Editor:

Before the year ends I would like to recognize some people that deserve praise from the local Conservative Party and that would include Town Supervisor Joe Sidonio from Murray for cutting taxes 2 years in a row. Promises made, promises kept.

Senator Rob Ortt again this year has been given a 100% rating by the State Conservative Party. Good job, senator.

Orleans County Legislator Don Allport’s conservative values have come alive this year on many issues. Common sense key votes like voting against a budget that raises taxes and a pay raise that is out of touch with the economic times are what we like to see. Good job, Legislator Allport.

Happy New Year to all.

Paul Lauricella

OC Conservative Party chairman

Editor:

It’s time again to discuss dissolving the Village of Holley. Why shouldn’t the Village of Holley and Town of Murray merge to provide a more efficient use of taxpayers’ dollars?

I grew up in the Town of Webb, not the Village of Old Forge. The Town of Greece used to be the largest Town by population in NY!

There are synergies to be taken advantage of for the betterment of all.

John Beckingham

Holley

Editor:

This past year was certainly one for the books, though the reasons 2021 was so notable aren’t necessarily worth celebrating.

Our governor resigned in disgrace, more of the businesses we love in our communities shuttered, taxes increased, prices increased and we passed a budget that cost us more than ever. All while doing less than ever to actually help working families.

Throughout, we have also continued to contend with a pandemic that has worn on our economy and the fortitude of New Yorkers across the state, as some in government yet again consider mandates and lockdowns that would assuredly take a tremendous toll on our collective recovery.

I say this not to elicit feelings of doom or gloom but out of a hope, that by recognizing the mistakes made in state government this year, we can work together to rectify them and put our state on a path toward growth.

The circumstances we face have often been described as “unprecedented,” so given the challenges before us, I feel that we have an opportunity to work collaboratively to deliver solutions many in the Legislature haven’t given a fair shake in the past.

To put it simply, I believe that the best way of fostering prosperity here in New York state is to unleash the power of its people by staying out of the way of their success. By creating a business climate that will attract the brightest minds our nation has to offer, and that will retain the talents we have. More than anything, we need to give people a reason to believe New York’s brightest days are still ahead.

Perhaps, most important, we must also ensure that people feel safe living and starting families here. To do so we must give our law enforcement and judiciary the tools they need to protect our neighborhoods. The end of the decay of our villages, towns and cities will begin with the rescinding of our state’s dangerous bail reform laws.

These changes have tied the hands of our judges and empowered criminal elements to act with impunity, knowing that they will be released back onto the streets, even if they’re apprehended. In 2022, we must collectively recognize that bail reform was a mistake and restore law and order throughout New York.

Here in New York we’ve tried raising taxes, we’ve tried heavy-handed mandates and we’ve tried various police “reforms,” all to the detriment of our state’s public safety and prosperity. If there was ever a time for a change to give New Yorkers a chance to chase their dreams and lift up their communities in the process, that time is now.

This year, let’s give New Yorkers a chance to control their own destinies, put an end to one-size-fits-all mandates and empower individuals and local governments to do what’s best for their families and the municipalities they know and love.

New Yorkers are the toughest and most industrious people in this entire country and they deserve a legal and economic climate that will allow them to unleash what they’re capable of onto the national and global marketplace. This year let’s make New York work for those who seek to better their lives and communities through hard work.

Assemblyman Steve Hawley

Batavia

Hawley represents the 139th District, which consists of Genesee, Orleans and parts of Monroe County.

Editor:

‘Twas the night before Christmas, and all through the house,

Not a creature was stirring, not even a mouse,

My laptop was open, I looked down and stared

Time to write this poem, the paper was still bare.

The children were grown up, moved out on their own,

But with the holidays here, they’d surely be home.

With my wife in her flannels, enjoying the bliss

Kathie wrapped some presents, while I worked on this.

When out on the lawn, there rose such a clamor

I forgot about the rhymes, the poem and the grammar,

Away to the window I flew like a flash,

And for the umpteenth time, fell flat on my a–.

The moon on the puddle of the new fallen rain

Gave credence to the theory, the climate had changed

When what to my wondering about the outside flap,

Apparently the neighbors’ dog, was just takin’ a crap.

Not far from Bowser, near the edge of the lawn

Were eight tiny reindeer … and one little fawn.

With a little old driver so lively and quick,

Bent over and heaving, I knew he was sick

More rapid than eagles the yard-cookies spewed

The optics were wretched, such a horrible view,

He got out a phone and made frantic calls,

He needed a doctor, so he called them all

“Now Oz and Phil, calling Kildare and Ben Casey,”

The little fat guy was dialing like crazy.

I pulled up the window, “What can I do?”,

He looked up and yelled, “I think it’s the flu.”

“I’ve been very busy, burdened with tasks”

“But such selfish people, who won’t wear their masks.”

And then with a smile, he took a last heave,

And cleaned off his beard with a swipe of his sleeve.

Then up to the roof top, did ol’ Santa bound,

With gifts in his bag, moonlight around,

His eyes how they twinkled, his color so ashen

But he kept on going, a heart full of passion,

He went straight to work, but different this time,

He lowered the presents on a simple clothesline.

Being real cautious and considerate of others,

Lest he infect the children, their dads and their mothers.

I rushed down the stairs, to help with his chores,

Went to the fireplace and saw gifts on the floor,

I untied the rope and sent back the tether,

Up the chimney it swept, as light as a feather,

Atop the gifts was an envelope to open,

A special message left, Santa had spoken

It was meant for all, for every family and house

I sensed it was something that Santa espoused,

So I opened the letter and felt warm and proud,

It was touching and honest, I’ll read it aloud:

“My dear friends I love you, but things have turned,

What you do to each other, has got me concerned,

Where cooperation and compromise once existed,

It’s sad to see, how it’s gotten so twisted,

Your hate, the vitriol, it’s all over the place,

The anger you have is all over your face,

Where is the tenderness, the caring of yore,

That would bring you together in the years before?

What has happened to you, to cause such a split

Surely not just the Covid, is the reason for it.

There was a time, when you’d all come together

To fight this disease, dissent and whatever.

I see that no more, it’s all push and shove,

So try this Christmas, to spread and give love,

Let it fill the emptiness, let it make you whole,

Let it ease the weariness and soothe your soul.

Do that my friends, and I promise you’ll rally.

Merry Christmas to all!” — and that’s … straight from the Valley.

Tom Valley

Medina

Editor:

With the holidays in full swing and the year shortly coming to a close, I would like to share some good news with you from our state Capitol. Unfortunately, there has been so much negative news this year with scandals from the previous administration, Covid-19 uncertainty and fatigue, and the adverse effects of so called “bail reform,” but it’s important to share some bipartisan results with you because there are a number of positive changes that will benefit Western New York.

First and foremost, I am proud to have pushed for the Commission to Prevent Childhood Drowning. This bill (A.7734) will study how more children can have access to swimming lessons and help our state find more ways to prevent childhood drownings, making our beaches, pools and even bathtubs safer. This was an idea I had early this year, initially sponsoring the original bill (A.6141) and then I worked with Assemblywoman Stacey Pheffer Amato from Queens on revisions for her to introduce this new bipartisan legislation. It passed both houses of the Legislature unanimously and will ultimately save lives for decades to come.

Next, the Erie Canal Recreationway Commission is a statutory body made up of key stakeholders in economic, tourism and historical preservation to protect and enhance the Erie Canal. The law allowed meetings to be called by the chairperson and the commission has not met since 2017. It was frustrating to these stakeholders that meetings were not being held. So, I co-sponsored legislation which will require that these meetings must be held on a quarterly basis and this bill passed both houses and has been signed into law by Gov. Hochul. This is good news for all of our canal communities so a collaborative approach can continue for our historic gem.

There is also good news for our agriculture community. As many farmers know, I have been working hard to protect against the overtime wage threshold reduction, but I also am pleased to see the proposed expansion of the Nourish New York program happen this year (A.5781) and co-sponsor legislation that was recently enacted into law to provide tax breaks for historic barns (A.6947). Agriculture is the backbone of our state’s economy, and quite literally the landscape of our state. Protecting this landscape and this industry remains a top priority for me.

Some other key bills I supported include the creation of a women veterans’ advisory board (A.1140), better protecting against household fires started by unsafe flame retardants through passage in both houses of the Family and Firefighter Protection Act (A.5418-B) and allowing for a compassionate caregiver at nursing homes (A.1052). We also enacted safe-staffing measures at both hospitals and nursing homes (A.108 and A.7119).

This year, we also saw some key state investment projects completed, including the Olcott Breakwall and Wilson Pier as part of the Resiliency Economic Development Initiative along Lake Ontario, the first step toward cleaning up the North Adam Street Lift Bridge and the beautiful restoration of the Palace in Lockport

Our community also pulled together for another successful Winter Clothing Drive and a special Peanut Butter and Jelly summer drive that I proudly sponsored. Thank you so much to all those who participated. This effort will help so many in need.

Finally, the highlight of 2021 as your Assembly representative was the opportunity to honor and recognize over 50 hometown heroes who stepped up in so many different ways during the Covid-19 pandemic. These volunteers, nurses, essential workers and businesses represent the very best of Western New York and truly left a lasting impression that goodness will always shine through difficult times.

There is so much more, but these are just some of the efforts I have made this year to represent you to make our state and region a better place.  As your voice in state government, I am working for you and here to help. Please do not hesitate to reach out if I can be of assistance, and please accept my best wishes for a very Merry Christmas and a happy, healthy and prosperous New Year.

Assemblyman Michael Norris

Lockport

Editor:

The Associated Press has once again provided evidence that voter fraud is minuscule. But let’s be honest, Republicans are not interested in factual evidence.

Remember President Trump’s voter integrity committee in 2018 failed to find evidence of wide spread voter fraud. After the 2020 election, in over 60 court cases, there was no evidence of widespread voter fraud.

William Barr, President Trump’s Attorney General, stated on Dec 1, 2020 that there was no widespread voter fraud.

This past week the Associated Press (12/14/21) reported on a month’s long comprehensive review of votes cast in five swing states – Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin – and found very little fraud; way too little to change election results.

In the five states there was more than 25.5 million votes cast, Joe Biden won by more than 311,000 votes and in those five states the AP found less than 475 cases total of fraud or irregularities.

There is no evidence and there has never been any evidence of widespread voter fraud, but that is not the point. Republicans use this ether, this thin disguise, of voter fraud to pass legislation that will allow them to overturn free and fair elections without providing evidence.

Pew Charitable Trust reported (7/28/21): “Republican lawmakers this year passed an unprecedented bevy of bills targeting the authority of state and local election officials, a power grab that might allow partisan legislators to overturn future election results by claiming there was fraud.”

This claim, by Republicans, of voter fraud and stolen election, drove hundreds of people to try and overturn the democratic process of a peaceful transfer of power. What Republicans could not achieve by physical violence on Jan. 6th they are trying to achieve by the violence of lies and deceit.

The Declaration of Independence states that it is self-evident that government is only legitimate if it has the consent of the governed. Republicans, using lies and deceit of voter fraud, are passing laws to prevent votes they disagree with from counting. This Republican lie of voter fraud is being used to threaten and overthrow our democracy.

William Fine

Brockport

Editor:

Countries are locking down over Omnicron. They are excluding people from any close contact public activity without vaccine passports. Like in our Constitution securing public health is an over-riding mandate. Public health trumps personal liberty and sometimes religion.

The difference here is no one who is arguing against vaccination is doing the math.

Delta Covid kills 20 times what the flu kills of the  unvaccinated but virtually no one who is vaccinated. It seems we are not concerned about Omnicron as it kills the unvaccinated about half, 0.5, and of the vaccinated about nil but many do need the hospital.

The key is we know already Omnicron spreads 3 to 4 times faster!

4 x 0.5 x 20 = twice number of unvaccinated dead compared to flu. 4 times x the number of vaccinated needing hospitalization = 4 times as many beds for vaccinated.

I do not have the bed space requirements for flu but it is a so what? Just Omnicron doubles the number unvaccinated dead due to increased transmission rates.  Add it up and it requires 8 times the bed space all on its own.

That is why surgeries are being cancelled and medical ethicists are debating who should get the beds or how to decide who should be allowed to die due to lack of hospital capacity.

The difference between many of our politicians and anti-vaxers is they forget that this is not a freedom issue but one that simply depends on the math of public health and its resources.

Play with the estimates all you want. Not getting vaccinated is going to kill you or at the least result in several others dying because of your choice.

Eighth grade math is not part of some deep state conspiracy. Get as weirded out as you can delude yourself about  government and hospitals and pseudo science. But in the end, casket production is simple supply and demand.

Boom.

Conrad F. Cropsey

Albion

Editor:

On December 9, 2021 the Administrative Law Judges on the Heritage Wind case ruled in their Recommended Decision that six proposed turbines in Barre do not need to be removed from the project!

The ruling was based on Heritage Wind having provided the burden of proof that was needed to support this finding based on other projects in New York State, peer reviewed studies, and other cases around the Country. I would like to commend the judges for their sound decision making on this matter.

Many residents have worked hard to make this project happen in our Town and it would be shameful if the Office of Renewable Energy Siting took 20% of this project away based on arbitrary reasoning that was brought to the case in the eleventh hour.

I am urging ORES to approve the Heritage Wind project as contemplated in the Draft Permit with all 33 turbine locations. Heritage Wind will reduce our Town taxes, help generational farms stay in operation, and help our State reach its necessary climate goals of 70% renewables by 2030.

Chris Loss

Barre

Editor:

As the former owner and operator of our family farm, I know firsthand that running a farm or an agribusiness is a uniquely challenging undertaking, and if we fail to recognize how these businesses operate in the real world, it will be the death knell for family farms in New York state.

I say this because recently many have called for farm worker overtime to be reduced from the 60-hour threshold established by the Farm Laborers “Fair” Labor Practices Act in 2019 to 40 hours.

As well-intentioned as this idea may sound, this demand comes from a lack of understanding regarding how farms and agribusinesses actually operate. If it were implemented, I fear the only farms that could afford to comply would be large, corporate-operated ones, as the family farms we know and love in our communities would be driven out of business.

To give insight as to why this could happen, simply put, agricultural work isn’t a 9-to-5 job. Farms operate on schedules that are at the mercy of Mother Nature. During the planting and harvest season, it’s often necessary to work from sunrise to sunset, while other seasonal periods could warrant fewer hours of work. This proposal fails to acknowledge this reality, as well as the broader consequences that could arise from decreasing this threshold. We don’t have the luxury of having 12 months of growing and harvesting seasons, we are not Florida or California!

If we begin to lose our farms, which already face many competitive disadvantages compared to out-of-state competitors, farm workers, in turn, will lose their jobs. When that happens, they may very well seek opportunities working for competitors in other states, creating a vicious cycle in which job openings and our farm workforce disappear in tandem, harming the very people the policy sought to help.

We should also bear in mind that our dairy farmers are beholden to price controls that limit their ability to increase their prices to recoup overhead costs. At the end of the day, all farmers are price-takers, meaning that they sell their goods at prices set by processors, distributors and facilities. Farmers, here in New York, are often unable to meet the low costs sought by these purchasers. Even as things stand now, prices on our produce are so high that many New York City schools order apples from Washington state.

If the overtime threshold were to be lowered at all, or to 40 hours, it’s likely it would no longer be profitable to produce many beloved crops here in New York. Our produce would then be less fresh, less plentiful and more expensive. During a year in which we’ve seen unprecedented increases in food prices in stores, where profits don’t directly benefit farmers, the last thing we need is to deliver another gut-punch from Albany to families finding it increasingly difficult to nourish their loved ones. Additionally, farmers have seen the cost of feed, fuel, equipment and other goods they need skyrocket due to inflation.

My hope is that the Farm Laborers Wage Board, along with Gov. Hochul, as a native of upstate New York, listens to the concerns of our upstate farmers on the many implications of this issue, instead of ignoring those concerns for the sake of appeasing partisan activists who lack insight into the day-to-day operations of a farm.

In rural upstate New York, agriculture is more than an economic sector, it’s a way of life. This proposal jeopardizes the existence of farms that have been pillars of our community for generations. To imagine our region without family farms is like imagining New York City without skyscrapers. My hope is that on this issue, if no other, our concerns will not fall on deaf ears.

Assemblyman Steve Hawley

Batavia

Hawley represents the 139^th Assembly District which includes most of Orleans County, all of Genesee County and part of western Monroe County.

Editor:

I thought the election was over. Time to move on. Yet Councilman Riggi had to throw in one more letter with confusing successes. Then had to spin up accusations of misinformation about what he perceived was misinformation on a part of a few. Who are the few?

Misinformation is a nice word for inaccurate or purposely intending to deceive. Gives no examples. My guess would be myself and anyone who helped me. Let’s have a debate on that misinformation right here on the Hub.

There was no deceit no misinformation. Campaigns bring out differences and truths. Sometimes the truth is ugly and embarrassing. If not for this misinformation accusation I would not have bothered responding to such a letter. Not Mr. Riggi’s best work but since he opened the door I have more to say that otherwise would have been left at rest.

How out of touch can one person be to tout this list of stretched accomplishments? Honestly, A fund was not the fault of this board ($86,000 hole). It was missed by a private auditor the town still employs and it goes way back to 2005 when town hired this bookkeeper. They were forewarned but did nothing about it by many constituents, for many years. Read the Yates and Ridgeway Water Audits from 2012. They are very relevant as they shared same bookkeeper. A past history is why the present situation.

Audit In Yates #4 Water: Books so amateurishly done they were hard to decipher. Water customers were overcharged. Town law was broken. Phony water districts were created within the district. Money that wasn’t supposed to be used was used for the “create” Blood Road extension that ran a water line and ended dead in front of… the bookkeeper – another ignored conflict of interest within Yates.

All beyond them had to wait a few years till it went down Route 18 and came up the front end of that road to finally connect all. To top it off our town had to take out a bond and the taxpayers have to pay all the money back I believe over 20 years. Did that administration know exactly what it was doing? You be the judge.

Ridgeway’s Audit is self explanatory. Nobody to this day paid a price, history repeated itself and it will again somewhere because those in political power protect one another.

Standard and Poor’s rating from B to A-. A B rating is speculative – currently meets payments but faces uncertainties. A full A rating would mean adequate but an A- is not acceptable when dealing with taxpayers’ money. Triple AAA is tops so nothing to brag about. Successful financial management under the tax cap. Unbelievable!

So what is it with politicians thinking that raising your taxes 2% every year is something to be proud of? With the raised assessments automatically raising your taxes coupled with the tax increase it’s more like 5% or more depending on how much your assessment was raised. They should not believe this is a success. Then blames Covid for the village money grab for the 15.29 percent tax increase in 2020. Six years of increases.

The comprehensive plan. Fierce opposition to the first one. Little to no survey response on second one. Comments never released to the public. Probably not good. Living document gives the power to completely control every aspect of your life and land. Only 2 people said no. Myself and one comprehensive plan committee member. A tool for obtaining grant money. Read it yourself. We’re global citizens. The LWRP, in which Mr. Riggi has put time in. Another tool for grant money. Read the September 10th 2018 Town Board minutes. He says, “The town of Yates has a long list of projects that they will be going after the state for this money to do these projects starting with the village.”

That’s where bike paths, nature trails, and sidewalks to nowhere came from. I’m not going to go in detail through the whole list. Most is routine town business, or a personal wish list to change the area (Bio Digester) or taking credit for business growth when it’s the achievements of a AAA business friendly planning board and code officer that really deserve the credit.

I know your fairly new being politically active but I have been around a long time and seen much of this personally. There was no misinformation in the campaign. Get over it and stick to town business. This is not Pittsford or Orchard Park. It’s Lyndonville. Slow down with the changes.

Paul Lauricella

Yates

Editor:

It was probably a good idea to put charging stations at the library, but whose design was it to put them on the other side of the sidewalk?

The cords go across the sidewalk so that people have to walk on the grass or in the parking lot.

When it snows and you can’t walk on the grass you end up in the parking lot which makes it a hazard for pedestrians and motorists.

Are they going to put a sidewalk behind the charging stations to give people a safe place to walk?

Orleans County concerned citizens,

Robert & Patricia Snell

Kendall

Editor:

This letter is in response to one recently submitted by concerned neighbors, Sharon Cassidy and Pamela Cook, in regards to an out-of-town organization from western New York who has purchased a private medical doctor’s office on West Center Street and Florence Avenue in their residential neighborhood.

When Dr. Surinder Bath was approaching retirement, discussions began on how we can best continue to serve the patients that had been under his care. Dr. Bath was truly concerned about what would happen to his patients once he retired. That is where Oak Orchard Health (OOH) came into play.

Dr. Bath liked the integrated model of care that OOH provides, where primary care, behavioral health, vision, dental, and supporting services are all provided under the umbrella of one organization. OOH provides care to patients who are fully insured as well as those with limited medical insurance. OOH provides care to all members of the community, from birth to geriatrics, and does so with skill and compassion.

At this point, OOH does not intend to significantly vary how we provide medical care at Dr. Bath’s former office. Michelle Okonieczny, NP, a member of the Medina community, will be the primary provider practicing there. Michelle lives only a few short blocks from the office, and has a vested stake in the neighborhood.

The two support staff who previously worked with Dr. Bath will continue working with OOH – so patients will experience the same familiar faces in the same familiar setting. Dr. Bath decided to sell to OOH because he thought this was the best way to take care of his patients and to continue to serve the community.

OOH does not intend to expand the size of the office, but will be making some regulatory as well as cosmetic improvements to the facility. We too, are concerned with preserving the aesthetics of the neighborhood, and will make every effort to add to it rather than distract.

Any additional services that the patients of the community may desire can be provided from one of our several other office locations that are situated throughout western New York. OOH remains dedicated to improving and enriching the lives of the patients and communities we serve. We value the concerns of all stakeholders and welcome this opportunity to ease the fears some may have.

Sincerely,

Mary Ann Pettibon, CEO

Oak Orchard Health

Editor:

I applied for a code enforcement officer position with 3 towns and a village. In doing so, I knew patronage would be my biggest competitor.

I have 25 years in construction inspection services, for multiple government agencies, and commercial development, and I’m a  30-year resident of the village.

I applied to two of the towns so nobody could say the application got lost. A month later, I got an interview. I was excited, but anxious because I’m cynical.

The night before the interview, I got a call from Strong Hospital. They had just told my mom that she has terminal cancer, with not much time. Knowing this, I manned up, and went to the interview. I was anxious (mom’s alone at the hospital).

I felt the interview went well. As I was leaving, an angel told me I did amazing, and she would be fighting for me. Made me feel good, then off to hospital to console my dying mom – got to get her home, I promised.

A few days later, a call, need help with your references, and in the spirit of transparency and fairness, the committee is going to ask you about town zoning. The other applicants received same information.

Another call, interview, next Monday. Awesome, I got a chance.

Get mom home to hospice at home. Friday, she’s home. Happy to have her. In hospital bed, really weak, on morphine. Knowing it won’t be long.

Saturday, family and friends show up, her spirits lifted, even as her body lags. Sunday, she’s looking better, demanded to get out of bed. I was awoken, put her back to bed. Breathing, so laborious. She’s resting, family leaves, tears and hearts all over floor.

I need a break, anxious again, watching my amazing wife care for my mom, through the window, freezing outside. I feel so numb. She’s talking to my aunt, seems worried.

Seeing, her gasping, I called the nurse, more morphine. Can barely swallow. Aunt’s asleep and doesn’t look so good, herself. But glad she’s here.

My mother’s gasping lessens, I caress her head, tell her it’s OK to go. Over, and over…. Till  Mom, Mom. I listen, she’s gone. 11:45 p.m. on a Sunday.

First thing in morning, contacted towns, please withdraw my application for the position. Thank you. What do I do for work now?

Couple days later, another call. Can you come in next Tuesday, committee really wants to hear from you. OK. Anxious again, tired. Brother thinks it’s good news, think they liked what I said. I’m cynical. Second interview, I performed well, I crushed it. Had a thought out answer for all questions. Left feeling good. Anxious, when will they call? Days go by.

Friday, missed call. The town, can you call me. Call town. Hello, yes it was so close, we had to “Flip A Coin”….. Thud.

Well thanks again for opportunity and meeting you all. Seriously! A coin toss, didn’t realize it was OT in a football game.

My emotions played with, my grief ignored. Embarrassing. By the way, so and so got the position. Patronage over qualifications wins again. Illegal, No. Unfair, Yes.

My own town sold me out. $100,000 spent investing in my house, my community. For not. I’m not going to judge, I’ll leave that to the tax payers, and God.

I’m going to grieve.

Kevin A. Rogers

Lyndonville

Editor:

This is an open letter to New York State Legislative members.

Dear NYS Senators and Assembly Members: Re: Assembly Districts

In 1964 the US Supreme Court declared that 49 of the 50 states had to abandon their legislature’s Republican Structure and were now required to reorganize their legislative districts based on population.

Not only does the US Constitution not give the Supreme Court the authority to make such a decree, the United States Supreme Court itself completely ignored Article 4, Section 4 of the US Constitution, which reads:

“The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government, … .”

Even before New York became a state it had a Republican form of government. How the Republican Structure was to be maintained was spelled out in the NYS Constitution whereby each county was granted one Representative in the New York State Assembly. (Historically, there was only one exception to this requirement). The more populous counties were granted additional representation in the Assembly when the county’s population was 50% greater (or more) than the average New York State county’s population. New York State maintained its Republican form of government up to 1964.

Despite the New York State’s constitutional requirements, the New York State Legislature complied with the Supreme Court’s decree and proceeded to destroy the Republican Structure of the NYS government.

I ask you to reject any proposal for the redistricting of New York State Assembly Districts that does not restore the Republican Structure to the NYS Assembly and that does not allocate at least one Assembly representative per county.

Vote to return the Republican Structure to the NYS Legislature. Restore the responsibility of the Members of the Assembly to be the representative from, and for, their respective county.

Additionally, consider the fact that the representatives in counties with just one representative are essentially ‘At-Large’ within their county. The Members of the Assembly are all supposed to be representatives of their county. Therefore, all the Assembly districts, regardless of how many representatives each county is allotted, should be designed as the entire county, and all the members should be Representatives At-Large. Please consider making all Assembly Districts county wide and do not allow any Assembly District to be drawn that is just a part of a county, or that includes part of another county.

If you support this proposal, it would completely eliminate gerrymandering of Assembly Districts and would restore the Republican Structure to the New York State Legislature. It would put an end to the “Divide New York” movements, and would restore some county oversight of the New York State Legislature.

I pray that you give consideration to this proposal and help restore the Empire State to its prior greatness.

With goodwill toward all, and proud to be Libertarian.

PS: The following is an example of how simple the redistricting of the Assembly Districts should be to re-establish the Republican structure to the New York State Legislature: The following Assembly seats are allocated to the counties as follows: Kings County 16, Queens County 13, New York 12,  Suffolk 10, Nassau 9, Bronx 8, Erie 6, Westchester 6, Monroe 5, Richmond 3, Onondaga 3, Orange 2, Rockland 2, Albany 2, Dutchess 2, Saratoga 2, Niagara 2,  Oneida 2, Broome 2, and the remaining 43 counties would each be assigned 1 Assembly seat. All of the districts would be county wide and the candidates for the Assembly would be At-Large.

For many reasons, these assignments were made based on the number of registered voters. If you request, I will send the excel table with the calculations.

Mark E. Glogowski, PhD

Hamlin

Former Libertarian Party Chairman in New York

Editor:

My wife and I, along with our two sons, moved to eastern Tennessee in 2013 after we retired but still like to keep up with activity in the Albion and Holley area. The Hub is a great way to do that.

There are only three areas that stand out as far as really welcome changes from Western NY – the weather, taxes and politics .

I don’t need to go into detail on the weather unless you like gloomy, cold and snow. Although some people do, we actually moved following our son’s previous relocation and thought we were heading to the backwoods, but pleasantly were surprised to see less poverty and well maintained infrastructure – roads are superb and the most noticeable plus!

But the taxes and politics are the biggest differences. Property and school taxes were beyond surviving on Social Security, in my opinion from corruption. Here we actually saved some of our Social Security up until the inflation caused by the current president. Politics has obviously gone to liberalism in my hometown. How’s that working out for you now?

After that last sentence you probably know where I am politically but you might be wrong. Actually I am a strict Constitutionalist and don’t agree with either party that have been running this country into the ground – taking turns ruling us!

I am a Vietnam Marine Corps veteran that was told my helicopter squadrons that a 5% casualty rate was “acceptable” in order to preserve our liberty, economy and way of life. I don’t regret it one bit. Granted we were mostly volunteers and knew what was at stake when we signed up.

So tell me how we gave away our liberty, economy and way of life over a virus that is 98.6% survivable? Are you civilians worth more than vets? Or just dumb!

Ed Steuber

Dawn Patrol Aviation (the ex-crop duster)

Erwin, Tenn.