legislature appoints the county commissioner of public works, and the Boards of Education all hire the school district superintendents.

Heminway said he favors a new process for choosing the town clerk and highway superintendent at Shelby. He doesn’t have anyone in mind for the positions.

Rich will be retiring after the end of her term on Dec. 31, 2027. Dale Root, the current highway superintendent, hasn’t told the Town Board whether he plans to seek re-election. He would be welcome to apply for the job if the town goes to an appointment process, Heminway said.

Currently the town clerk and highway superintendent operate on their own, and don’t need to follow directives from the Town Board, Heminway said.

“We don’t have any no direct control over the town clerk or highway superintendent,” he said.

One speaker at the meeting claimed Root attended a highway superintendent conference despite being told by the board not to due to budgetary concerns.

About 75 people turned out for the public hearings on Tuesday evening.

If the appointment process is approved by the voters, Heminway said the Town Board would work to implement measures to make the positions Civil Service and also protect the appointees from board meddling and any unjust firings.

Heminway said the town could require a super-majority vote to remove an appointed official.

John Pratt, a Shelby councilman, said residents can still have the power of their vote by choosing who is on the Town Board, who then will choose who gets appointed as clerk and highway superintendent.

“There will be better checks and balances where board interviews candidates to choose the best person,” he said.

Waters, Pratt, Heminway and Councilman Ed Zelazny all have been elected despite not having the Republican Committee endorsement. They mounted their own campaigns, securing signatures for petitions and pushing to get their message out.

Waters said it is an uphill battle to run without the Republican Committee’s endorsement, or to run as a Democrat or independent.

The appointment process turns it into a job interview where the Town Board makes the choice on who is the best candidate, Waters said.

He noted the Village of Medina appoints its village clerk and DPW superintendent.

“No one is at the Medina meetings up in arms,” Waters said. “Why? Because that’s the way it’s always been.”

Joe Sidonio, a former Murray town supervisor, commended the Shelby Town Board for the “courage” of proposing a different way to choose the town clerk and highway superintendent.

“I say give them a chance to put forth an idea,” Sidonio said about having the issue go to a public referendum. “It’s voters’ decision whether it goes forward or not.”

Sidonio urged the packed town hall to “leave friendly and warm and not divisive.”

He noted many of the key positions in the county, including the commissioner of public works, are appointed.

Sidonio said too many of the elected positions throughout the county go unopposed.

John Misiti, a lifelong Shelby resident, served as town supervisor for four months last year after the previous supervisor resigned.

Misiti said the town faces escalating costs with revenue that isn’t keeping up, putting more pressure on raising property taxes.

He supports appointing the town clerk and highway superintendent, saying “purposeful change is good.”

Misiti said the town clerk and highway superintendent positions have both become very complicated.

“This isn’t take away someone’s right to vote,” Misiti said. “It’s centralizing the organization. You can’t have three different people doing their own thing.”

Misiti said the change “is about streamlining things and getting into the 21^st century. If we don’t adapt we’ll end up like Kodak. And that is something that is avoidable.”

Gerry Zinkievich, a retired Shelby Town Clerk, believes the Republican Committees are capable of screening candidates to see if they are a good fit for town clerk or highway superintendent.

She said there is a lot of expertise needed to be an effective town clerk. She doesn’t want it to be an appointed position, where the whims of a Town Board decides who serves in the important post.

Maureen Beach, the Barre town clerk for more than 30 years, said a change to an appointed town clerk and highway superintendent “will drastically change how your town operates.”

She said an elected system “provides important checks and balances.”

If appointed, the town clerk and highway superintendent will serve at the pleasure of the Town Board.

“They could be dismissed without voter approval,” Beach said. “Carefully consider the long-term impact.”

Tracy Chalker, left, is the Clarendon highway superintendent and Roger Wolfe, right, is the Yates highway superintendent. They both spoke of favor of having the highway superintendent be elected.

Chalker, who is president of the Orleans County Highway Superintendents Association, said switching to an appointed process leaves choosing the highway leader to the “good ole boys club.”

If the highway chief is appointed, there would be less accountability, he said.

“Being an elected person you are personally libel,” Chalker said. “That keeps you on your toes. I think an elected official puts way more pride in their work than an appointed person.”

Roger Wolfe has been the Yates highway superintendent for the past 41 years, and a Yates highway employee for 49 years.

He said many of the elected highway superintendents stay in the position long-term. He noted the county has had several leaders of the public works department over the years.

“There is no continuity over there,” Wolfe said.

George Phillips urged the Town Board not to pursue the change to an appointment process.

“If you have a problem with the Republican Party, go to the Republican Party and fix it, and don’t take away my right to vote,” Phillips said.

Another resident, Brian Wiesinger, noted apathy at the polls. He said only 14 percent of registered voters turned out in the last Shelby election out of 4,800 voters.

He still prefers having that 14 percent, about 550 to 600 people, choose the town clerk and highway superintendent over a five-person Town Board, which is one-tenth of 1 percent of the registered voters.

Marlene Seielstad, a candidate for a county-wide county legislator position, said the appointment process diminishes voters’ rights. Seielstad, a Democrat, said Shelby shouldn’t try to pass laws or do a public referendum when it’s targeting its highway superintendent.

Shelby would be the first town in Orleans County to go with appointing the clerk and highway superintendent if the issue goes to referendum and passes.

“Agreeing to this is putting the town into the hands of only five people, and honestly, only three as that is the majority required to carry a vote,” Seielstad said. “Imagine that?  Three people could make decisions for nearly 5,000.  Where are the checks and balances?”

Wendi Pencille, a Shelby resident, said taking away the right of residents to directly pick their officials is a bad direction.

“Taking the voice away from the voters is not the right decision – find another way,” she said. “Your proposed solution will make this worse, not better.”

Pencille highlighted Rich has won several terms as a Democrat, one of the few in the county. If the position goes to an appointment, Pencille said the Republican-dominated boards wouldn’t back a Democrat for clerk or highway superintendent.

“You don’t make a new law to address a single personnel issue,” Pencille said. “You’re proposing fast and easy solutions for you, but they are not the right decisions.”

Mike Neidert, the Albion highway superintendent, urged Shelby to keep the highway leader as an elected position.

“To take that away from the people is not a good idea,” he said.

Neidert has run as a Republican and has been cross endorsed by the Democrats and Conservatives.

“I’m not working for a party,” he said. “I’m working for the people.”

Dale Brooks, the Barre highway superintendent, said highway department costs are going up with fuel, trucks and other equipment.

Changing to an appointed highway superintendent wouldn’t reduce the other expenses that are on the rise, he said.

“Our hands are tied when you talk about costs,” he said. “We operate under OGS (state Office of General Services) with contracts.”

Linda Limina and Ed Zelazny, both Town Board members, said they support moving to appointed positions for the two jobs at Town Hall.

“Right now you have three separate islands,” Limina said. “You have a Highway Department, a Clerk’s Office and a Town Board.”

The Town Board can only make suggestions with the town clerk and highway superintendent.

“We had a elected official spend money not authorized, but we can’t do anything about it,” Limina said. “I wish you would hold them accountable.”

Ed Zelazny said he would be focused on appointing whoever is best qualified for the job, regardless of their political affiliation.

He wants the issue to go to a public referendum.

“We’re putting it in front of the taxpayers and the voters,” he said. “It’s your decision.”

SHELBY – In a close race for two positions on the Shelby Republican Committee, John Parada received 66 votes and Steve Seitz, 62, for District 1.

They were ahead of Dale Root with 55 votes. There are only two outstanding absentee ballots.

The vote is close enough that there will be a recount on July 1, said Mike Mele, the Republican election commissioner for Orleans County.

Photos by Tom Rivers: This photo of Dave Green was shared during a slide show at his funeral at the East Shelby Fire Hall, where he was an active member the past 65 years. Green died at age 83 on May 22. Green never left the East Shelby community, where many people considered him the “mayor.”

EAST SHELBY – The East Shelby fire hall was packed with about 300 people on Sunday to say good bye to Dave Green, a much-loved retired sheriff and stayed very active in his retirement, organizing classic car shows and volunteering with the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company.

Green, 83, was praised for his professionalism as sheriff and as the county’s fire coordinator/emergency management director. Green had extraordinary people skills that allowed him to work with the top law enforcement officials in the region and also to connect with inmates in the county jail.

“Dave’s great genius was in how he dealt with people,” said James Punch, retired Orleans County Court judge who also was the county district attorney, a role where he worked closely with Green when he was sheriff. “He could make anyone feel like he was their best friend no matter what walk of life.”

James Punch, who is retired as Orleans County Court judge and district attorney, delivers a eulogy at Sheriff Dave Green’s funeral on Sunday. Green earned the respect of the law enforcement community in Western New York. Punch said there were five murders his first 18 months as DA, and Green and the Sheriff’s Department did excellent police work leading to convictions in all the cases.

Green pulled off the rare feat of being elected as a Democrat to a countywide position in Orleans County, were Republicans have a 2-to-1 advantage over Democrats, and Green did it five times. He was first elected in November 1978 and served as sheriff until the end of 1998.

Green had a way of uniting people and brining out their higher calling, whether in the fire service, law enforcement or other community service, Punch said.

When Green retired as sheriff, he worked in the courthouse as a court officer. Punch was the judge. There was another court officer who became good friends with Green: Don White. He was the Republican candidate who lost an election to Green. Several years later they shared laughs and friendship.

“Adversarial politics didn’t make sense to him,” Punch said the retired sheriff.

Green visited inmates in the county jail and treated them as people, the judge said.

“Dave was a natural leader because he cared about everyone and he had the courage to let them know,” Punch said. “I’ve never met anyone who loved people more than Dave or anyone who was loved by more people than Dave.”

Green became sheriff after serving as the county’s fire coordinator and emergency management director. He led the local response during the Blizzard of ’77.

As sheriff, he pushed to create the Orleans County Major Felony Crime Task Force, which brought together the law enforcement agencies in the county to work on the most serious crimes.

Punch said Green was often at crime scenes and would interview suspects, often securing their confessions through kindness and understanding. He was respected around the state and served as president of the New York State Sheriff’s Association.

The Rev. Kim Smith, former pastor of the Millville United Methodist Church, said he was honored that Green requested Smith lead the funeral service.

Smith used to call Green when he was sheriff to request an escort for a funeral procession from the church to a local cemetery.

Smith praised Green not only for his community service, but for his 64-year commitment to his wife, Jessie. The two dated throughout high school. They have three children, six grandchildren and seven great-grandchildren.

Green attended a one-room schoolhouse before going to the bigger school in Medina. In high school “he became a social butterfly,” Smith said.

He remained very close to the Class of 1961, planning their reunions every five years. He was working on the upcoming 65^th reunion this summer.

Green became a sought after master of ceremonies for fire department banquets, mixing in humor and personal stories about the many firefighters and other volunteers.

“He knew how to interact with people, where others didn’t,” Smith said.

For 25 years Green organized the classic car shows in Medina in the canal basin, including the Super Cruise on Main Street. He had his own classic cars, and he let his grandchildren take them to their senior proms.

Green loved the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company. It was his second home, Smith said. Green was prolific at selling raffle tickets and raising money for the fire company, while also empowering its leadership, including Debbie Taylor as the first woman to be fire chief in the county.

Green took great joy driving an East Shelby fire truck in local parades, especially Medina’s Parade of Lights.

Todd Ralph, Dave Green’s cousin, said Green was a great role model of service to his community and family. Green should go into “The Civic Hall of Fame” for his exceptional service over many decades, ralph said.

“He was a mentor, role model and sounding board who helped me grow personally and professionally,” Ralph said. “No one embodied civic virtue like Dave Green.”

Ralph urged the crowd to “carry Dave’s light” and his example forward.

“He was a humanitarian and a splendid one,” Ralph said. “He was a Western New Yorker and a proud one.”

Two of Dave Green’s grandchildren spoke at the service: Ryan McPherson and Sawyer Green. Ryan is the son of Green’s daughter Lisa and Sawyer is the daughter of Green’s son, Jeff.

The grandchildren shared how their grandfather was a mainstay at their sporting events, concerts and other activities.

Dave and Jessie also gladly welcomed their grandkids and now great-grandchildren to their home on East Shelby Road. The grandfather would joke to them that they were just stopping by for snacks.

Dave loved to cheer on the Buffalo Bills and Syracuse Orange basketball teams. He took the Bills losses hard.

“He was a giant in my life,” Ryan McPherson said.

His grandfather was a man of integrity, who put conviction behind everything he did.

Ryan would join his grandfather at Rudy’s Diner in Medina and it was almost nonstop with people stopping by to shake hands and chat with his grandfather. Ryan, when he was a kid, was surprised to see former jail inmates stop by and thank him for treating them fairly.

Ryan said his grandfather helped teach him to drive, and loved to brainstorm ways to raise funds for the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company, including Ryan’s passion to bring pro wrestling to the community.

“He was a constant presence in my life,” Ryan said. “He always showed up.”

Sawyer Green also praised her grandfather for his presence in his grandchildren’s and great-grandchildren’s lives.

He loved to share jokes and dispense wisdom: “Don’t trouble trouble until trouble troubles you.”

She said her grandfather was a good man and her hero.

At the end of the service, a county dispatcher said the fireman’s last call for Green, who served was a past fire chief and captain of the fire company, as well as the steward for 41 years.

“His love for the East Shelby Fire Company was immeasurable,” the dispatcher said.

He mentored many of the department’s leaders, offering extraordinary friendship and service to the community, the dispatcher said.

The East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company was like a second home to Dave Green, who was a very active member for 65 years.

Other tributes to Green have been posted online at his obituary (click here).

Joe Cardone, retired Orleans County district attorney: “I had the tremendous fortune of working with Dave for several years prior to his retirement. His wisdom and advice guided us through many difficult cases.

As Sheriff he set a benchmark for his successors.  Dave could handle most any difficult situation and he did it with a sense of sincerity and a reassuring smile. He had the respect of the community that he served and he was a beloved role model and educator for the scores of law enforcement officers and firefighters that worked for him.

Despite often dealing with very tragic situations he maintained a great sense of humor. He humbly helped a lot of people throughout his career and made a difference in so many people’s lives. Our community is indebted to Dave for his years of public service and his fund raising for so many charities.  My condolences to the entire family.”

Ron Spike, retired sheriff of Yates County: “Dave was a truly honorable man and community servant and an admired Sheriff. He and Jessie always so welcoming and caring for my Sue when I at a conference meeting. I will always remember his love of ketchup. He had a great smile that said everything without uttering a word. Thank you Dave for your public safety fire, emergency management and law enforcement service. Your contribution to conserving peace will always be remembered. RIP my friend.”

Sue Zinkievich: “We built our house right next to the Greens. They were the best neighbors. I am sad to think he’s gone. He was one of a kind, special man who understood people, great joke teller. Even though I have been gone for 10 years, I still consider them – my East Shelby Family. I love all the Greens! Sending my sympathies to Jesse and the rest of the family rest in peace, Mr. David magnificent Green.”

Arnold Canham: “When the Medina High School Class of 1961 elected David Green as our class President, I doubt we realized back then just how wise our choice was. Here was a regular guy, always smiling, humble and quietly humorous who didn’t ‘make waves.’  In 1965 I moved away, leaving Medina behind and a few years later settled in the Chicago area.

Yet over the years it was always nice to learn about Dave back in Medina taking on responsibility for another activity or quietly guiding a long term function like the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Department. When I learned he was elected Orleans County Sherriff I was not surprised. Why not? Dave was a humble yet caring guy, seemingly a local fixture happily living a comfortable local life.

Years later it felt good to attend class reunions because Dave would be there, still with the smiling personality and quiet jokes. My Mom told me about Sheriff Dave calling when the 1977 major winter storm dumped 3 feet or more of snow on the area. He asked if my dad would use one of his bulldozer machines to help clear the roads. She quoted him as saying, ‘We can settle up later.’ An example of that steady and honorable guy, now in one of his leadership roles getting things done. Somehow, I expect Dave, who went on from high school to accomplish so much, is now ready to quietly help the ‘big guy’ get more things done.”

Photos by Tom Rivers: Gideon Pask is congratulated by Todd Draper, scoutmaster of Troop 28 in Medina, for earning the rank of Eagle Scout. Gideon received the rank during a Court of Honor celebration today at the East Shelby Community Bible Church.

Gideon Pask became an Eagle Scout today.

EAST SHELBY – Gideon Pask, a very busy student at Albion Central School, has earned the highest rank in Boy Scouts. Today, he had a Court of Honor for his Eagle Scout.

Gideon, 18, is the valedictorian at Albion for the Class of 2026. He also is the drum major in the marching band and starred in the school musicals. He also is very active in the school’s chorus and band programs.

“He’s extremely goal-oriented,” said Todd Draper, scoutmaster of Troop 28 in Medina. “If he puts his mind to it, he’ll do it.”

Kids who are busy learn to prioritize and complete their projects, Draper said.

Gideon has made time for Scouting for more than a decade. He initially was part of Troop 175 in Barre until it disbanded.

He completed 28 merit badges, above the required 21 to be an Eagle Scout.

He also completed his community service project at the East Shelby Community Bible Church, adding benches, picnic tables and a sandstone walkway. Gideon has long attended the church, which was led by his grandfather, the late Erik Olsen. Gideon’s uncle Levi is now the pastor.

Gideon follows his brother Eli as an Eagle Scout. Eli earned the rank in 2018. He volunteers as an adult with Troop 28.

“I enjoy the camaraderie,” Gideon said about scouting. “You can meet some of your best friends.”

He said scouts also will have fun camping and will learn first aid, self sufficiency and problem solving, as well as many other skills.

Gideon Pask follows his brother Eli Pask, age 23, as an Eagle Scout. Eli is an adult volunteer with Troop 28. Eli got caught in the afternoon rainstorm before this photo was taken.

The troop is preparing to send 10 scouts and adults volunteers to the Philmont Scout Ranch for 9 days of rugged hiking in the mountains of New Mexico. The group will cover about 50 miles to start the summer.

Gideon will be attending the Rochester Institute of Technology this fall to major in electrical engineering. He would like to stay involved with scouts as an adult volunteer, in particular at high-adventure camps like Philmont.

Gideon Pask is shown as drum major for the Albion Marching Band during Saturday’s Albion Strawberry Festival.

‘He had a knack for communicating with people. As soon as you sat down with him, you felt like you had known him all your life.’ – Sheriff Chris Bourke

Photos by Tom Rivers: David Green is pictured on Aug. 23, 2017 during the Super Cruise on Main Street in Medina. Green organized the car shows in Medina for more than 25 years with proceeds going to the United Way. For many of those years, he teamed with Donna Bushover and Donna Mruczek in putting on the events.

EAST SHELBY – Orleans County is mourning the loss of David Green, a retired sheriff who stayed very busy in retirement as a community volunteer, especially with the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company.

He was a sought after emcee for fire department banquets for decades, well liked for his sense of humor and his ability to also bring a dignified presence to the events.

Green was a rarity in Orleans County: a Democrat elected to a countywide position. He reached across party lines and had an amazing ability to connect with people from all walks of life, whether an inmate in the county jail or high-ranking politicians, said Chris Bourke, the current sheriff.

“He had a knack for communicating with people,” Bourke said. “As soon as you sat down with him, you felt like you had known him all your life.”

Photo from Orleans County Sheriff’s Department: David Green served 20 years  as Orleans County sheriff, retiring after 1998.

Green was sheriff when Bourke was hired in 1984, as a part-time corrections officer making $5.30 an hour. Green would promote him to corporal in the jail, then to a deputy sheriff on Jan. 1, 1986 and later to lieutenant and K9 handler.

Green was elected sheriff in 1978 after serving as the county’s fire coordinator. He brought an ability to work with people and expand the department’s services. He was the Orleans County sheriff for 20 years.

“The department was growing and he knew how to manage his resources,” Bourke said.

Green joined the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company when he was 18. On March 7 he attended the annual banquet and was recognized for 65 years of service to East Shelby. His father Milton was a charter member of the fire company.

Green served as fire chief at East Shelby from 1966 to 1972. In 1970, he was appointed Orleans County emergency manager and in 1972 he took on additional duties as Orleans County fire coordinator, working with 1,600 volunteer firefighters at the time. He was an experienced administrator, as well as an arson investigator.

Bourke said Green, when he was sheriff, built a strong bridge between the Sheriff’s Department and the volunteer fire service.

“Sheriff Green served this county in ways few ever have,” Justin Niederhofer, the county’s current emergency management director, posted on Facebook today. “He gave years of faithful service as a member of the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company, where he was known not just for showing up, but for being all-in — the kind of member every department hopes to build around.”

Green’s career of public service is “truly rare in its breadth and commitment,” Niederhofer said about Green’s roles as director of Emergency Management, County fire coordinator and Orleans County sheriff.

“To follow in someone’s footsteps means something different when you’ve seen the path they walked,” Niederhofer said. “David helped shape the foundation that this office stands on, and that is not something we take lightly.”

In his retirement, he remained an active volunteer with the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company and helped organize East Shelby’s annual swap meet at fairgrounds, which usually raises $5,000 to $10,000 for fire company.

Green for more than 25 years led the car shows in Medina, teaming with Donna Bushover and Donna Mruczek for many of those years. The car shows would draw about 100 cars on a typical Friday.

The “Super Cruise” brings about 200-300 cars when Main Street is closed off and an Elvis impersonator entertains. Green also sells raffle tickets during the Super Cruise with proceeds going to the Orleans County United Way. Green retired as car show organizer after the 2023 season.

For many years he served as the emcee of fire department banquets around the county, mixing in many jokes and gentle ribbing of the firefighters and elected officials in the crowd.

“He was a very friendly guy who had the ability to make everyone feel at home,” Sheriff Bourke said.

David Green, second from left, is presented a “Special Recognition Award” in March 2021 from Orleans County Legislator Bill Eick and an award from the Firemen’s Association of the State of New York by Dale Banker, the county’s emergency management coordinator at the time. Debbie Taylor, the East Shelby fire chief, joined Green at the County Legislature’s chambers for the awards for his 60 years of service with the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company. This award was presented during a time with Covid restrictions when people were encouraged to wear masks in public.

‘The Mayor of East Shelby’

By Ginny Kropf, correspondent

East Shelby Fire Chief Deb Taylor has known Dave Green for more than two decades – 21 of which they served together in the fire service, she said.

“He was more than just a fellow firefighter or a friend – he was family,” Taylor said. “He was the patriarchal of East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company for sure. A lot of people called him the mayor of East Shelby. Well, he was.”

Taylor said Green was the kind of person you could run anything by him without asking him first.

“He was a person you could always count on, regardless of the situation,” she said. “He stood by me through both good and difficult times. I will never forget how he encouraged me to run for fire chief. He often told me how proud he was that I became the first female chief in Orleans County.”

She continued to say Green carried himself with strength, loyalty and compassion, always giving everything he had to ensure others felt support and respected.

“His passing leaves a significant void, but his impact will live on through the lives he touched, the lessons he taught and the memories we all shared,” Taylor said. “I’m going to miss him terribly. I already do.”

Sheriff Bourke praised Green for giving him an opportunity when he hired him as a corrections officer in 1984, and then again on Jan. 1, 1986, when Green hired him as a deputy sheriff.

“I was promoted to lieutenant and assigned as the canine handler in 1987,” Bourke said. “Dave gave me the opportunity to move up through the ranks and be elected sheriff in 2020. I thank him for that.”

Bourke added Green was a kind-hearted person who volunteered a lot of time to the community, including coaching Little League and volunteering with the East Shelby Fire Company.

Photo and information from Shelby Volunteer Fire Department

SHELBY – The Shelby Volunteer Fire Company responded to a motor vehicle accident today involving a vehicle into a pole with poles and wires down at 11:28 a.m. on South Gravel Road (Route 63).

Chief and Engine 10 arrived on scene at 11:29 a.m., with Shelby 81 and Shelby 69 responding to assist with traffic control and arriving within four minutes.

Upon arrival, the Chief confirmed that extrication was needed. Crews on scene stabilized the vehicle and cut the windshield and seatbelt to assist with patient removal. With 13 Shelby members operating on scene, the patient was successfully extricated from the vehicle at 11:35 a.m.

After extrication, Medina Ambulance obtained a patient sign-off.

Later during the incident, Shelby was toned out for a second call involving a reported seizure. Shelby 10 and the Chief responded to the EMS call while the original incident was still in progress.

Nathan Fuller named ‘Firefighter of the Year’

Photos by Ginny Kropf: (Left) Mike Fuller, president of East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company, presented the EMS Award to Nathan Fuller at the installation banquet Saturday night. Fuller was also named “Firefighter of the Year.” (Right) Sue Green, left, and her aunt Debbie Green received certificates for 40 and 45 years of membership, respectively, in the East Shelby Ladies Auxiliary.

EAST SHELBY – The East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company held its annual installation of officers’ banquet Saturday night at the firemen’s recreation hall. Steve Cooley, chief of the Medina Fire Department, served as master of ceremonies.

This was the first banquet since 1974 in which David Green did not serve as master of ceremonies, due to health problems. Green, a 65-year member of the fire company, was also recognized for serving 41-1/2 years as steward of the fire company.

The steward’s duties include arranging for food for meetings, signing up people for use of the hall, making sure the hall is ready for events and many other little things that may come along, Green said.

“The fire company has been a big part of my whole life,” Green said.

(Left) Bronwyn Green, center, poses with Doris Antinore, left, and Gerry Zinkievich, both of whom were recognized for 55 years of membership in the East Shelby Ladies Auxiliary. (Right) Dave Green, who was served East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company as steward for 41-1/2 years, chose the Ladies’ Auxiliary as recipient of the Steward’s Award. Accepting the award are Auxiliary president Bronwyn Green and vice president Leona Weese.

Dave Green joined the fire company on his 18th birthday, making this his 65th year as a member. He said he knew from an early age he would be joining the fire company, as his father Milton was a charter member.

“It was tough sledding in the beginning,” Green said. “In the early days we had to take up a collection from members just to pay the bills. Now we’re in good shape.”

Green has been involved with all the fundraisers through the years, and wishes more young people today would take an interest in volunteering.

“Young people would enjoy becoming a member,” Green said. “Our goal is to work hard with all the other members and see the fire company succeed. Once you join, you’ve got to think it’s the best.”

Officers of the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company were inducted Saturday night by Steve Cooley, chief of the Medina Fire Department.

Mike Fuller, president of the fire company, and Bronwyn Green, president of the ladies’ auxiliary, welcomed guests and shared their memberships were healthy with 61 and 40, respectively. A moment of silence was observed for one auxiliary member who was lost last year – Judy Allen, who had more than 50 years as a member.

Senator Robert Ortt, who had to leave early for another fire department banquet, thanked the members for all they do for the community. He told them they had a terrific advocacy organization working for them in Albany.

“You take care of this community,” Ortt said. “Volunteer firefighters are the norm in New York state. They save taxpayers $4 billion with their volunteer hours.”

In stepping up to emcee the evening’s program for Green, Cooley said he had big shoes to fill.

“I won’t be half as funny as you were,” he told Green.

Fuller announced the fire company had five new members last year.

Members of the ladies auxiliary were installed by Robyn Watts, secretary of the Shelby Ladies Auxiliary.  They are Bronwyn Green, president; Leona Weese, vice president; Sawyer Green, secretary; Mindy Kenward, treasurer; Shirley Printup, Pat Vader and Elaine Newton, trustees; and Rose Allen, chaplain.

Members of the fire company installed by Cooley were Mike Fuller, president; Kirk Zinkievich, vice president; Karen Bracey, secretary; Allen Turner, treasurer; and Dennis MacDonald, Norm Behrend and Alan Lonnen, trustees.

Firematic officers were Deb Taylor, chief; Devin Taylor, 1st assistant chief; Andy Beach, 2nd assistant chief; Jeff Taylor, 3rd assistant chief, Jared Zinkievich, captain; Josh Fuller, lieutenant; Steve Wolters, fire police chief; and Sue Behrend and Mike Fuller, EMS officers.

(Left) Susan Green received the President’s Award from Bronwyn Green, leader of the Ladies Auxiliary. (Right) Karen Bracey was recipient of the President’s Award, given by Mike Fuller, president of East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company.

Next on the program was presentation of awards and recognition of long-time members.

The first presentation was the President’s Award, given by Mike Fuller to Karen Bracey.

“Karen is somebody who helps me on the back end and spends numerous hours organizing tickets for our fundraisers,” Fuller said.

Mike also presented the EMS Award to Nathan Fuller, who put in a lot of time last year studying to advance his position. He became a Firefighter I and spent more than 200 hours studying for his EMS status.

Deb Taylor gave the Chief’s Award to Dylan Taylor, who she described as dependable and ready to step in when needed. He shows up consecutively when needed and serves with heart, she said.

Dave Green chose to give the Steward’s Award to the Ladies Auxiliary, which he described as the “Best ladies auxiliary in Western New York.”

They number 40 members and regularly have 20 to 30 who attend meetings.

“This award is given to the Ladies Auxiliary in appreciation for your contributions to the East Shelby Fire Company,” Green said.

Later in the program, the auxiliary presented Mike Fuller with a $15,000 check for the fire company. Fuller said that will be a big help in buying equipment.

East Shelby Fire Chief Deb Taylor, left, and president Mike Fuller accept $15,000 from the East Shelby Ladies Auxiliary president Bronwyn Green.

Outgoing  auxiliary secretary Sue Green and treasurer Sharlene Pratt were recognized for their years of service.

Bronwyn Green announced the Service Awards for years of membership, with several receiving special recognition. They were David Green, 65 years; Charlie Ralph, 55 years; Mike Zelazny, 50 years; Alan Turner and Ken McPherson, 40 years; Ron Martin Jr., 35 years; Bob Scharlau, 30 years; Amy Fuller and Laura Fields, 25 years; Matt Grimes, 20 years; Devon Taylor and Sharon Grimes, 15 years; Josh Green, 10 years; and Eli Howard, 5 years.

The East Shelby Ladies’ Auxiliary officers were installed Saturday night by Robyn Watts, secretary of the Shelby Ladies’ Auxiliary.

A special recognition was given to Zelazny with a gift of a firemen’s axe mounted on a plaque. He received proclamations from Senator Robert Ortt, Assemblyman Steve Hawley, Orleans County legislator Bill Eick and FASNY trustee Michael Lipinski, who shared FASNY has one of only two retirement homes for firefighters in the country.

Zelazny joined the fire company Aug. 8, 1975, and has served as president and vice president. He also worked on the bingo team and fundraisers, as well as responding to all emergencies.

Fields and Amy Fuller received proclamations from Ort, Hawley and Eick.

The evening also included a meal catered by Donna Eick and music by DJ JT Thomas of Medina.

Photo courtesy of Alana Koneski: Mike Zelazny, left, was recognized for 50 years of service to the East Shelby Volunteer Fire Company. He was presented a special award by Medina Fire Chief Steve Cooley (master of ceremonies), East Shelby Fire Chief Deb Taylor and East Shelby President Mike Fuller.

Aaron D’Angelo

SHELBY – A 36-year-old Medina man has been charged with murder and attempted murder after two brothers were stabbed today in Shelby.

Aaron D’Angelo allegedly caused the death of Dale R. Lang, 65, who was pronounced deceased at the scene, 4643 South Gravel Road (Route 63).

His brother John Lang, 67, also suffered multiple stab wounds and was transported to Medina Memorial Hospital and then Erie County Medical Center. His condition is currently unknown, Sheriff Chris Bourke stated in a press release sent at about 8:30 p.m.

The Orleans County Sheriff’s Office responded to a reported 911 disturbance at the above address at 11:55 a.m.

Upon arrival, Bourke said a Sheriff’s deputy encountered D’Angelo, who was armed with a knife and confronted the deputy. The deputy deployed a Taser, successfully subduing D’Angelo, who was then taken into custody without further incident, Bourke said.

As additional personnel arrived on scene, Dale Lang and John Lang were discovered inside the residence with multiple stab wounds.

D’Angelo has been charged with the following offenses:

• Murder in the Second Degree (Class A-I Felony)
• Attempted Murder in the Second Degree (Class B Felony)
• Assault in the First Degree (Class B Felony)
• Menacing a Police Officer (Class D Felony)
• Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the Fourth Degree (Class A Misdemeanor)

He is currently being held at the Orleans County Jail pending arraignment.

The Orleans County Sheriff’s Office was assisted at the scene by the Medina Police Department, Medina Ambulance, the Shelby Fire Department, and the New York State Police Forensic Identification Unit.

“This incident remains under investigation,” Bourke said. “Anyone with information related to this incident is encouraged to contact the Orleans County Sheriff’s Office.”

SHELBY – A person has died and another seriously injured after two stabbings in Shelby at 4643 South Gravel Rd.

Another man, who allegedly stabbed the other two individuals, is in custody, Sheriff Chris Bourke said.

Law enforcement was dispatched to scene at 11:55 a.m. for report of a disturbance in Shelby Center. The responding deputy encountered an aggressive individual who was covered in blood, Bourke said. The man came at the deputy, who used a taser to try to subdue the man, the sheriff said.

That man remained aggressive, but was able to be put in the back of the police car. He is being interviewed by law enforcement and is now being cooperative, Bourke said.

There were two people inside the house and one was dead from stabbing wounds. Another man suffered more than 20 stabbing wounds, and remains alive but with severe injuries, Bourke said.

The man was transported to Medina Memorial Hospital and then transferred to Erie County Medical Center by ambulance due to mercy Flight being unable to fly its helicopter due to the weather conditions.

Law enforcement remain on scene to process the evidence. Route 63 has been closed between Alabama Road and Oak Street.

The sheriff said a news release will be forthcoming with more details.

‘Job Corps is one of the best bang-for-your-buck programs we have to boost our local economies’

Press Release, U.S. Senate Minority Leader Charles Schumer

Photo by Tom Rivers: This sign on Route 63 in Shelby notes the Iroquois Job Corps. This center has space for up to 225 students who are served by 104 full-time equivalent employees.

After Schumer stood at Job Corps centers across Upstate NY to lead the fight to protect one of the nation’s largest and most effective workforce training programs from Trump’s effort to eliminate it, U.S. Senator Chuck Schumer today announced he has successfully preserved funding for Job Corps and helping students across America, including thousands in New York, get the skills they need to enter in-demand careers.

“Job Corps is one of the best bang-for-your-buck programs we have to boost our local economies, which is why I fought hard to protect it from Trump’s proposed cuts,” said Senator Schumer. “I’m proud to announce that, following my advocacy, we have preserved funding for Job Corps, ensuring the continuation of one of America’s largest and most effective workforce training programs.”

The just-passed Fiscal Year 2026 Labor, Health and Human Services, Education funding bill rejects Trump’s call to eliminate Job Corps and instead provides $1.76 billion in federal funding to keep them open. Schumer also secured language that blocks the closure of Job Corps Centers unless such closures meet specific requirements.

Anand Vimalassery, National Job Corps Association Interim President & CEO said, “Job Corps faced unprecedented disruption and uncertainty over the last year. Through it all, Senator Schumer stood by our students and staff in Calicoon, Cassadaga, Glenmont, Medina, New York City, and Oneonta. His leadership is helping ensure young adults in New York continue to have a pathway into the skilled workforce through Job Corps and we’re grateful for his support.”

In May 2025, Trump paused operations at Job Corps centers nationwide. Afterward, a federal judge temporarily blocked Trump from shutting down Job Corps centers, and another federal judge said operations must resume until the previous case is resolved. Schumer explained that the Trump administration not only attempted to shut down Job Corps centers, but in his budget request, Trump said he wanted to totally zero out funding for the program, effectively killing the program without needing the approval of federal courts.

After hearing about Trump’s proposed cuts, Schumer last year traveled to Job Corps centers across Upstate New York, from the Iroquois Job Corps center in Orleans County to the Cassadaga Job Corps center in Chautauqua County and the Otsego Job Corps Center, to stand with students, staff, and small business owners and demand we protect this vital pipeline for skilled workers to fill jobs.

In addition to fighting back on Trump’s proposed elimination of funds for Jobs Corps in the Fiscal Year 2026 appropriations bill, Schumer led efforts in the Senate to oppose the Trump administration’s destructive and potentially illegal actions like pausing existing funds for the Job Corps centers.

Schumer called on U.S. Department of Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer to protect Job Corps and demanded answers on these destructive efforts. Thanks to Schumer’s leadership, the Fiscal Year 2026 Labor, Health and Human Services, Education funding bill rejects Trump’s call to eliminate Job Corps and instead provides $1.76 billion in federal funding – which is consistent with the previous year – to keep them open and includes language to protect against Trump’s efforts to illegally shut down specific centers.

 “The Iroquois Job Corps Center has been a cornerstone of opportunity in Orleans County for more than sixty years, helping young people gain the skills and credentials they need to succeed while strengthening our local economy,” said Lynne Johnson, Chairman of the Orleans County Legislature. “Preserving funding for Job Corps is critical for our students, our workforce, and our community. Thanks to Senator Schumer, the Iroquois Job Corps Center can continue delivering real pathways to good-paying careers and supporting the next generation of skilled workers.”

Schumer said Job Corps centers have helped millions of young people ages 16 to 24 finish high school, learn technical skills, and get jobs in in-demand fields such as healthcare and construction. Low-income and at-risk young people have received stable housing and healthcare while developing the skills they need to get good-paying jobs after graduation. Across Upstate NY, centers in Albany, Sullivan, Orleans, Otsego, and Chautauqua Counties serve thousands of young New Yorkers and employ over 500 staff.

Genesee would receive $285 million in revenue over 30 years, plus an estimated $18 million in sales tax annually to be split by county and state

Photos by Tom Rivers: Stream U.S. Data Centers held an open house at the Alabama Fire Hall on Monday evening for people to meet members of the development team for the data center. Many of the attendees are concerned about the environmental impacts on the community, including the nearby wildlife refuge and Tonawanda Indian Nation.

ALABAMA – A massive data center proposed for the STAMP site in Alabama, just a few miles south of Orleans County, would bring a major influx of revenue for Genesee County, said officials at the Genesee County Economic Development Center.

Stream U.S. Data Centers would pay $285 million over 30 years to Genesee County, the Town of Alabama and Oakfield-Alabama Center School. (The project also would receive $744 million in tax incentives. The GCEDC board is expected to accept an application from Stream during its board meeting on Thursday. There will be public hearings about the incentives and the site plan for the data center.)

Bradley Wells, site selection and development manager for Stream U.S. Data Centers, speaks to reporters at Monday’s meeting. He said the project uses a relatively small footprint of the STAMP site and won’t generate much traffic after construction. The data center would have 125 employees working different shifts. There would be about 1,000 people working on construction of the data center’s three buildings, each over 700,000 square feet.

The company also will have to pay sales tax on its electricity usage and that is expected to be about $18 million a year to be split by Genesee County and the state.

Stream U.S. Data Centers is proposing to invest over $11 billion in the data center at STAMP. GCEDC gets a fee when it facilitates a project, usually 1.25 percent of the development costs.

With the data center, the fee would be 0.75 percent or about $83 million. That money would help build out public water in Genesee County and with infrastructure at other GCEDC business parks, said Mark Masse, GCEDC president and CEO. Five of the eight GCEDC parks are currently fully occupied but there is space at STAMP, Le Roy and in the Pembroke parks.

“This whole program is generational revenue for Genesee County,” Masse said during an interview on Monday during an informational meeting by Stream at the Alabama fire hall.

The project is outside Orleans County, but Masse and GCEDC officials expect Orleans would see significant benefit for employment and other services for the data center, as well as people looking to move into the community.

The project has faced resistance from Orleans County, including Legislature Chairwoman Lynne Johnson who doesn’t want any wastewater from STAMP to go into the Oak Orchard Creek, which is a major tourism draw for fishing in the county.

STAMP will be using the Village of Oakfield sewer plant for treatment, and Masse said the plant will be upgraded to treat phosphorus.

The Allies of Tonawanda Seneca Nation have been vocal in opposition of the data center, saying it uses enormous amounts of electricity – 500 megawatts – that could impact electricity rates for other customers.

The Allies passed out flyers listing concerns with noise, impacts to wildlife, water usage and pollution, air pollution, e-waste, and other environmental impacts.

Arthur Barnes of Shelby was among the attendees at Monday’s meeting. He wore a “Stop STAMP” button. Barnes would have preferred to hear a presentation from the developer to the group, but instead Stream had people meet one on one or in small groups. Barnes said the presentation was “too slick” and didn’t consider the impacts of the project on the community.

Bradley Wells, site selection and development manager for Stream, said the meeting format was a chance to “have one on one time with developer.”

The new data center would be “unique and premium in the market,” he told reporters at the meeting.

The data center helps meet a need with the “growth of internet, growth of interconnectivity, subscription streaming and artificial intelligence,” he said.

The STAMP site is attractive for Stream because it offers all of the existing infrastructure –with electricity, water and waste water. Wells said the facility would use “very minimal water” and would operate on a closed loop air cooling system.

There are very restrictive noise requirements, and Wells said the site would operate at 65 decibels at day and 45 decibels at night from the Stream property lines. The noise would be quieter farther away from the site. Wells said 65 decibels is similar to the sound when talking in a room and 45 decibels is the sound of a quiet office environment.

Stream U.S. Data Centers showed renderings of how a vacant field at STAMP could be turned into a large data center.

The company, based in Dallas, Texas, will need to get through an environmental review with the GCEDC the lead agency. The Allies of the Seneca Nation, Orleans County and others wanted the state Department of Environmental Conservation to lead that review. Barnes said the GCEDC role “is like the fox guarding the hen house.”

Wells said Stream strives to build a long-lasting partnership with the community. The company is hopeful construction could start in 2026 with the facility to begin operations in 2027, although a full buildout is expected to take until 2030.

He foresees “1,000 continuous trade jobs” during the construction. Once that is complete, the traffic impact from the data center would be “extremely low,” Wells said, with 125 employees working different shifts, many of them software specialists and engineering technicians.

Other manufacturing at STAMP could see many more employees and deliveries, with a much bigger impact on traffic in the community, he said.

Stream would operate on 90 acres out the 1,250 acres at STAMP.

“We think it’s one of the most dense, best uses of the park right now,” Wells said.

Retired DA Joe Cardone pitches his property in Shelby for massive project

File photo by Tom Rivers: A massive data center, totaling 2.2 million square feet, could be headed to the STAMP site off Route 63 in the town of Alabama.

 ALABAMA – The leader of the Orleans County Legislature is asking the state Department of Environmental Conservation to be the lead agency for an environmental review of a proposed data center at the STAMP site in Alabama, just south of Orleans County.

Lynne Johnson, chairwoman of the County Legislature, said in her Jan. 16 letter that the Genesee County Economic Development Center would be “biased” in the review of Project Double Reed and it would be better to have the environmental impact review conducted by the state Department of Environmental Conservation, not the GCEDC. Johnson sent the letter to DEC Commissioner Amanda Lefton.

GCEDC has fired back with its own letter to the commissioner and also Regional Director Timothy Walsh, claiming the Orleans opposition is based on “sour grapes” because Orleans wanted the project in Shelby, not Genesee County.

GCEDC also said Orleans has been unable to secure larger-scale projects and tried to thwart Genesee County from running a sewer transmission line from STAMP to Oak Orchard Creek in Shelby to derail development of STAMP. GCEDC has decided to use the sewer plant in Oakfield, with the discharged water still ultimately going into the Oak Orchard.

Adam S. Walters of the Phillips Lytle LLP law firm sent the letter on behalf of the GCEDC on Monday, and cited several procedural errors in Johnson’s letter that should make it invalid. Among the five cited: the letter wasn’t sent by certified mail or other form of receipted delivery (instead by email).

The letter also didn’t have the backing of the full legislature because there was no formal resolution from the County Legislature, Walters said.

Orleans County also isn’t an “involved agency” for for the proposed data center as it “will not fund, approve or directly undertake Project Double Reed,” Wash writes. GCEDC considers Orleans County as an “interested agency” due to STAMP’s proximity to the Orleans/Genesee County line and sewer infrastructure planned to run from STAMP into Orleans County.

Walters said that Johnson’s letter “has no effect” since the GCEDC staked its claim to serve as lead agency more than 30 days ago and that “the NYSDEC itself did not challenge GCEDC’s declaration of intent.”

“It appears that the objections in the Johnson Letter do not stem from any legitimate environmental concerns but rather result from GCEDC refusing to push Project Double Reed to locate in Orleans County rather than at STAMP,” Walters said.

GCEDC first stated it would be lead agency for Project Double Read about a year ago. At the time the $6.3 billion project was proposed at 900,000 square feet and it would have paid $218.4 million to municipalities in revenue over 20 years. The data center now is proposed to be more than double that initial plan.

The initial declaration by GCEDC to be lead agency in the environmental review was rescinded when the project changed to a 2.2 million-square-foot data center consisting of three two-story buildings. It would be on approximately 90 acres at STAMP with another 40 acres to be utilized as temporary construction/logistics areas.

Johnson, in her letter, said no businesses are currently operating at STAMP despite years of public investment in the site. (Edwards Vacuum is building a 250,000-square-foot manufacturing site at STAMP, a $319 million project that is part of the semi-conductor industry.)

“Under GCEDC’s stewardship, STAMP has been nothing more than a series of unfulfilled promises, questionable allocation of resources and a series of environmental pollution events so significant that this Agency and the Federal government revoked its permits,” Johnson said.

GCEDC holds a “biased position,” Johnson said,  to “justify the fact that it has spent almost $500 million of taxpayer dollars is to jump start a project — any project — regardless of its environmental impact.”

Her letter said the data center would have a negative impact on air quality, energy usage, water usage and wastewater disposal.

GCEDC responded that Johnson is way off on claiming $500 million in taxpayer dollars for STAMP. The number represents the total investment so far at the site, and most of that has been private contributions, GCEDC said.

“Accordingly, the motivations for Orleans County’s objection appear to be based on so called ‘sour grapes’ regarding failed efforts to secure a multi-billion dollar project and past litigation defeats rather than an honest concern about GCEDC serving as lead agency,” Walters wrote in his letter.

Joe Cardone has proposed his 284 acres of land off Route 63 in Shelby be considered for a large-scale data center.

Walters, the GCEDC attorney, said Johnson’s letter may be an effort to steer the data center into Orleans County. Joe Cardone, the retired district attorney for Orleans, met with the GCEDC on December 18 to pitch his property for the data center. Walters said Cardone is trying to “poach” the project so it can be on his property.

GCEDC, in its letter to the DEC officials, included information provided by Cardone to the GCEDC on why he sees his site as a superior location.

Cardone said it would be away from the Tonawanda Indian Reservation and the wildlife management areas, sensitive sites that many detractors say make STAMP a bad fit for such a large development project.

Cardone, in his presentation to GCEDC, cited other benefits of the site in Shelby:

• “downstream” from all environmentally concerning areas
• not bordered by sensitive Native American properties
• only 5 miles due north of STAMP and 11 miles north of NYS Thruway
• closer to Niagara Falls hydropower plant
• close proximity to major utilities in Medina, including sewage disposal plant
• within 2 miles of industrial development facility in Orleans County (Medina Business Park)
• seismically stable property
• existing 100-acre excavated stone quarry to serve as cooling station for “closed loop” system
• located in sparsely population area
• limestone material ad concrete plant at location for construction
• access to facility on four roads (Route 63, Ryan, Blair and Salt Works roads)
• noise less of a factor with currently operating stone quarry
• minimal impact on environmental concerns or farming
• more amenities available with the village of Medina just comfortably 3 miles to the north
• results of reclamation of existing stone quarry
• elimination of disposal into Oak orchard Creek

GCEDC said Cardone’s land would be years away from securing the needed infrastructure and approvals to make the site a possibility for such a development.

Johnson spoke about the letter and response from GCEDC after today’s Legislature meeting. She said she supports the development of STAMP but doesn’t want the sewer discharges harming the Oak Orchard Creek, which is a valuable asset in the county, particularly for fishing, the county’s top tourism draw.

The buildout of STAMP would have many positive ripple effects for Orleans County, she said, bringing more residents to the area for housing, businesses and other economic activity.

She said she was aware Cardone was presenting his land as an option for the data center and she said that is his right as a landowner, but it hasn’t formally been presented to the board of the Orleans Economic Development Agency as an option.

Cardone said the land is Shelby is a better location for the data center than STAMP, which borders a Native American reservation and wildlife management areas.

Updated at 11:22 a.m. on Jan. 28

Lynne Johnson, the County Legislature chairwoman, sent this statement about GCEDC’s response to her letter on Jan. 16:

“My job as Chairman of the Orleans County Legislature is to look out for the best interests of our community.  In this instance, that means protecting Oak Orchard Creek which, given past history, is why we objected to GCEDC serving as lead agency for the purported data center project at STAMP.  Our sole interest is in protecting the natural resources of Orleans County.  Any insinuation that we are attempting to poach this data center project is categorically false and a red herring put forth to discount our legitimate environmental concerns.”

Photos by Ginny Kropf: Andy Benz presided at the installation of officers of the Shelby Volunteer Fire Company.

Orleans County Clerk Nadine Hanlon installed officers of the Shelby Volunteer Fire Company’s Ladies Auxiliary Saturday night.

Hunter Sturtevant, left, and Zach Petry presented David Moden with a chief’s hard hat for his years of service.

MEDINA – Shelby Volunteer Fire Company and Auxiliary welcomed members and guests to their 57th annual installation of officers banquet Saturday night.

Jason Watts served as master of ceremonies, while his father Howard Watts and Auxiliary president Elaine Watts welcomed guests. The evening began with invocation and memorial service by chaplain Karl Haist Jr. Haist reported they had lost six members during 2025 – Tom Fuller, Jim Watts, Fred Filipowicz, Charles “Huck” Fuller, Edward Pray and Elroy Fuller.

The fire company also reported seven new members were added during 2025.

Andy Benz was the installing officer for the fire department. He said he considered the job as an honor.

“A few of the names stick out tonight,” Benz said. “In the past I had given out five chief’s awards and all five of them are still here tonight, and still dedicated.”

Fire company officers installed are president, Kirk Myhill; vice president, Howard Watts; treasurer, Tyler Root; assistant treasurer, Michael Saladeen; secretary, Kali Sturtevant; sergeant-at-arms, Dale Watts; chaplain, Karl Haist Jr.; assistant chaplain, Phil Keppler; and steward, Gary Watts.

Also, trustees – Nick DiCureia, for three years; Ron Smith, two years; and Bill Luckman, one year.

Firematic officers are chief, Zachary Petry;  deputy chief, Hunter Sturtevant; assistant chief, Joe Kyle; firematic captain, Marcus Watts; firematic lieutenant, Alex Benz; EMS captain, Jake Quackenbush; and EMS lieutenant, Donnell Bennett.

County Clerk Nadine Hanlon installed Ladies Auxiliary members: president, Elaine Watts; vice president, Brianna Wheeler; secretary, Robyn Watts; treasurer, Lori Myhill; chaplain, Marian Fry; and trustees for one year, Sherry Wheatley; and two years, Mary Herbert.

Elaine Watts, left, president of the Shelby Ladies’ Auxiliary, presented flowers to dedicated members Lori Myhill, Robyn Watts and Marian Fry.

The presentation of special awards began with Howard Watts recognizing David Moden for 34 years of active duty. Moden was also presented with a chief’s hard hat by Hunter Sturtevant and Zach Petry.

Andrea Benz received the President’s Award for stepping up to work on the bylaws and chairing the Christmas party, while completing her teaching degree and planning a fall wedding.

“I can see her being a future president,” Howard said.

The Chief’s Award was presented to Mark Reigle, for consistently leading with his willingness to step up and serve.

Elaine Watts, president of the Ladies Auxiliary, said it was hard to single out one recipient for an award. Instead, she presented flowers to Lori Myhill, Robyn Watts and Marian Fry and announced she would take all the ladies out to eat.

(Left) Howard Watts, left, presents a certificate to Kirk Myhill for 50 years of membership to the Shelby Volunteer Fire Company. (Right) Jason Watts, left, and his father Howard Watts are ready to greet guests at Shelby Volunteer Fire Company’s 57th annual installation of officers banquet Saturday night. Jason served as master of ceremonies, while Howard welcomed guests.

Moden recapped the fire company’s activity in 2025, announcing their 240 calls was fewer than in recent years. Fifty-one percent of the calls were EMS and 16 percent were mutual aid.

Moden also recognized the top 10 responders for 2025. They are Zach Petry, 75% or 181 calls; Moden, 75%; Howard Watts, 67%; Chris Stacewich, 63%; Jake Quackenbush, 52%; Hunter Sturtevant, 47%; Ed Quackenbush, 44%; John Rotoli, 43%; Alex Benz, 41% and Donnell Bennett, 36%.

For his efforts, Petry will receive an embroidered jacket.

“This level of commitment doesn’t happen by accident,” Moden said.

Moden also reported the fire company had received a $95,000 AFG grant last year which will be used to install vehicle exhaust stations. This year they plan to apply for a $300,000 grant to purchase new turnout gear.

Rounding out the evening was dinner catered by The Hilltop in Lockport and music by Beamin’ Sounds.

Members of the Shelby Volunteer Fire Company’s Ladies Auxiliary take the oath of office that was administered by County Clerk Nadine Hanlon.

OCCS expects to move to location to start next school year

Photos by Ginny Kropf: Krista Lawson, standing, teaches all subjects to first-, second- and third-graders, in addition to teaching Bible and acting as school nurse at Orleans County Christian School. Two of her students are Zavina Wright, 7, and Isabella DeVore, 6. Lawson is the wife of Kevin Lawson, pastor of The Vine Church on Maple Ridge Road.

This is the former Shelby Baptist Church on Allegany Road in Shelby Center. The church, an adjoining cafeteria and a brick building have been donated to the Orleans County Christian School, which plans to start the 2026 school year there.

MEDINA – The Orleans County Christian School is about to make a monumental move, which they hope will propel them far into a successful future.

Now located in Alabama Full Gospel Fellowship Church on South Gravel Road, the church is planning a move to the former Shelby Baptist Church, which has been donated to the school.

“God has opened a remarkable door for OCCS,” said Dawn Zaidel, principal and acting administrator, in a press release last week. “A new building has been donated, positioning us for growth, sustainability and increased community impact.”

“OCCS already has a strong foundation and a rich legacy of faith,” said Ayesha Kreutz, who was recently hired as administrator.  “Now we get to be part of the next chapter of this story, strengthening what God began and building toward the future He is preparing.”

The church/school complex in Shelby Center, formerly the Shelby Baptist Church, was donated to the Pastors’ Aligned for Community Transformation (PACT), which donated it to the Christian school.

Orleans County Christian School had its beginnings in October 1993, when the Rev. Tim Lindsay organized a steering committee of individuals with a heart for Christian education. Present were the Rev. Lindsay, Rev. David Vetter, Rev. Randy Anson, Rev. Chris Johnson, Curt Strickland, Curt Follman, Mark Irwin, Vanche Hedley and Dr. William Bellavia.

From that meeting, they sent a county-wide survey to see how much community interest there was. The steering committee continued to meet for three years until, in 1996, the Orleans County Christian School opened its doors on Sept. 4. It began with 13 students, one full-time teacher and one part-time teacher. The school was initially located at Harvest Christian Fellowship in Albion.

After five years, the school moved to Calvary Tabernacle Assembly of God in Medina’s old high school, where they were given use of the northeast wing of the first floor, along with the cafeteria, auditorium and gymnasium. After 17 years there, they were forced to move again when the building was sold, and Alabama Full Gospel Fellowship on Route 63 north of Shelby Center became their new home.

“Pastor Russ Peters and his congregation have welcomed us with open arms, but we are excited about our move once again to a new home,” Zaidel said. “We are also excited about the possibilities for growth at our new location. Orleans County Christian School’s purpose was, and still is, to provide young people with the tools and environment they need to attain the highest level of academic achievement and Christian character.”

Students and teachers frequently gather in the Community Room at Orleans County Christian School. Here, from left, are Mary Hollenbeck, an all-around teacher, GED instructor or adviser on hybrid or distance learning; Dawn Zaidel, principal and English and history teacher; a 10th grade hybrid student; Ayesha Kreutz (standing), newly hired administrator; and students Levi, 13, and Jayden 11.

Zaidel said the school won’t be moving until next September. They have to convert the new church into a dual-purpose gymnasium and community center. The cafeteria is housed in the low wood building which connects the church and brick building on the north, which will house the classrooms.

“It is amazing when God pours out,” Zaidel said. “It’s never something small.”

Kreutz is excited about her new position and what she can bring to the school.

Her background is in classical Christian education, fundraising and organizational turnaround, which she is confident will help strengthen the school’s academics, expand student programs and build on the incredible foundation of this school’s history. As administrator, Kreutz will work as a consultant specializing in grant writing, program development and organizational strategy.

“I bring a blend of administrative leadership, curriculum development, community engagement, fundraising and long-range strategic planning,” Kreutz said. “We are on a mission to keep Christian education alive in Orleans County and investing in a legacy that will serve families for generations. I want to be part of raising up citizens with good character, who have a love of learning, family and community, and are prepared for life, wherever that might lead them. We need to invest in our youth so they will stay here and build this community, not just leave the first chance they get.”

Sophia Standish, standing, is working with Abigail Smith, a new student at the Orleans County Christian School.

The Orleans County Christian School is supported by Harvest Christian Fellowship, Albion; Calvary Tabernacle Assembly of God, Medina; Faith Alliance Church, Albion; First Baptist Church of Holley;

Oak Orchard Assembly of God and Alabama Full Gospel Fellowship, Medina; Light of Victory Church, Albion; and Faith Covenant Fellowship, Medina.

The parent of a former student shared this testimonial: “This is an awesome school that takes time for one- on-one learning and really cares about the kids. My daughter has gone there for almost 7 years.”

The Orleans County Christian School accepts children from pre-school through 12th grade. This is the first year for preschoolers and they are filled to their capacity of seven children.

Michael Zaidel, school nurse and member of the Christian school board, said most parents don’t realize they can get busing to and from our school if they live within 15 miles of the school. They currently have students registered from Royalton/Hartland, Albion, Holley, Oakfield, Lyndonville and Batavia. Several students are driven in by their parents, he said.

The school is also able to offer students participation in BOCES, and busing is provided, Dawn Zaidel said.

The school plans to use the brick building on the north for the classrooms. The church building is planned to become into a dual-purpose gymnasium and community center. The cafeteria will be housed in a low wood building which connects the church and brick building.

Kreutz said they are looking at additional opportunities for students at the school.

“The kids want to start a Club America,” Dawn said.

“It is student-run and encourages kids to develop different service projects in the community,” Kreutz said.

Dawn said when she was asked to fill in as administrator, the first thing she did was brainstorm on how they could get more students enrolled.

“We have gone from eight to 20 students,” she said. “Our capacity is 37. I am a firm believer if we can get a child from the beginning, he will stay. Our parents are overjoyed we are able to now accept preschoolers.”

The Orleans County Christian School depends heavily upon donations, and anyone wishing to donate to the school may make a one-time donation of any amount or pledge a monthly gift by logging on to www.orleanscountychristianschool.com; or mailing a check to OCCS, P.O. Box 349, Medina, 14103. Donations can also be made through Venmo:@occsschool.