U-Haul driver whose passenger died in canal sentenced to state prison
Ryan Armstrong gets 4- to 8-year sentence, maximum as part of plea to manslaughter

Photos by Tom Rivers: Ryan Armstrong leaves Orleans County Court this morning after he was sentenced to state prison for second-degree manslaughter.
ALBION – Ryan Armstrong was sentenced to 4 to 8 years in state prison today in Orleans County Court. He is the driver of U-Haul who led police on a high-speed chase in two counties and plunged the U-Haul into the Erie Canal, causing the death of his passenger.
Armstrong, in County Court on Feb. 11, pleaded guilty to second-degree manslaughter for reckless conduct that led to the death Reginald Russell, 56, on Sept. 2, 2025.
Armstrong, 43, in court today said he was deeply sorry for his actions on Sept. 2 that led to Russell’s death. He apologized to Russell family. Several of Russell’s family members were in court this morning at the sentencing.
“I hope the Lord and the families involved will forgive me,” Armstrong said.
Assistant District Attorney Daniel Punch said Armstrong put “countless people at risk” in the high-speed chase from Brockport to Murray. He turned what could have been a simply shoplifting arrest into a death that has devastated the Russell family, Punch told County Court Judge Sanford Church.
Punch said Armstrong has an arrest record going back to 1999 and has chosen a life of crime with drugs, assaults and vehicle and traffic violations.
Public defender Joanne Best said Armstrong and Russell were both heavily under the influence of drugs on Sept. 2.
They were stealing items from the Walgreens in Brockport at about 6:30 p.m. that day. They were putting merchandise in a U-Haul truck when law enforcement were called.

Law enforcement and firefighters check the scene on Sept. 2, 2025 after a U-Haul went into the Erie Canal in Murray, just east of Bennetts Corners Road. Reginald Russell, 56, drowned in the canal.
Monroe County Sheriff’s deputies and Brockport police officers attempted to stop the vehicle once it was on the move but Armstrong refused, leading law enforcement on a pursuit throughout the west side of Monroe County and into Orleans County. Armstrong drove the U-Haul at speeds of 85 miles per hour from Clarkson into Ogden, back through Brockport and eventually onto a canal service road in Murray.
Police used spike strips in the area of Bennetts Corners Road, where one of the vehicle’s tires became deflated. Armstrong then drove onto the southside of canal pathway before driving the U-Haul into the water, just east of Bennetts Corners Road.
He then swam across the canal to the other side of the canal, and then fled on foot. He was apprehended on the northside of the canal through the aid of drone technology.
After the U-Haul plunged into the water, Russell exited the vehicle. Deputies could see he was struggling to swim. They jumped into the canal to rescue Russell, but lost sight of him when he went under in the murky water.
Best, the public defender, said Armstrong didn’t intend to cause Russell’s death.
“He has accepted responsibility because he knows his actions were reckless,” Best said. “He is very remorseful.”
She asked for the minimum possible sentence for 3 to 6 years in prison. She said Armstrong has been active in a counseling program in the Orleans County Jail and is in a much better position mentally after being off drugs for many months.
The charge of second-degree manslaughter would normally have a maximum of 7 ½ to 15 years in state prison. The plea agreement reduced the maximum to 4 to 8 years.
County Court Judge Sanford Church gave Armstrong the maximum in the plea deal. The judge noted Armstrong has a long criminal history, put many people in the danger in the high-speed chase and ultimately caused the death of Russell.
The judge also fined Armstrong $2,500 and assessed $375 in other court surcharges and fees.



















