Murder trial ends for Magee with judge to issue decision Dec. 4, possibly sooner

Photo by Tom Rivers: Noah Magee walks out of the County Clerk’s Building, where there is an entrance to the County Courthouse, after the trial concluded today where he faces second-degree murder. Judge Sanford Church scheduled Dec. 4 for when he will announce his decision in the case, although he could issue a written decision sooner.

ALBION – Noah Magee’s attorneys say he shouldn’t face any charges for a Feb. 8 collision that resulted in the death of Roger Kingdollar III.

It was merely an accident and Magee, 19, shouldn’t be charged with second-degree murder, leaving the scene of an accident, reckless driving or failure to keep right, his attorney, Paul Vacca Jr. said in closing statements this morning in the Orleans County Court.

Kingdollar, 24, was driving a dirt bike on McNamar Road at about 4 p.m. He was on a lawn beyond the north side of the road. Two of his friends were on four-wheelers, and Vacca said they were weaving in the road. Magee had just turned from Angevine Road onto McNamar when he was confronted with Kingdollar on the north side and the four wheelers in the road, Vacca said.

Magee then tried to safely get off the road, and collided with Kingdollar, Vacca said.

He described Kingdollar as driving the dirt bike recklessly, doing wheelies and weaving.

“My client is the victim of circumstance here,” Vacca told Judge Sanford Church, who is presiding over the case and will decide Magee’s fate. “The dirt bike was the cause of the accident.”

Magee last week waived his right to trial by jury. In a bench trial, the judge decides if the defendant is guilty.

District Attorney Joe Cardone said it was “preposterous” to say Kingdollar was at fault in the accident. A surveillance video from a neighbor shows Kingdollar riding just north of the road in the grass. He wasn’t doing any wheelies.

The video shows Magee cross the center line, go past the opposite lane and shoulder of the road and then strike Kingdollar in the grass, Cardone said.

“He drove his vehicle in the path of this victim,” he said.

Magee was very familiar with the intersection and road, Cardone said. Magee traveled the road almost daily going from his sister’s in Batavia to his girlfriend’s.

He and Kingdollar also knew each other from years of “animosity,” Cardone said. Kingdollar previously tried to run Magee off the road, and Magee threw a rock at Kingdollar while he was driving a vehicle, Cardone said. Magee felt like Kingdollar had “constantly terrorized” him and his friends who also enjoyed dirt bikes and four-wheelers, Cardone said.

In text messages with a friend, Magee was urged to find Kingdollar and “beat his ass,” Cardone said in his closing statement. Magee allegedly told the friend in a text he was waiting for the right time.

Cardone said that moment came on Feb. 8, when Magee rounded the corner of Angevine and McNamar and saw Kingdollar without a helmet on the dirt bike.

Magee didn’t intend to kill Kingdollar. He just meant to intimidate him and brush him off, Cardone said.

Magee hit the gas pedal and drove towards Kingdollar, but then hit the brake just before the collision, Cardone said. The left side of Magee’s 2006 Chevrolet Silverado truck hit the left side of the dirt bike’s handlebars. Cardone noted the 9,200-pound truck far outweighed the 236-pound dirt bike.

The collision caused a fatal fracture in Kingdollar’s neck, Cardone said citing the testimony of the medical examiner who performed an autopsy. Kingdollar was knocked into a ditch by the road.

James Vacca, Paul Vacca’s brother and part of the defense, said Kingdollar may have suffered the fatal neck fracture when he was moved from the ditch using ropes without any neck support.

Vacca said Magee decelerated to 24 miles per hour and didn’t have any intoxicants in his system, while Kingdollar had three types of THC from using marijuana that day and from chronic use.

“That may have been a contributing factor,” James Vacca said.

Cardone refuted that contention, saying Kingdollar did nothing to cause the collision.

The lack of any intoxicants in Magee’s system also shows he was clear-minded in driving towards Kingdollar, Cardone said.

Vacca also described the collision as being similar to people walking in a busy mall and rounding a corner and bumping into each other.

“This is not an accident,” Cardone said about the collision. “This is not two people running into each other in the mall.”

While Magee didn’t intend to kill Kingdollar, Magee made intentional choices that led to Kingdollar’s death, Cardone said.

Magee would face a more serious charge if he intentionally tried to kill Kingdollar. But Cardone said the evidence shows Magee tried to scare Kingdollar, by grazing him instead of making a direct hit. And Magee certainly wouldn’t have tried to intentionally kill Kingdollar in front of his friends who were on four-wheelers, Cardone said.

With the second-degree murder charge, the defendant doesn’t need to have tried to kill the other person. Cardone said the defendant needs to show an extreme disregard for human life, and that is the situation with Magee who struck the dirt bike with a much heavier pickup truck.

“He thought he would just brush the victim and move on, but he totally miscalculated,” Cardone said. “He badly misjudged. Any reasonable driver who saw people coming in the opposite direction would have slowed down and not sped up.”

After the collision Magee drove off but came back to get a headlight in the road. One of Kingdollar’s friends allegedly threatened Magee’s life and Magee fled the scene out of concern for his safety, James Vacca said.

Cardone said Magee fled and attempted to hide the truck on a dirt lane off Chugg Road. He only returned to the scene after being persuaded by his sister.

The trial is the last one for Cardone in his 33 years as the county’s district attorney. He told the court today he has tried to be a voice for victims of crimes in the community.

“I ask the court to do justice for the Kingdollar family,” Cardone said.

Judge Sanford Church didn’t make a ruling today. He scheduled 1:30 p.m. on Dec. 4 to announce his decision in the case, although he said he may decide the outcome sooner.