We appreciate input from our readers, and we publish letters to the editor without charge. The letters should be written by the person who submits the letter and not be “ghost written” by someone else. While open speech and responsibility are encouraged, comments may be rejected if they are purely a personal attack, offensive or repetitive. Comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Orleans Hub. Although care is taken to moderate comments, we have no control over how they are interpreted and we are unable to guarantee the accuracy of comments and the rationality of the opinions expressed. We reserve the right to edit letters for content and brevity. Please limit the length of your letter (we suggest no more than 500 words) and provide your name, telephone number, mailing address and a verifiable email address for verification purposes. Letters should be emailed to news@orleanshub.com.

Editor:

In previous writings regarding The President I have made comparisons to other Fascist leaders throughout history particularly comparing Hitler’s Der Generalplan Ost, the promotion of the idea of Lebensraum and the de-intellectualizing of education to The President’s ideals and ambitions for America. These objectives have been outlined in his Project 2025, which very oddly he has alleged he knew nothing about.

What intrigues me the most is why 49.8% of the participating electorate in the 2024 Presidential Election would prefer to “choose” this for our nation. Which then reminds me of the conversation I used to have with my students who could not possibly understand how a person like Hitler could come to power. Likewise, why does the President of the United States prefer to weaken, destabilize and reduce educational opportunities for our young.

The answer then was as obvious as it is now; things like this happen for example when The President appointed Linda McMahon, a former professional wrestling promoter, with absolutely no experience in education, to be the Secretary of the United States Department of Education. What message does that send to the American People about how little he values education when the founder of the failed and bankrupt Trump University (which was never a university in the first place) shows such total disregard for the significance and importance of public education. Her appointment was an absolute embarrassment to REAL educators nationwide.

Further, upon her appointment he instructed her from the beginning to plan for the termination of this Cabinet-level position and the absolute minimization, if not total elimination, of the department during his administration.

The headline on March 12: “Education Secretary: Mass Layoffs First Step Toward Total Shutdown”. It might as well have said let Der Generalplan Ost, the idea of Lebensraum and the de-intellectualizing of America’s youth begin!

Perhaps you wonder what the Department of Education does for you; some of which comes directly from the federal government, other benefits are parceled via New York State. By Congressional mandate the DOE enforces anti-discrimination policies in schools, they distribute financial aid based upon need, they finance the Pell Grants which provides direct financial aid to students for college, and they help finance localized vocational training programs.

They also provide direct financial aid for physically and mentally challenged students.  These services, which are in part or totally supported by the United States Department of Education, are absolutely critical to a community such as ours, and no doubt some of you benefit from and depend upon.

Lastly, consider this brief data analysis with regards to The President’s disregard for education and academic achievement. In the 2024 Presidential Election the President won the popular vote in 31 states. Of these 31 states, according to an extensive study conducted by the US News and World Report, 20 were identified to be among the absolute worst 25 public educational systems in the country. This includes both public institutions of higher education and all pre-K – 12 school systems.

Ask yourself again why he does not value education … and if the answer does not jump off this page at you – please consider yourself to be one of his deliberately targeted constituents!

Doug Miller

Albion

Editor:

I will do my best to provide a clear response to the Shelby Town Supervisor’s letter date February 21, 2025. However, his letter is very confused and difficult to follow.

To begin with he takes credit for a reduction in the tax rate. That reduction had nothing to do with his reducing the budget, but the result of a town-wide reassessment that substantially increased the area’s tax base. Because of this reassessment many residents saw their taxes increase even though the tax rate was adjusted downward.

The 2024 NYS Comptroller’s letter is indeed a follow-up to the 2021 audit. The failures pointed out in this letter, which you need to read, were the result of extensive interviews with Supervisor Scott Wengewicz and Bookkeeper Miranda Bennett. The comptroller’s office found that of the 7 recommendations made in the 2021 audit, only one had been partially accomplished.

The quotation I cited was not from me but from the Comptroller’s 2024 letter.  Here is the complete quotation:

“Although the bookkeeper was present during our last audit and was aware of the discrepancies in accounting records, she did not correct or resolve the discrepancies. In addition, neither the former Supervisor nor the current Supervisor resolved the discrepancies in the Town’s accounting records and could not provide a reasonable explanation for not correcting the discrepancies in the Town’s accounting records”

This is after Supervisor Wengewicz had been office over a year and a half.

The list of the supervisor’s and bookkeeper’s failures go on. I invite you to read the 5-page letter from Deputy Comptroller Robin L. Lois posted on the Town of Shelby’s website titled, “Review Follow up NYS Comptroller Sept., 2024”.

The common phrase from the Supervisor has been “no corruption and no money missing.”  No one has ever suggested this; however, the facts point to the Supervisor making bad decisions regarding taxpayers’ money, including creating budgets without the slightest idea of the true finances of the Town. In my many years in business, dealing with large budgets, you cannot control expenses if you do not have good accounting information and he obviously did not.

He likes to take credit for work currently being performed by two outside accounting firms.  To date they have completed 2023 and are working on 2024 so we will have a clearer picture when they are done. The presence of these firms was the result of pressure applied by two very determined board member’s, Councilwoman Linda Limina and Councilman Ed Zelazny and repeated pressure by certain members of the taxpaying public.

Such as:

• April 11, 2023 Former councilman John Pratt recommends hiring an outside accounting firm.
• June 13, 2023 Councilman Zelazny notes discrepancies in the finances and pushes to hire an outside accounting firm. Supervisor Wengewicz refuses and states that there is no money missing.
• Councilwoman Limina, who has a 4-year accounting degree, offered on numerous occasions to help the bookkeeper and talk with the software company. All attempts to do so were met by refusals from the Supervisor.

I have compiled a list Shelby Town Board meeting minutes and YouTube recordings which show the Supervisors consistent refusal to seek outside help. Email me at heminway2025@gmail.com for that list.

In terms of the windmills and STAMP projects. As recently as March 2024, Borrego asked the board for a zoning variation that would define a Wind Overlay district. There is currently a moratorium on any wind project until the Town Board gets this Wind Overlay recommendation from the Shelby Planning Board. The STAMP issue is not finished and is still being litigated. Both these projects are like vampires – they are not dead.

He takes credit for using the ARPA money. This was one-time COVID-era Federal/State money that went to everyone. He did nothing to get it and we will never see this type of financial assistance again.

Claims to be in negotiations with the Village of Medina over the rates that Medina charges Shelby for water. He had two meetings with Medina on January 4 and February 8, 2024.  The third meeting scheduled for later in February was cancelled by Shelby and there had not been another until 4 members of the Village board attended the latest Shelby board meeting and in public forced a future meeting date.  I would not call these on-going negotiations.

Claims credit for putting the Town’s money in the NY Class investment fund. This was first suggested by Councilman Pratt in January 2023 and again in December 2023. He finally proceeded in mid-2024.

These are not just “Heminway says” but rather real facts.

If elected, I promise the taxpayers of Shelby that I will apply the lessons I learned as a Chief Operating Officer to the role of Shelby Town Supervisor and never allow the type of poor fiscal oversight and lack of transparency we have experienced over the last two years.

Regards,

Jim Heminway

Medina

Editor:

Dr. Jane van Dis, an obstetrician/gynecologist affiliated with the University of Rochester, spoke on Wednesday, March 5th at the Hoag Library in Albion in a presentation arranged by Sister Dolores O’Dowd and “Green Orleans.”

Following her insightful talk she took numerous questions about the dangers of excessive plastic in our environment. This session was attended by about twenty residents who got an eye-opening reality check from an expert.

Doing justice to the amount of information she presented is beyond me, but this is an attempt to alert people to a problem we know too little about. Much of what we surround ourselves with contains plastic in some form. What it is doing to us may be far more harmful than most of us realize.

What Dr. van Dis had to say was quite eye-opening. Plastic in some form is in much of what we expose ourselves to. Her remarks revealed that its presence has serious deleterious effects on our health.

Among the conclusions Dr. van Dis had come to was that she should expose herself to as little plastic and the chemicals it contains and leaks as possible. That includes avoiding polyester clothing and acrylic paint. Look for paraben-free shampoo. According to her, growing your own food as much as possible works. She described herself as a vegan. Not allowing her children to crawl on polyester carpeting was mentioned.

Those who attended the informative session got a big-time wake-up call. One of the more surprising views she expressed was that attempting to recycle plastic likely does more harm than good. Green Orleans will attempt to alert residents to her next nearby presentation.

Sincerely yours,

Gary Kent

Albion

Editor:

In the aftermath of the President’s speech to Congress, my reflections have brought me to accept certain unsavory truths. Left wing liberal Democrats have a pathological hatred of Trump.

It doesn’t matter what the issue is or if the American people support what he’s doing. One of Trump’s most poignant remarks substantiated this when he stated that even if he cures devastating diseases, he would not warrant their approval. They are totally combative to him. At this point in time it seems inconceivable that the Democrats will admit that Trump has done any good for our nation.

The Democrats are still licking their wounds from the November loss and following James Carville’s advice to play dead.

The walking dead manifested themselves, like true zombies, during that speech. A new low. Except for Al Green of Texas who made a fool of himself and sacrificed his dignity to disrupt and create bedlam. Did he really think he would awaken the zombies in attendance?

Then the “This is Not Normal” sign. You know what isn’t normal – the Democrats had a chance during the Biden presidency to do something about corrupt capitalism but instead sidetracked that to focus on the grievances of extreme liberals, illegal immigrants and gender diversity.

Now that Musk is trying to reduce our national debt, which is unsustainable, and advocate for transparency, they are all up in arms – targeting him as the bad guy. Normal business practice where first and second line supervision are continually under pressure to cut heads has always been the law of the land.

When Musk asked employees to list the 5 things they accomplished in the past week, everybody went nuts. Many huge corporations have done this for years on a timely basis. GM started this in the 1970’s calling them Monthly Highlights – a very common practice.

If you didn’t turn them in, you didn’t get your paycheck. When I taught, my lesson plans had to be done weekly, and if I was out sick, my alternate plans for the sub were ready to execute.

The Democrats have become impotent and that in turn has prevented them from doing the right thing. That is NOT normal!

The ridiculous “bingo signs” ( Symone Sanders Townsend and Michael Steele of MSNBC) reminded me once again of their failures and difficulties as a political party to face the facts. They really never achieved their break through moment and are trying to redefine their identity. However this identity crisis has prevented them from creating a platform that extends beyond their antagonism to Trump.

Their refusal to not even applaud DJ Daniel a boy diagnosed with brain cancer, or Jason Hartley who had just gained admission to West Point  illustrated their stubborn refusal to open their minds. A disgrace!

Marc Fogel, an American school teacher, arrested in 2021 by Russia; sitting in the audience with his 95 year old mother – and the zombies didn’t flinch to acknowledge his release.

When hatred is this intense, one seldom welcomes varying views, belief systems and behavior. It becomes intolerant and is an overt act of discrimination. The unity of humanity is corroded and breaks down.

Instead of listening to James Carville, the Democrats better wake up and redefine who they are, to align their party’s purpose with the goals, safety, prosperity and solidarity of the populace.

Mary Mager

Fairport, formerly of Albion

Editor:

The current proposal from the GCEDC is to build a huge data center on the STAMP site in Genesee County.  A data center will have a large negative ecological impact (including high noise levels), require enormous public subsidies (almost $4M per job created) and produce relatively few jobs.

It is the antithesis of the original vision for STAMP. The payback time for the enormous financial inducements is in excess of a century – an absolutely terrible investment. The one advantage it offers the GCEDC is that it requires huge amounts of electricity, and thus may help bring electric power to a site that currently doesn’t have any.

A staggering fact is that  the site, which began construction in 2014, currently lacks water, sewer, and electricity infrastructure!  Water will have to be piped in, possibly through protected lands.

The current proposal is to pump raw sewage and industrial wastewater to Oakfield, where it will be treated and dumped into Oak Orchard Creek, a waterway that is critical for the multimillion dollar sport fishing industry in Orleans County, and that is already classified as ecologically impaired. An expensive electric substation will also have to be constructed by somebody – like the data center? –  in order to power the place.

Much of the failure of STAMP lies with the siting decision. The decision to build the complex 1) in a rural, sparsely populated area, 2) on what are essentially wetlands, 3) adjacent to multiple environmentally protected areas, and 4) bordering the Tonawanda-Seneca Nation, reflected insufficient consideration of environmental and ethical issues. Protected lands are rare and need to be preserved, not threatened.

The Tonawanda Seneca culture is closely wedded to nature and the land. The threats to the land from industrial pollution are real. The very existence of STAMP is an affront to the Nation – the latest in a centuries-long series of insults. They don’t deserve this. It is morally wrong to build a mammoth industrial site on the border of their nation.

In summary, in spite of all the hype, the genuine good intentions of its proponents, the money spent, and the hard work by well-meaning people, the reality is that STAMP is in the wrong place.

In Its present location STAMP is a failure, and no amount of good intentions or additional taxpayer money will alter that fact. It is time to recognize reality, reject the truly horrible idea of a data center, and make the painful decision to pull the plug on STAMP.  We built it in the wrong place, and they did not and will not come.

David Giacherio

Kent

Editor:

The Orleans County Democratic Committee strongly believes June 14th, Flag Day, should stand on its own out of respect and reverence for our flag.

We also submit that making this a National Holiday because it happens to be our current president’s birthday is premature.

Beth Wood

Barre

Wood is secretary of the Orleans County Democratic Committee.

Editor:

Department of Government Efficiency sounds great! I want one! It is not what we got when Trump created DOGE and put Elon Musk in charge.

The brilliance of the extreme right has been their ability to use language to hide what they are doing. A recent example, the Creating Confidence in Clean Water Permitting Act (H.R.7023) was introduced on January 17, 2024. It has nothing to do with making water cleaner, it will make water dirtier.

The bill limits the Environmental Protection Agency’s authority. I’m old enough to remember when Lake Erie was dead. It is alive again because of environmental protections.

When I think of an office that is focused on increasing government efficiency and reducing waste, I imagine they would look deeply into how things are being done and cut waste. That would take a little investigating to find out what is important and what is not.

If they cared about the American people, they would really look to find waste while keeping important programs. We are all tired of government waste. That is not what they are doing. They are just going in and slashing things without finding out how things work so they can keep the tax cuts for the wealthiest.

Cutting from the National Institute of Health will stop a lot of health care research. If you know anyone who has been in a clinical trial in hopes of healing cancer, these are the types of people that will be affected.

DOGE recently fired staff who were critical to the response to the bird flu and had to bring them back. The way they are working to save money does not make me feel confident. It highlights a complete disregard for the average American. They proposed cuts to Medicaid and Medicare that will take health care away from low-income families, seniors, and people with disabilities. We are safer in Orleans County because we are in a blue state.

They are focusing on cutting programs and services that help middle income and working families to keep the tax breaks that were started in Trump’s first term. Democrats were going to let them expire, in fact Republicans ran on these tax breaks.

One of my childhood friends is an accountant who has been serving the 1% for over 25 years. Accountants attend workshops when tax laws change. She attended three different workshops on making the most of these tax cuts. All three workshops started with a statement saying it was the biggest tax cut for the wealthy in the history of our tax code.

When they say tax cuts, they are not saying tax cuts for the average American. When they say they are not going to tax overtime or tips, they are shifting your focus. This is just like a magician who points something out in one direction, so you don’t see what they are doing to make the trick work.

Betty García Mathewson

Albion

Editor:

The following Shelby elected officials and endorsed-Republican candidates stand with and support the correction officers on strike due to the current unsafe working conditions they have been dealing with.

The Town of Shelby has many corrections officers and their families in our community, and they need our support.

These officers are forced to work over 24-hour shifts continuously which is an unsafe working condition. The HALT Act limits confinement for inmates which puts the officer’s safety in jeopardy, since the inmates know they will not be restricted for violation of the rules and regulations.

Now the state is penalizing officers for standing up for safe working conditions by taking away their health benefits, which is ironic. So now the inmates get healthcare and the correction officers don’t.  In what reality is this OK?  We need to support these officers in any way we can.

Respectfully,

Scott Wengewicz, Supervisor

Jeffrey Schiffer, Councilman

Steve Seitz, Councilman

Mike Moriarity, Endorsed Republican candidate

Vassilios Bitsas, Endorsed Republican candidate

Editor:

Congratulations to Congresswoman Claudia Tenney on her sweeping election victory last year.  When I travel to DC this week, I will urge her to use her mandate to address climate change and follow in the footsteps of the Republican environmental giants of the 20th century like Roosevelt and Nixon.

The American people know that there is 99 percent consensus in the scientific community as to the link between climate change and human activities. Recent wildfires have highlighted the continued risk of CO2 induced warming.

One policy that is addressing CO2 emissions is The Inflation Reduction Act. The policy serves to spur private investment, clean our electric grid and reduce costs for consumers. Our district benefited from this when Plug Power got $387 million for their facility in the STAMP industrial park. I hope that Congresswoman Claudia Tenney will work to preserve the clean energy provisions of the IRA.

As a lifelong Republican and a member of Citizen’s Climate Lobby, I know that Conservation is Conservative!

Rob Johnson

Medina

Editor:

After reading Ed Zelazny’s letter from Feb. 13 I am still left thinking, “Well Ed in the last 4 years what have you done for us residents?”

You bring up minute generic kicks the can down the road points, time and time again that you did nothing to help the town. Why should we sign your petitions or vote to renew your seat?

You constantly bring up and vote no to raising the budget – how can you run a business knowing the price of goods are going up but have no way to pay for them?

You vote no on paying monthly bills.

You vote no to save us money on water rates.

You voted no to a proposed flat tax rate for all residents resulting in the board accepting a higher budget proposal.

We watch the meetings month after month and not a damn thing gets resolved. The amount of bickering we see helps not one tax-paying resident. This behavior is why local residents want nothing to do with local government.

It’s embarrassing the way some of you board members behave. You continually bring up the same “issues” monthly, but never offer a solution. You wanted a code of ethics, then when the board needed to vote on it…. wait for it… you voted no on accepting a code.

The only light I see shown on “wild wild west” spending is you voting yes to give a pay raise for the Town Clerk three times, you voting yes to spending 6x more money than needed with an engineering firm for Royalton water flow, voting yes to keep purchasing 100% of our water needs from Medina that is double what Royalton is willing to sell at.

You are killing our community by not voting to purchase needed equipment at discounted rates when department heads bring deals to the table. Maybe we should have Elon come audit and see where this mystery money is disappearing to.

If you know what these backdoor deals are that we must be so blind to, why are you not informing us, the taxpayers after you have been in Town Hall serving your 4-year term?

Your term might have started with a signature, but it will end with your favorite vote, “No.”

William Luckman

Medina

Editor:

“For in a democracy, every citizen, regardless of his interest in politics, ‘hold office’; every one of us is in a position of responsibility; and, in the final analysis, the kind of government we get depends upon how we fulfill those responsibilities. We, the people, are the boss, and we will get the kind of political leadership, be it good or bad, that we demand and deserve.” – John F. Kennedy

During a recent visit to the Kennedy Museum, I had the distinct and unsettling experience of coming face to face with the above quotation. At the February 24th Village of Medina board meeting, I experienced the sobering reality of what it meant in terms of responsible political leadership. The meeting lasted for almost 3 hours with the Village Board and audience sparring on a number of issues, and the dominant topic was the financing of a fire truck and the construction of an additional bay to house the vehicle.

The Medina firefighters, their respective union and supporters spoke to many frustrations and instances of prior years and other village boards that in their opinion failed to act proactively. The current administration is left to figure out how to move the project forward given the serious impact to village taxpayers.

With poise and empathy, Ms. Padoleski, who over 40 years rose through the Village ranks as a clerk, deputy clerk and clerk treasurer. She currently serves as a village trustee and deputy mayor, and took exception to the tone, demeanor and breakdown in communication she has experienced in navigating the fire truck bonding and fire hall addition projects.

Ms. Padoleski was firm, resolute and unflinching in her opinion that she would not be cajoled given the long-term financial implications to taxpayers. Although Ms. Padoleski’s comments were met at times with interruptions and background chatter, I remain optimistic that a return to civil discourse, common sense and mutual goals will resolve this impasse.

Ms. Padoleski by her persistence and demeanor reinforced in my mind what John F. Kennedy meant when he said “we the people are the boss, and we will get the kind of political leadership…we demand and deserve” and I personally thank her for it.

Gabrielle Barone

Medina

Editor:

It is so refreshing to know that people still look out for their neighbors. A big “Thank You!” to the young man who plowed our driveway on Brockville Road this Sunday.

My husband has mobility issues and can barely walk. Our snowblower froze/broke this weekend so my son and I have been shoveling the drive all week. Even so, my husband’s car, my car, as well as an Amazon driver all got stuck in our driveway.

My husband has doctor visits this week and I’ve been sweating bullets as to whether I cleaned it well enough not to get stuck. Your act of kindness is appreciated more than you will ever know!

With appreciation,

Stacey Keon

Murray

Editor:

In response to Mr. Heminway’s editorial dated February 18, 2025.

Mr. Heminway states “That changed with the rapid increase in taxes and other issues like the STAMP wastewater pipeline project that threatened to overwhelm Medina’s infrastructure capabilities and damage our county’s natural resources.” For the fiscal year 2024 my budget dropped the tax rate $2.53, and $1.79 outside the village and inside the village respectively.  The budget I submitted for fiscal year 2025 had a flat tax rate for the whole town of $3.40. Watch the budget meetings to see how that submitted budget was revamped. The STAMP plant expansion is being dealt with by the Town of Shelby combining forces with Orleans County.

Mr. Heminway writes, “The NYS 2021 Comptroller’s Audit Report and the 2024 follow-up audit.” There was no audit done in 2024, there was a review conducted by the Comptroller’s Office. All discrepancies have been corrected.

Heminway continues, “neither the former nor the current Supervisor resolved the discrepancies in the Town’s accounting records and could not provide a reasonable explanation for not correcting the discrepancies.” I was not the town supervisor for the prior years. That being said I inherited the records and I am responsible for the financial records of the Town.

For those not in attendance at this month’s Town Board meeting you would have heard from two independent accounting firms the town hired, explain that there was no corruption, and no money missing. All Town financial records are in order and are being finalized for 2023 and 2024. There will be a Notice published announcing the findings.

The Town has sound financial records and a strong financial footing. You would also have heard the accounting software purchased before I took office was malfunctioning, not all accounts were transferred into the new system by the software company, and even the contracted accountants could not get the software to work correctly. Moving forward the town has hired and is working with an accounting firm to maintain financial records in accordance with the state comptroller’s office.

So, maybe the current Supervisor did fix the towns financial records! Maybe the current Supervisor led the charge to defeat the windmills, fight the STAMP plant expansion, get an alternate cheaper supply of water, while still negotiating with the Village of Medina for cheaper water rates, invested the towns funds in a NYS authorized interest bearing entity (earning the town five figure interest on its funds).

Maybe the new Supervisor helped the highway superintendent purchase a much-needed new plow truck for cash (ARPA funds) while decreasing taxes, and use ARPA funds to fix and update the Town Hall building that needed repairs, all with the Town Board’s approval.

Maybe, just maybe, it takes time to accomplish tasks. I have spent my entire adult life since 19 years old serving and protecting this great country of ours. I am currently serving our great town and will do my best to serve all of the taxpayers of the Town of Shelby, as a life-long, proud Republican.

I welcome Mr. Heminway’s challenge for Town Supervisor. In fact until recently he was a life-long registered Democrat, meaning now he is a RINO, (Republican in Name Only) to fool you into giving him your vote. I only have two questions, why didn’t Mr. Heminway run for office before all these problems were fixed? Why not run as a Democrat?

Respectfully,

Scott Wengewicz

Shelby Town Supervisor

Editor:

Hello, I am Dale Root, the chairman of the Shelby Republican Committee. I would like to remind our Republican residents we are once again starting our campaign season with signing of endorsed candidate petitions.

This year we have two Town Board positions and the position of Town Supervisor needing to be elected. The campaign season starts with signing of petitions beginning Feb. 25 and finishing on April 3 for the primary. Committee members along with candidates will be out circulating petitions. (The current committee members include Bill Bacon, Steve Seitz, CJ Woodruff, James Zelazny, John Pratt, Alana Koneski, Tom Winans and myself). We thank you in advance for your signatures.

After interviewing all that applied, the committee has endorsed 3 candidates: For the Town Board positions Mike Moriarty and Vassilios Bitsas have garnered the Republican endorsement.

Mike is a lifelong resident and family man of Shelby, business owner & the general manager of Pride Pak. In his position as GM, he is responsible for personnel, food safety protocols, works with a host of government agencies and has a strong work ethic. He takes a no-nonsense approach to wasteful spending.

Vassilios lives in the village, has a wonderful background of business experience, with his family they own five businesses. He is hands on with budgeting, finances and personnel. As a committee we found him to be smart & articulate – good qualities for the Town Board.

For the position of Town Supervisor the Republican Committee has endorsed the incumbent Scott Wengewicz. Scott is a Veteran, retired 30-year federal government employee and business owner. In December 2022 he stepped up and accepted the position of supervisor. In his time he has dealt with a flawed bookkeeping system, a bad STAMP project deal, windmill proposals, over-priced water where he negotiated a 50 percent decrease in rate, budget issues. Scott is committed to making sure Shelby residents and their tax dollars are taken care of.

On March 29 we will be hosting our fundraiser spaghetti dinner and meet and greet with the candidates at the Knights of Columbus in Medina. Everyone is welcome. The event will be 5 to 7 p.m. Please contact a member listed above for presale tickets or pay at the door.

Thank you,

Dale Root

Shelby Republican chairman

Editor:

President Trump, who was convicted of 34 felonies, and Elon Musk with Republicans acceding, are looting the government to line their own pockets with massive tax cuts and steering federal contracts their way.

Mr. Musk and his companies were under investigation by the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Department of Justice, the Federal Aviation Administration, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, the Environmental Protection Agency, the National Labor Relations Board, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the Department of Transportation, the Federal Trade Commission and USAID prior to President Trump’s illegal dismissal of 18 Inspectors General.

The job of the Inspectors General is to root out waste, fraud and abuse and they are accountable to Congress and the American people. Mr. Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) is not responsible to Congress or to the American people. They are not vetted; they could be foreign terrorist for all anyone knows. Mr. Trump fired the Inspectors General because they were accountable to the American people.

The budget proposed by the Republicans entails $4.5 trillion tax cut mostly for the wealthy and large corporations with $2 trillion in spending cuts that will jeopardize the health care and food programs for poor and middle-class Americans.

It is important to remember that during President Biden’s administration, the Democrats dramatically reduced the deficits and the ratio of debt to gross domestic product while creating the fastest recovery in decades and strengthening the social safety net, according to the Congressional Budget Office.

The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget estimates that the Republican budget proposal would increase the debt by “nearly $4 trillion.”  Also, they write that the Republican’s budget “economic assumptions are overly aggressive,” meaning that they expect the budget proposals would do more damage to the middle class and increase the debt by a lot more.

Cutting jobs and government agencies randomly with no purpose or plan is wasteful.  Furthermore, Mr. Musk’s DOGE group is rifling through Americans personal information through the IRS, the SSI and the Treasury Department.

They do not have any clearance or Congressional authority. I want readers to know that Congresswoman Claudia Tenney not only accepts this invasion of your privacy, the loss of government safety net and jobs and the looting of your tax dollars but she praises this behavior.

William Fine

Brockport