Don Bent opened opera house in Medina in 1865, a changing Main Street anchor

This image of a newly built Opera House is from the 1879 Illustrated History of Orleans County. Note there originally were three balconies: two on the front of the building and one over the West Center Street stairway entrance.
By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian
“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 6, No. 21

This portrait of Don C. Bent also is from the Illustrated Historical Album of Orleans County in 1879.
MEDINA – In the late nineteenth century, the construction of opera houses proliferated in small towns throughout the country. Generally located in prime downtown locations, these buildings were mixed-use with commercial or retail premises on the ground floor, performance or meeting space above. Few, if any, of these opera houses ever hosted classical opera performances but were so named to claim culture and sophistication.
Bent’s Opera House in Medina was opened to the public on Feb. 28, 1865. Named for its builder, Don Carlos Bent, it has seen many incarnations over the years and still retains its imposing presence as a Main Street anchor. Though Bent died in 1875, his name and legacy endure. Purchased in 2016 by Roger Hungerford and his wife, Heather, the building has since been fully restored.
Don Carlos Bent was born on December 2, 1815, the youngest son of Elijah and Susanah Bent. Some sources cite his birthplace as Orleans, Jefferson County, NY, while others list Shelby, Orleans County. At any rate, the Bents were early settlers in Shelby. Elijah was present at the first town meeting held at Ellicott’s Mill in Shelby on April 7, 1818.
In 1833, he purchased property located on the curve on the approach to Shelby Center. The family built a distinctive home there which still stands at 4536 South Gravel Rd. According to information provided by Miss Edith Colman, whose family later owned the property, the current gambrel roofed barn was constructed in 1928-29 and “was paid for just before the banks closed.”
Don C. Bent inherited the house and 100-acre farm in 1847. He and his wife Hannah Drew had one daughter, Frances M., who predeceased him. Mr. Bent bequeathed the farm of 100 acres to his two granddaughters, Julia M. Gates and Anna B. Gates, “share and share alike.”
He bequeathed the remainder of his estate to his wife Hannah. At the time of his death in 1875, his granddaughters were aged 14 and 13. Julia married Dr. DeWitt Green of Buffalo on June 10, 1885. Walter Colman purchased the property from Julia in 1908 for $6,438. (E. Colman).
Mr. Bent had other business interests besides farming. He had acquired the strategic Main Street corner property in 1854 following a fire which had demolished the previous structure. Opened to the public on Feb. 28, 1865, Medina’s opera house was “larger than Ringuberg Hall in Lockport, Boardwell’s in Albion and slightly larger than the Corinthian Hall in Rochester.” A history of the Opera House prepared by Orleans Renaissance Group in 2013 chronicles the range and variety of shows, performances and meetings hosted in the dramatic third floor public hall.
The first floor has been home to a variety of businesses over the years: Fred A. Sheeley’s Opera House Pharmacy in the 1890’s, Theodorakos Brothers candy, confectionary and ice cream establishment in the 1900’s and subsequent Olympia Lunch operated by the Calafates Brothers. The W. T. Grant variety store occupied the space from 1945 to the early 1970’s when it relocated to the new Maple Ridge Plaza.
Liberty National Bank opened a branch on the first floor in 1972. The location survived several corporate takeovers and name changes: Liberty National Bank, Norstar Bank, Fleet Bank and finally Bank of America which closed in 2009.
Our photographs chronicle some of these changes:

Bedecked in bunting for Old Home Week, August 19-26, 1906

All quiet on Main St., this photo must have been taken on a Sunday. Heritage Men’s Shop, to the north of Bent’s helped date this photo to the late 1970s – early 1980s.
Don C. Bent is buried in Boxwood Cemetery, along with his wife, Hannah, and his parents Elijah and Susanna.
























