letters to the editor/opinion

Editorial: Frenchy Downey and Brad Shelp set example as great citizens well into their 90s

By Tom Rivers, Editor Posted 3 November 2026 at 8:12 am

Photos by Tom Rivers: Everett “Frenchy” Downey is shown in May 11, 2024 when he was close to retiring after selling and repairing televisions and appliances for 60 years in Albion. He retired on May 25, 2024, his 94th birthday.

Today is Election Day, when many people go to the polls believing it is a strong sense of citizenship duty. Yes, it is. It’s a good thing to vote, especially if people research candidates and issues, and make an informed choice.

But the great acts of citizenship are in how we conduct our daily lives, being a good neighbor and using our talents and resources to build a stronger community.

Orleans County in the past week lost two amazing citizens, generous gentleman who were very active well into their 90s.

Everett “Frenchy” Downey died at age 96 on Oct. 28. His friend, Brad Shelp, was 94 and died on Oct. 31. These two may be the best examples of the power of showing up, day after day for decades. They were both people you could count on.

Downey worked up until his 94th birthday at Frenchy’s TV & Appliance on Ridge Road in Gaines. He sold and repaired televisions and appliances for 60 years. He had a remarkable work ethic and an ability to connect with everyone.

He was slowed at age 93 when he hurt his back moving a freezer. But Frenchy continued to be a steady presence at his showroom and to make some house calls to give extra life to a stove, refrigerator, washing machine or another appliance.

“I have loved what I’ve been doing every day,” Downey said during a 2024 interview at his business at 13576 Ridge Rd. “I got to know a lot of people. I always have thought of my customers as my friends. I want to help them if I can.”

Frenchy Downey is shown in May 2024 with a 1946 Taylorcraft airplane, which he has had since 1968. Downey also built his own plane. He earned his pilot’s license in 1968 after his barbershop quartet broke up and he had more free time. He pursued a love of flying that he kept up until age 93.

Frenchy was fascinated by aviation and built his own airplanes. He was active in the Albion Rotary Club and received Rotary’s highest award, the Paul Harris Fellow. He also sang in a barbershop quartet that won national awards.

He and his wife Dorothy raised three children. Dorothy worked with Frenchy for about 40 years, until her passing in 2005. She was the bookkeeper. After her death, Frenchy took on the dreaded task of doing all the paperwork for his business. That was one part of the business he despised.

Brad Shelp drives his Bell Air convertible from 1954 in the Albion Strawberry Festival on June 8, 2024. He gave a ride to Mike and Faith Smith, who were grand marshals in the parade.

Brad Shelp was a fixture in the community for many decades. He was a well-known car salesman, working part-time through his 80s and early 90s. He took great pride in his classic cars, and he often drove his 1954 Bell Air convertible in the Albion Strawberry Festival parade.

Shelp served as the parade chairman, even in his 90s. It was a daunting challenge to organize about 50 parade entries, and space them out so the marching bands weren’t too close together.

Shelp was a key member of the Albion Rotary Club and maintained perfect attendance for well over 65 years. If he was on vacation or couldn’t make the Albion meeting, he found clubs in other communities to make up and keep that attendance streak alive.

He did more than show up for meetings. Shelp was active in the club’s fundraisers and service projects, whether preparing food for the St. Patrick’s Day ham dinner or hauling away bags of garbage during the spring cleanup day. He was integral member of the Rotary fishing derby for many years, an event that brought in nearly 1,000 participants and raised about $5,000 for community projects.

Brad joined the Army in 1954 and served in Korea. When he returned home, he joined his father at the Albion Motor Company, a General Motors dealership. He met his wife when she was looking for a car in 1956. Brad proved a persuasive salesman.

Brad and Pat were married for 63 years and had two sons. Pat was a beloved teacher and school librarian at Albion. She was 86 when she passed away in 2021.

Brad Shelp and his wife Pat are shown in 2012 during Halloween. The Shelps had a big display at their home on Meadowbrook Drive, and they welcomed kids and their parents to a take a break with hot cider and doughnuts.

Many Albion people may best know Brad and his late wife Pat as the best stop for trick or treating. The Shelps had an elaborate setup on Meadowbrook Drive, with orange lights up their driveway. They turned their garage into a welcome center, offering parents a chance to sit down for a few minutes and enjoy some hot cider and doughnuts. The kids received bags that were stuffed with treats.

The lives of Frenchy Downey and Brad Shelp are examples for how to make a difference in our community by showing up every day. These two men were very dependable, anchors in the Albion community for many decades.

Write-in candidate for Clarendon supervisor wants safer community with lower taxes

Posted 2 November 2026 at 8:42 pm

Editor:

Hello, Clarendon!

I would like to explain why I am running and clarify my position on community issues.

I am running as a write-in candidate for town supervisor after concerns arose during the primary about my opponent and his wife Melissa Ierlan. I encourage voters to focus on facts, responsible use of public resources, and each candidate’s qualifications and character—not on personal favors or campaign rhetoric.

I also want to clarify statements about me circulating during the campaign.

Gun rights and community safety – I support the right to bear arms and am not seeking to take away residents’ rights to shoot firearms lawfully on their own property. I am a gun owner with a legal concealed-carry permit. I believe that exercising these rights also carries a responsibility to consider the safety and well-being of our neighbors.

Three years ago, I began working to help residents feel safe and at peace in their homes and community. This effort began during Dick Moy’s tenure as town supervisor. Mr. Moy arranged meetings with Sheriff Bourke and concerned community members, and our current town supervisor, Marc Major, has continued that work.

Because of my efforts to bring the community together I have become a lightning rod and now, my opponent, his family and friends new boogie man. Fred, it’s time to stand up and tell the community why you are running for our supervisor’s seat and what your plans are for our community. What are your plans to lower our property taxes.

I have already started looking into both. I know some in our community might not like what I propose, such as encouraging small businesses and new residents to join our community. I am also looking at hiring someone to look for state and federal grants that could take financial pressure off our community. That person will not be paid with our tax dollars. That person will be paid with my salary, paid for by the community.

At the board meetings I attended, I raised concerns about noise and unsafe conditions but did not initially raise firearm noise. That issue arose more recently when I learned of concerns about its impact on veterans living with PTSD. I believe those concerns deserve thoughtful consideration, and I support listening to the veterans who have served to protect our rights.

Personal character and respectful dialogue – I would like to address the characterization of me as an “angry lesbian.” My sexual orientation does not define my temperament or my qualifications to serve. I am not an angry or vindictive person by nature. Throughout my campaign, I have spoken with Democrats and Republicans, including longtime Republican voters who have told me they cannot support Fred Seeman. I believe our conversations should remain respectful and focused on the issues facing Clarendon.

My candidacy gives Clarendon residents a choice in this general election for town supervisor. I believe my actions demonstrate my commitment to our community. Voters deserve a campaign focused on constructive proposals rather than personal attacks.

During the primary, Fred Seeman spoke about transparency but did not attend a community question-and-answer session. He also discussed improving our infrastructure without explaining how those improvements would be funded. I believe residents deserve clear answers about these plans and their costs.

Your vote will affect everyone who calls Clarendon home. Please consider each candidate’s actions, qualifications, and plans, and make your voice heard.

Sincerely, your write-in candidate for town supervisor,

Kathy Harnischfeger

Clarendon

16-year-old says Seielstad is a hard-working and caring leader

Posted 2 November 2026 at 8:35 pm

Editor:

I want to take a moment to share why Marlene Seielstad is someone I look up to and respect so much.

As a 16-year-old, I see Marlene as one of the biggest role models in my life. She is incredibly hardworking and puts 200% into everything she does. She is fair, knowledgeable, organized, and truly loves what she does. She makes people feel included, and she has taught me a lot just by being herself.

Now, I will be honest. Marlene can be tough, very assertive, and sometimes rub people the wrong way. She has high expectations and isn’t afraid to speak her mind. But one thing I have come to realize is that Marlene will never ask someone to do something she isn’t willing to do herself. If she expects something to be done right, she gets right in there with you and shows you how to do it. She doesn’t just tell people what to do; she leads by example. To me, that shows integrity and what real leadership looks like.

I think sometimes people see her toughness before they see how much she cares. She is a strong leader with a big heart, and she wants to see people succeed. I believe there is a lot to learn from someone who works hard, stands by her expectations, and is willing to put in the same effort she asks of others.

At 16, I know I still have a lot to learn, but I am thankful to have someone like Marlene to look up to. She has shown me that being a good leader isn’t always about making everyone happy. Sometimes it’s about doing what is right, working hard, and helping others along the way.

Sincerely,

Christina Zaidel

Middleport

Shelby voters urged to keep town clerk and highway superintendent as elected positions

Posted 2 November 2026 at 2:30 pm

Editor:

The Town of Shelby Board would like you to vote to make the town clerk and the town highway superintendent’s positions appointed by them, as opposed to the current process of electing them.

This proposal by the board stems from disagreements between the current board and the people currently holding those positions. It has absolutely nothing to do with their qualifications for the job or their accountability. True leadership on the board would be able to work with anyone in those positions.

But more important than that leadership issue, is the fact that the elected clerk and elected highway superintendent’s positions are the only checks and balances over the board itself.

The clerk is responsible for protecting the records of the town. If the board appoints the clerk, there is nothing to keep board members from accessing those records, or disposing of records they might not want preserved, without the clerk’s oversight.

The highway superintendent would become a board bobblehead if that position were appointed by the board. Without constructive conversation, and differences of opinion, creative solutions aren’t possible. If the board is unable to function with those differing opinions, then maybe they should not be board members.

Taking the choice away from the voters is never a good answer.

Respectfully,

Wendi Pencille

Shelby

Key town officials should stay elected in Shelby where political parties do candidate vetting

Posted 2 November 2026 at 9:25 am

Editor:

Let’s review how people get on a ballot: Required signatures, deadline to be met, timely filings and requesting endorsement.

Candidates can obtain necessary signatures but if they want an endorsement they need to appear at a political party and be interviewed and vetted. The committee then votes on whether to support the candidate or not.

Every four years Darlene Rich sought the Democratic endorsement in the Town of Shelby for town clerk and appeared before us. We asked her questions regarding her work ethic and attending seminars to further her education and other pertinent issues.

The committee then voted to endorse her for another term. I would think the Republicans and other political parties follow a similar procedure.

The committee has a choice to approve or reject the candidate.

Darlene Rich has performed her duties beyond a reasonable doubt.

Thank you,

Jeanne Crane

Carlton

Crane is the former Democratic Party chairwoman in Orleans County.

Vote ‘No’ on Shelby referendums and let voters continue to elect town clerk, highway superintendent

Posted 1 November 2026 at 10:46 am

Editor:

As the November 3 election approaches, the residents of the Town of Shelby face a critical decision regarding two local referendums that seek to abolish our elected Town Clerk’s and Highway Superintendent’s elected positions and turn them into appointed offices.

We strongly urge my fellow neighbors to vote against these measures and preserve our right to vote. Changing these positions from elected to appointed reduces vital public accountability.

Currently, our town clerk and highway superintendent answer directly to us, the taxpayers every few years at the ballot box. If these referendums pass, control shifts entirely to the Town Board.

The highway superintendent manages the largest expense in our town budget, overseeing infrastructure, road safety and winter storm responses. With so much taxpayer money involved, residents deserve a direct say in who handles these resources rather than letting a few board officials dictate who serves.

Furthermore, data shows that the vast majority of towns in New York prefer elected officials. Out of 933 townships in the state, roughly 90% choose to elect their town clerk and highway superintendent.

The few towns that use appointed systems are typically large, urban or suburban areas requiring highly specialized administrative skills. Shelby is a rural community where direct accountability works best.

Consolidating power within the Town Board takes away the individual voter’s influence. We must protect our voting rights and keep local government accountable to the people.

Please vote “NO” on the Shelby town clerk and Highway Superintendent referendums on the back of the ballot this November.

Respectfully submitted,

James Rogenmoser, Marlene Rogenmoser, Thomas Winans, Becky Winans, David Bracey, Nancy Bracey, Timothy, Wickham, Gary Watts, Robin Watts, Helen Root, Stephen Rosenberg, Cathy Rosenberg, Karl Haist, Amy Haist, Rusty Hofmeister,  C.J. Woodruff, Lynn Woodruff, Melinda Kenward and Chad Kenward

Shelby

Seielstad has deep knowledge of community, willingness to ask the hard questions

Posted 1 November 2026 at 7:28 am

Editor:

Orleans County has an important choice to make for Orleans County Legislature. If, like me, you think we can do better, you finally have a real choice in Marlene Seielstad. I’ve known Marlene for nearly 30 years, through multiple programs at Cornell Cooperative Extension, the school board, and the BOCES Board.

She is one of the hardest working women I know. She’s smart, honest, and engaged in the community. Her drive and work ethic are second to none.

Marlene is a graduate of Leadership Orleans. She’ll use the knowledge gained there to ask the difficult questions and not shy away from challenging the status quo; something that is sorely lacking in our current Legislature.

Marlene is a thoughtful decision maker, and she truly listens in conversation. When is the last time you can say the legislature actually listened and considered comments from the community before making a decision?

Marlene has given a lifetime of volunteer service to our community through the Albion School Board, the Orleans Niagara BOCES Board, and the Orleans County Cornell Cooperative Extension. Marlene Seielstad is the right choice for Orleans County Legislature. Please vote this Tuesday. The future of your community depends on it.

Sincerely,

Wendi Pencille

Town of Shelby

Vote for candidates without hidden agendas, who work with others

Posted 1 November 2026 at 7:22 am

Editor:

Lots of hate is being whipped up to turn out the vote. Some are using the excuse to claim the results are fixed – assuming  several pollsters are right about how fed up people are.

But when you are at the polls really look at the kind and selfless people helping you. Remember they do not know your party and you do not know theirs.

Democrats are not immoral and Republicans are not ignorant. We simply need to elect those without hidden agenda and motives who are willing to talk to each other without rancor.

That’s the type who can articulate real solutions rather than shop worn epithets. Our job is to spot them and demand the right to live quiet, decent lives without fear of economic or personal hardship.

Regardless of the results  remember your poll worker and don’t get worked up by conspiracy from the fringes. Keep in mind that people no different from them are helping people at every precinct in the country. They will get the job done fairly and well.

Conrad F. Cropsey

Albion

Seielstad brings proven dedication, common-sense approach to solving problems

Posted 31 October 2026 at 3:35 pm

Editor:

I add my strong personal endorsement to Marlene Seielstad’s campaign to serve as an At-Large Member of the Orleans County Legislature.

I have been impressed with Marlene’s common-sense approaches to modern challenges, her dedication to the completion of each task, as well as her heart for serving our community.

Marlene inspires confidence in her leadership, and she will be a strong voice for Democratic principles during a time when even the most basic functions of government are under threat.

Election Day is Tuesday, November 3rd, from 6 a.m. until 9 p.m, with a polling site in each of the county’s 10 towns.

James R. Renfrew

Clarendon

Orleans County Democrats, Chair

Allport engages in partisan fearmongering, stirs anti-government cynicism

Posted 30 October 2026 at 7:48 pm

Editor:

After reading some recent letters to the editor, I have to agree – these are trying times.

As a resident of Orleans County, I believe our community deserves leadership grounded in truth, rather than partisan fearmongering and unverified talking points.

In a recent letter, County Legislator Don Allport presented several claims that do not hold up under the simplest scrutiny. Rather than respond to the recitation of those familiar alarmist points about Socialism, I’ll keep this focused on the truth as relates to our election.

No one in Orleans County can vote for someone who is endorsed by the Democratic Socialist Party or who is running a campaign to advance items from their platform.

Now that that’s out of the way, let’s talk about what we can vote for. We should expect that a candidate taking the time to assert historical claims in the local news source would fact check them prior to writing. I have heard Don speak about history, particularly the revolutionary war, with the accuracy and reverence it is due. This leaves me particularly confused regarding the following assertions:

Allport: One vote decided our national language.

Truth: Unless we’re considering the 2025 executive order by the current president, the US does not actually have an officially designated language, and there was never a risk of this occurring were it not for a singular vote.

It’s likely that Mr. Allport refers to the persistent myth stemming from a group of new citizens in Virginia, German speakers, who requested that some of the laws be copied over into German so that they could be readily followed by that populace. The “one vote” difference was not even whether to copy over the laws in German for the residents, rather it was a vote resolving to table the issue and take it up another time. It was defeated 42-41, and the actual measure did not come to the floor.

Allport: The ’60 presidential election was lost by Nixon due to one vote in each election district in Illinois.

Truth: Back in 1960, the path to 270 was actually the path to 269, the number of electoral votes needed then to secure the office of President-elect. Even if the 27 electoral votes from Illinois had gone to Nixon rather than JFK, Kennedy still would have prevailed with 276 votes.

Allport: An earlier Nixon presidency would have prevented so much of the upheaval of the ’60s, including Vietnam, the JFK assassination, and Kent State.

Truth: If we are going to judge Nixon by his fruit, we may find it hard to believe that the man who delayed peace talks through Anna Chenault (something well documented in US historical documents including Haldeman’s own declassified notes) and then carpet bombed Cambodia while hiding it by falsifying military records – resulting directly in the Kent State massacre, would somehow have been the peace president he claimed in word but never deed.

As for the JFK assassination, I don’t think that he would have been shot in November of 1963 if he was not the sitting US president, so perhaps that one could have been averted if the election outcome was reversed.

Back in the local arena, attacking federal safety net programs ignores the reality that low-income residents in Orleans County rely on these services. Would the county choose not to offer them if they were not mandated or supported by federal and state support? An average house assessed at $200,000 paid around $1,600 in county taxes last January. Of that, nearly half of it (roughly $700) paid into Medicaid. This money solely funds healthcare to residents of our county.

Because the most recent census shows that the median household income in Orleans County is $65,969, the median taxpayer spends 1.06% of their annual gross income on healthcare for their neighbors. Maybe there’s a better plan. Maybe there’s a better method of implementing the current plan. But I bet it doesn’t involve calling homes in the county where we all live a cesspool – literally household sewage.

Elected officials should welcome community observation and transparency rather than promoting anti-government cynicism or attacking media credibility. I have met most of the elected officials in this county and, regardless of party affiliation, do not believe that a single person running for or holding office here did so for any motivation but one: to make their community a better place the best way that they know how.

It’s disingenuous to attempt to distinguish local office holders from “politicians.” Government is the system, politics is the method. We should expect all of our elected officials to work methodically to advance good government for the residents they serve.

Therefore, it’s alarming to hear a local politician, writing in his personal capacity, to both misrepresent facts in history and to describe a fear of being watched.

A truth that we do agree on, and the most important truth being advanced in each letter, is that each vote does in fact count and not nearly enough of our neighbors are exercising that right.

Because our elections are how we choose who represents our interests best, I hope that the truth weighs heavily in your decision-making process this year.

See you at the polls,

Jess Marciano

Medina

Marciano is a trustee on the Medina Village Board.