local history

In 1979, community created keepsake of favorite recipes

A treasury of recipes was compiled by the Orleans County Historical Association in 1979.

Posted 23 March 2025 at 3:02 pm

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian 

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 12

ALBION – “Tucked among the keepsakes that reflect the earlier years of this unique county are the recipes found in this treasury. Some are copied, some created, some from yesteryear and some from today. All with a special touch from a special person – the one who so generously shared their favorite recipe.”

“Favorite Recipes of Orleans County” is a spiral bound community cookbook produced in 1979 by the Orleans County Historical Association. It was printed in Albion by the Eddy Printing Company. Mary Shuler and Millie Scofield were co-chairwomen.

A hefty tome, with over 300 pages, it is double the size of a regular community cookbook. It includes the staple community cookbook recipes one would expect but also includes heirloom recipes from grandmothers and great-grandmothers, thus linking back to the early years of the county.

Mrs. Charles Defendorf (Rose Hart) submitted a recipe for Salt Raising Bread which was passed down from her great grandmother, Matilda West, 1826-1899. It begins:

“Start bread at night. Scald 2tbsp. of cornmeal and ½ tsp each of salt, sugar, and soda in 1 cup sweet milk. Cover and set in warm place overnight…..”

A recipe for Gingerbread submitted by Doris Bannister is traced back to a descendant of John Proctor, “the Paul Revere of the Ridge” who, in 1813, alerted the residents along Ridge Rd. that “the British were coming.”

A recipe for Corn Bread which includes yeast, mashed potato and cornmeal is traced back to the Matthew Dunham family, the earliest settlers in the Lakeside area of the Town of Carlton.

A recipe for Homemade Ale copied from the Journals of Samuel Brent, Canterbury, England, dates to 1829. It was submitted by his great-granddaughter, Betty Hurd.

Not surprisingly, there are many variations of apple recipes: Apple Grunt, Apple John, Apple Roll, Elegant Apple Pie, French Apple Pie, Apple Cake, Apple Chip Cake, Applesauce Cake, Apple Pie Cake, Apple Pudding Cake, Glazed German Apple Bread, Apple Stuffed Pork Chops, and Squirrel in Apple Bake.

Several recipes reflect the strong English heritage of the county’s population: Grandma’s English Trifle, English mincemeat and 19th Century Whig Rolls.

So many recipes with intriguing names: Taylor Duff, Tell Your Neighbor Cake, Seafoam Salad, Pickled Seckel Pears and The Old Stand By, to mention but a few.

Interspersed with the recipes are nuggets of local history such as: how Troutburg got its name, the Orleans Meat Processing Company in Albion, canning in Holley, the cheese factories. A section on Remedies includes instructions on how to make soap using potash, lard, and rosin, how to remove wrinkles, make a liniment or a mustard plaster.

“Favorite Recipes of Orleans County” is a heartfelt homage to the families who have lived in Orleans County and to the cooks who sustained them. If you don’t own a copy, keep an eye out at yard sales and book sales. If you are lucky, you may even find an edited version, with the former owner’s comments critiquing the recipes!

Presbyterian Church had 2 different buildings in Knowlesville with first built in 1832

Posted 16 March 2025 at 4:37 pm

First building was demolished in 1893, and second fell into disrepair and was razed in 1969

The first Presbyterian Church in Knowlesville was constructed in 1832, and then demolished in 1893 when a new building was erected.

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian 

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 11


“Like all things earthly, passing away,

“The old brick church may no longer stay,

“Though dear to our hearts as our childhood home,

“Within its walls we may no longer come.

“Now lingering near the old church ground,

“We hear the busy workmen’s sound

“And see the fragments here and there

“Of what was once our house of prayer”


These lines, composed by Mrs. I.O. Root in 1893 concerning the demolition of the first Presbyterian Church building in Knowlesville, still resonate. They capture that acute feeling of loss that is felt when a church closes and remind us that nothing is permanent.

The early settlers in this area, having first built their homes, soon turned their attention to providing a place of worship. On August 27, 1817, the following eleven people convened at the Oak Orchard schoolhouse and formed the First Religious Society of the Town of Ridgeway: Orange Wells, Leonard Dresser, Daniel Gates, Elizabeth Whipple, Mary Ann Taylor, Lois Robbins and Sarah Lawrence, Dr. William White, Archy B. Lawrence, Martha Marsh and Anna Sheldon.

At that time the township comprised the present townships of Ridgeway, Barre, Shelby, Yates, Carlton and Gaines, all but four of the present towns which had not yet been named.

At first, the Society affiliated with the Congregationalists, but in 1820 resolved unanimously to unite with the Presbytery of Rochester. For the first fifteen years, meetings were held in homes, schoolhouses and barns.

The Holland Land Company provided a tract of one hundred acres to the first organized religious society in a township. The new trustees secured this “Gospel lot.”

With the completion of the Erie Canal, a settlement grew in the area later named Knowlesville. In 1831, the Society voted to accept a piece of land from John Aldrich and to purchase as much as was necessary for the site of a church building from John Vedder at the rate of $50 per half-acre.

A Federal style brick building was erected at a cost of $3,500. William Knowles provided half of the cost. The building was dedicated in 1832 and remodeled in 1861. It was demolished in 1893. A second brick church was built on the same site at a cost of $12,000. The Gospel Lot was sold at that time, and the proceeds were used for construction costs.

The second Knowlesville Presbyterian Church building, constructed in 1893, was demolished in 1969.

The “New Brick Church,” Victorian Romanesque in style, was dedicated in 1894. It flourished for many years, but closed in 1964, due to declining attendance. The parish was dissolved, and the physical assets were turned over to the Rochester Presbytery. The church building was demolished in 1969 as it had fallen into disrepair.

Today, a vacant lot remains on the north side of the street where the church was once located but its presence is still remembered by the street name: Presbyterian Street.

Photo from 1890s shows a much different Kuckville hamlet

This photograph from the Orleans County Department of History collection is labeled “Kuckville in the early ninty’s (sic). Looking east.”

Posted 9 March 2025 at 5:48 pm

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 10

KUCKVILLE – A visual puzzle!

The scene shown in this photograph from the late 1890’s does not resemble the Kuckville you are familiar with as you breeze through on Route 18, unaware that you are even crossing a creek, and, unless you are driving north on Lakeside Road, perhaps even unaware of the hamlet.

The barn and bridge shown in the photograph no longer exist, and the area is wooded now, but the bridge abutments are still visible. Writing in 1981, Betsy Hoffman, a former Town of Carlton Historian, explained the changes:

“Prior to 1933, the road now known as Church Street came into the hamlet of Kuckville from the west, continued on to the east across the old bridge with the Kuck estate on the left and Joe Nicholson’s house on the right sitting on what is now the middle of what now is Route 18. The house was moved from that position to where Townsends store is now. The store as we know it in 1981 is part of the old Joe Nicholson house”

Detail of Kuckville from the 1913 Atlas of Niagara and Monroe counties which shows the original road configuration.

The Medina Daily Journal of March 27, 1930 noted that “Work has begun on the bridge at Kuckville.” The new road bypassed the hamlet. Identified on maps as the Roosevelt Highway and the Great Lakes Seaway trail, the road is locally referred to as “Route 18.” The “old” bridge across Johnson Creek was dismantled in the 1940s.

Hoffman’s notes continue with details on “who lived where” that delight residents and their descendants, fodder for after-dinner discussions and ramblings:

“Prior to 1933, Kuckville remained much the same as it did in years previous with John Cann’ s store setting next to the church on the northwest corner of the road. To the south of Cann’s  store set the coopershop…To the west was a large building that stored the barrels, and west of that was Howard Miller’s garage which set next to his house which is now owned by Jack Szyikowski”

Local history at its finest. Should any readers be interested in these specific accounts, please contact me at Catherine.cooper@orleanscountyny.gov.

Medina Historical Society program puts focus on pioneers of Orleans County

Photo by Ginny Kropf: Board members of the Medina Historical Society who presented a program on the pioneer history of Orleans County at their opening meeting of 2025 are, in front from left, Barb Filipiak, Gail Miller, Shane Sia (Ridgeway and Shelby historian), Georgia Thomas, Erica Wanecski and Orleans County Historian Catherine Cooper. At rear are Kay VanNostrand and Medina Historical Society president Reinhard Rogowski.

By Ginny Kropf, correspondent Posted 7 March 2025 at 8:00 am

MEDINA – The Medina Historical Society’s first meeting of 2025 took place Feb. 24 at Lee-Whedon Memorial Library and featured a program on the pioneer history of Orleans County.

In honor of the county’s bicentennial this year, Orleans County historian and Medina Historical Society board member Catherine Cooper suggested a program focusing on stories of the early pioneer settlers and the hardships they faced. She got the idea from Amanda Burris of Texas, who reached out to her over a year ago, explaining her connection to one of the early settlers. Burris’s ancestor is Aretas Pierce, whose stories she heard while growing up. Burris runs a recording studio and was interested in re-issuing the stories and also creating an audio version.

“With the upcoming bicentennial, the timing was perfect,” Cooper said. “Her book became available Jan. 1, so I proposed we devote the February program to a presentation on the pioneers and their stories.”

Board member Georgia Thomas took the reins and organized the entire event, Cooper added.

Historical Society president Reinhard Rogowski welcomed guests and described Orleans County in the early years.

“It was heavily wooded north of the woods, resulting in its being called the Black North,” Rogowski said. “Pioneers had to deal with bears, beavers, panthers, rattlesnakes and malaria, along with starvation.”

Rogowski then introduced board members, each of whom gave a presentation on a different town in Orleans County.

Barb Filipiak talked about Barre; Gail Miller, Clarendon, Carlton and Yates; Shane Sia, Ridgeway and Shelby; Georgia Thomas, Gaines; Erica Wanecski, Knowlesville; Catherine Cooper, Eagle Harbor, Kendall and Murray; Kay VanNostrand, Medina, Holley, Hulberton and Hindsburg.

In the late 1860s, the early pioneers of Orleans County were encouraged to write about their experiences, their journey here, how they settled the land and their hardships.

“Early pioneers were very conscious of their place in history. Their heart-felt stories provide a unique insight into the early history of the county,” Cooper said. “Their accounts were beautifully written, and then along came Arad Thomas and put them into a book.”

At this time, Pierce’s Pioneers of Orleans County is available as a set of three titles, including a pioneer cookbook, on Amazon.com. One volume may be purchased, or the entire set. T-Shirts, like the board members wore during their presentations, will soon be available on Burris’ site – https://folk.studio/blog/

In honor of the county’s bicentennial, the Medina Historical Society is planning to devote a future meeting to the history of Medina and how it was laid out by Ebenezer Mix, in a program by former Medina mayor Adam Tabelski.

Meetings are at 7 p.m. the fourth Monday of the month through May, with programs resuming in September at Lee-Whedon Library.

Orleans County Historian Catherine Cooper provided this photograph of the Pioneers of Orleans County, taken by George P. Hopkins at their 11th annual meeting June 19, 1869 in Albion.

Group of ‘Rebekahs,’ shown in 1927, were part of Odd Fellows, offering hospitality

Front row: Ida Boyce, Ethel Croach - Sec. Treas., Bessie Gaze - District Deputy, Jessie Breitbeck, Harriet Bulmore. Back row: Addie Servoss, Alice Brown, Georgianna Strouse, Lina Blood, Vernita Boyce and May Montgomery.

Posted 2 March 2025 at 1:17 pm

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian 

“Illuminating Orleans” – Vol. 5, No. 9

MEDINA – A friend came upon this intriguing A.J. Richards photograph of a group of ladies this week and rescued it from the ignominy of a Lockport thrift store bin. Not only is the photo in good condition but wonder of wonders – the names are clearly written on the reverse!

However, the date, nature of the group, and the occasion were lacking. Naturally the challenge was accepted!

Judging by the clothing, the period appears to be late 1920’s. The ladies are wearing decorative collar sashes, so they are obviously members of a group or club. The clue in determining the date and subject of the photograph turned out to be the words “District Deputy” which follow Bessie Gaze’s name on the reverse. A search of the New York State Historic Newspapers unearthed the following paragraph in the Medina Daily Journal of May 20, 1927:

“The Welcome Rebekah Lodge of Medina was highly honored at a New York State Rebekah assembly held at Buffalo this week by having one of its members appointed to a state office.

Mrs. Jessie Breitbeck, past District Deputy, was installed as assembly conductor.

Mrs. Bessie Gaze also received her appointment as District Deputy, President of the Orleans District.”

The Daughters of Rebekah, generally referred to as the Rebekahs, was founded in 1851 by then U.S. Vice-President, Schuyler Colfax. It is the women’s group associated with the Independent Order of Odd Fellows (I.O.O.F.). The Odd Fellows originated in England in the 1700’s as a mutual aid society to assist smaller tradesmen (“odd fellows”) and their families when in need.

The name “Rebekah” honors the biblical character who offered hospitality to a humble stranger.

The group’s stated objectives were to “aid in the establishment and maintenance of Homes for aged and indigent Odd Fellows and their wives, the care, education, and support of orphans of deceased Odd Fellows and deceased sisters of the Rebekah degree” as well as to cultivate social relations among these groups.

The Medina Welcome Rebekah Lodge, No. 146 was instituted on Feb. 6, 1895, by Charles M. Morgan, Grand Master. At that time the membership boasted 38 “brothers” and 32 “sisters”. The I.O.O.F. Lodge rooms were in the Downs & Kearney Block, 108 West Center St., Medina.

Armed with Medina directories from 1908 and 1941, and using the online Orleans genweb site, we pieced together the following information about the ladies in the photo:

  • Lina Blood was the wife of Seldon P. Blood, a feed store owner. They lived at 208 West Oak Orchard St., Medina. Lina died in 1949 and is buried in Boxwood Cemetery.
  • Ida Boyce was the wife of Charles W. Boyce, a manager at the N.L.& O. Power Company. They lived at 618 West Center St., Medina. Ida died in 1989 and is buried in Boxwood Cemetery,
  • Vernita Boyce was the wife of Clarence H. Boyce, an electrical contractor. They lived at 224 Highland Ave., Medina. Vernita died in 1971 and is buried in Boxwood Cemetery.
  • Jessie Breitbeck was the wife of Fred C. Breitbeck, a foundry worker. They lived at 1031 Gwinn St., Medina. Jessie died in 1983 and is buried in Boxwood Cemetery.
  • Alice Brown was the wife of William N. Brown, a Post Office carrier. They lived at 305 Park Ave., Medina. Alice died in 1950 and is buried in Boxwood Cemetery.
  • Harriett Bulmore was the wife of Fred Bulmore who owned the Synthetic Granite Vault Co. which was located at 514 Erie St., Medina. The couple resided at 117 Frank St. Harriett died in 1953 and is buried in West Ridgeway Cemetery.
  • Ethel Croach was the wife of Arthur W. Croach, a rural delivery mail carrier. They lived at 110 Elizabeth St., Medina. Ethel is buried in West Ridgeway Cemetery.
  • Bessie Gaze was the wife of W. Henry Gaze, a foundry worker. They lived at 207 William St., Medina. Bessie died in 1937 and is buried in West Ridgeway Cemetery.
  • May E. Montgomery, a linotype operator at the Daily Journal, lived at 210 William St., Medina. She died in 1955 and is buried in Boxwood Cemetery.
  • Addie Servoss was the wife of Burt L. Servoss. She died in 1938 and is buried in Boxwood Cemetery.
  • Georgianna Strouse was the widow of Harvey Strouse. She lived at 409 South Academy St., Medina. She was a seamstress at the Robert H. Newell Shirt Factory for many years, died in 1970 and is buried in Millville Cemetery.

Our thanks to Todd Belfield for rescuing this photo which provides a glimpse into the past.

Directory from 1903 shows forgotten livestock breeds in Orleans County

Posted 24 February 2025 at 8:46 am

Advertisement from the Directory of Orleans County, 1903

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian 

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 8

Poland China? Ayrshire? Rambouillet? Are these familiar names?

They would have been recognizable to many Orleans County residents over one hundred years ago. Poland China swine, Ayrshire cattle, Rambouillet sheep were some of the many different breeds raised in the county according to the Directory of Orleans County, 1903.

This amazing publication (click here) is accessible online courtesy of the Central Library of Rochester and Monroe County and is well worth downloading and perusing.

This Directory lists the residents of the county and their occupations, an ambitious undertaking. It was one of several such directories compiled by the George Hanford Company of Elmira, NY. So many aspects of social change are obvious when glancing through the pages.

Today’s column was prompted by the two-page listing of Livestock Breeders and Dealers in the Business section. Even a portion of the list illustrates the variety of livestock being raised at that time:

From the Directory of Orleans County, 1903

The list totals sixty breeders and dealers, some handled more than one breed. As we examine the variety of breeds represented, we are inferring that the prevalence of breeders for any one breed equated roughly with the breed’s popularity.

Cattle

Jersey cattle were first bred in the British Channel Islands and introduced to the U.S. in the 1850s.

It appears that Orleans County farmers favored Jersey cattle, with eight breeders listed. Jersey cows are small and noted for producing milk with a high butter-fat content. Ayrshire cattle, who also produce high-quality milk, were also raised, with just one breeder listed.

Two beef-producing breeds, Durham Shorthorns and Herefords were represented with two Shorthorn breeders and one Hereford breeder listed.

Sheep

Shropshire sheep are medium sized with dark faces and feet.

Raising sheep was a significant element of the farm economy in 1903.  In the Town of Barre alone, fifty-nine farmers listed sheep among their holdings. A quick tally of the number of sheep in Barre came to 2,500.

Shropshire sheep were the most prevalent in the County in the early 1900s. Of the sixty breeders listed, ten bred Shropshire sheep. Several other breeds were also raised: Cheviot, Delaine Merino, Dorset, Merino, Oxforddown, Rambouillet, Southdown, Tunis, and Yorkshiredown. The Shropshire flocks were raised for meat, as were the Cheviots and Dorsets. Delaine Merino, Merino, and Rambouillet sheep were bred for wool.

Merino sheep yield very fine soft wool.

Pigs

A colorful variety of pigs were raised, the Chester Whites being the most prevalent. Originating from Chester County, Pa., these white pigs with droopy ears produced a high-quality meat. Seven livestock owners handled this breed.

The reddish-brown Duroc-Jersey pigs which were noted for producing very flavorful pork were raised, as was the distinctive Berkshire pig, which is black with a white snout.

Several farmers raised the quaintly named Poland China pig, the oldest American swine breed. Related to the Berkshire pig, the Poland China pig is also black but distinguished by its white face and feet and a white tip at the end of the tail.

A trove of valentines from century ago discovered in attic

A selection of Valentine’s Day cards from the 1920s was recently discovered in an attic.

Posted 14 February 2025 at 7:40 am

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 7

Local historians love to hear the phrases “We found these in the attic” or “We found these in the barn.”

Many charming Valentine’s Day cards from the 1920s were discovered in the attic of a home near Kenyonville Road and were donated by Duane and Pat Payne of Medina. One cannot but marvel at the fact that they survived critters, weather and time.

“Ephemera” is the term used to describe paper items that have short-term usefulness – receipts, bills, cards etc. We can appreciate why these cards were not thrown out, they have a lasting visual appeal and no doubt they held a sentimental value for the person who put them aside.

According to the Greeting Card Association, Valentine’s Day is second to Christmas as the most popular holiday for people to send greeting cards. The city of Worcester, Mass. became, by chance, the center for the printing of commercial Valentine cards after Esther Howland was inspired by European lace-layered cards in the 1840s. She used her father’s printing business to create her own multi-layered card creations and developed a very successful business.

The cards in this donated collection were produced by the Whitney Valentine Company, also located in Worcester, Mass. In the late 19th century, George C. Whitney purchased Howland’s firm as well as other Valentine card companies. He developed mass-produced greeting cards which were very popular.

Valentine postcards from the Payne collection.

Valentine’s Day postcards were also popular and just required a 1-cent stamp. The design and verse were on the front, message and mailing address on the back. The sender’s message could be read by everybody. The handwritten message on one postcard written by Joyce and sent to Ronald reads “If you think a lot of a person, why isn’t Valentines Day a good time to say so?”

But where could you purchase cards to mail to your Valentine? Stationery supplies were sold at drugstores. The 1903 Directory of Orleans County lists the following suppliers under the heading Stationery:

BISHOP, FRANCIS M. – Public Square, Holley

CENTRAL DRUG STORE – Main St, Albion

MILLENER, WILLIAM S.  – Public Square, Holley

WRIGHT & ROSS – Main St., Lyndonville

Generally, the images and greetings were polite, this one is a little saucier.

Do you save cards? If you read this column, chances are you do! Why not put some aside in an attic or barn to tantalize future generations?

Tetanus from hemlock timber left Jeddo man with lockjaw a century ago

Posted 8 February 2025 at 9:18 am

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian 

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 6

JEDDO – This headline which appeared in the July 29, 1926, Niagara Gazette caught our attention. According to the article, George Prudom of Jeddo felt unwell and thought he was having an attack of rheumatism.

Dr. Thurman of Lyndonville was called, he suspected lockjaw, but Mr. Prudom could not recall having received a scratch of any kind that might have caused the infection.

Dr.  Russell, a specialist from Buffalo, was consulted. He agreed with the lockjaw diagnosis and prescribed a lockjaw serum treatment which was effective and after a week, Mr. Prudom was able to open his jaws slightly. He recovered fully after some time.

Upon reflection, the only incident that Mr. Prudom could recall was that a short time previously, he had been handling a heavy piece of hemlock timber which had fallen on his foot. At the time, the injury was slight, and Mr. Prudom paid no attention to it. He surmised that the infection may have been caused by a scratch from a hemlock splinter.

However, hemlock trees are not poisonous, so Mr. Prudom’s lockjaw was not caused directly by the hemlock log but was most likely the result of an infection caused by tetanus spores entering through a cut or scratch occasioned by the fall of the log onto his foot.

Hemlock trees are native to this area and were growing in abundance when the first settlers came here. They used hemlock splints for the roofs of their log cabins. Lacking furniture, they made comfortable beds from hemlock boughs laid on the floor and covered with blankets.

When laying the first roads from Ridge Road to the lake, Jeremiah Brown, the first Commissioner of Highways in the Town of Ridgeway wrote: “We would lay a road, following the lines between lots to the lake, keeping us busy all day. At night, we would make a fire, cut some hemlock boughs for bed and sleep soundly all night.”

There is a plant known as poison hemlock which is highly toxic to humans and animals. It contains coniine, an alkaloid capable of inducing paralysis. Hemlock trees and the poison hemlock plant are unrelated, they share a name because their leaves emit a similar odor. The roots of this plant were an ingredient in witches’ brew in Shakespeare’s Macbeth: “Root of hemlock, digg’d in the dark”

Hemlocks are large pyramid-shaped evergreen trees which resemble Christmas trees. They can attain a height of 60 – 70 feet. There must once have been a significant stand of hemlocks on the road which was named Hemlock Ridge Road which runs east-west through the Towns of Shelby and Barre. Some hemlocks may still be seen along the road. Hemlock trees may also be found in Mt. Albion Cemetery.

Oxen provided critical muscle for pioneers of Orleans County

Posted 2 February 2025 at 1:18 pm

Historian urges community to embrace for painted Ox statues for county’s bicentennial celebration

Orly the Ox was featured in the Nov. 30 Medina of Parade of Lights. It was the debut of Orly in his mascot costume. The vest includes the names of Orleans County towns, villages and hamlets. The statue was propped up on a trailer for the parade. The County Bicentennial Committee would like to see more of the statues painted to celebrate the county’s 200th anniversary.

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, Number 5

ALBION – Hoag Library patrons may very well wonder if they are experiencing auditory hallucinations.

“Did I just hear a moo?”

Yes, Orly the Ox is temporarily “Ox in Residence” at Hoag. He emits a hearty “Moo” from time to time. Owned by Cornell Cooperative Extension, Orly is the first ox in Orleans County’s bicentennial herd. Scenes depicting his role in agriculture were created by artist Stacey Kirby Steward.

Orly’s “ambassador” is a nimble two-legged character with a winning personality. Orly in costume has proved to be very popular. He has recently made appearances at the Canal Culvert and and at various businesses throughout the county.

Charged with honoring the county’s 200th year since its political formation, the Bicentennial Committee chose the ox as its mascot, since oxen were indispensable to the early settlers. The ox also represents the importance of agriculture to the county and honors all of those who labor in the fields.


‘Slow, steady, strong and sure-footed, oxen were more suited to the rough terrain than horses. They could pull heavier loads than horses, and they could pull steadily for longer periods of time.’


The settlers who moved here in the early 1800s provided detailed written accounts of their journeys here and of their experiences as they tried to wrest arable land from deep woods. They used oxen to haul their wagons westward, an arduous trip which took from three to five weeks. Slow, steady, strong and sure-footed, oxen were more suited to the rough terrain than horses. They could pull heavier loads than horses, and they could pull steadily for longer periods of time.

Oxen are castrated male cattle, four years old, who have been trained to work. They can weigh up to 2,600 pounds, depending on weight. “Oxen” refers to more than one ox. A “yoke of oxen” refers to working pair, connected by a wooden beam (the yoke) on their necks, which allows them to pull together

The following are but a few references to oxen from first-person accounts published in the Pioneer History of Orleans County by Arad Thomas, 1871:

David Matson raised the first log-house in Clarendon in 1814. He sold the horses which he brought into the country, having no use for them in the forest. He bought oxen which drew the logs for the first shanty.

Nathaniel Brown came to Kendall with three yoke of oxen and wagon.

Adin Manley arrived in Kendall in 1815. The following fall he returned to Massachusetts and married. In February 1816, he set out with three yoke of oxen and a covered wagon, for his new home in Kendall. Unfortunately, that was the “year of no summer”:

“We had three yoke of oxen and nothing for them to eat, this was the worst of all. We turned them into the woods and cut browse for them, but the poor cattle suffered much.”

As the woods were cleared, oxen hauled logs and pulled the stubborn tree stumps out of the ground. Oxen were used in Orleans County for quite some time. As late as 1871, the Orleans County Agricultural Society Fair held in Albion included a category for Working Oxen, one for the Best Pair of Working Oxen and one for the Best String of Ten Yoke of Oxen.

The Bicentennial Committee encourages businesses and community organizations to participate in the “Oxen of Orleans County” Public Art project. We hope to populate Orleans County with an artistic & historic ox trail. Several are already on order!

Details are available on the Orleans County Tourism Page. Click here for more information.

Orly the Ox will be out highlighting people, places and things in Orleans County this year. Orly recently stopped by Canalside Tattoo Company in Medina where he got some ink from owner Shawn Ramsey. It was actually a sticker. To request a visit from Orly the mascot, click here for more information.

Orly also was hyped for the Buffalo Bills playoff games. Here he is wearing a Josh Allen jersey. Orly’s adventures can be followed on the Orleans County Tourism’s social media.

Early settlers in Orleans were plagued by fever and ague

Posted 26 January 2025 at 11:58 am

‘Our county was very unhealthy until 1828.’ – Jeremiah Brown, pioneer in Ridgeway

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, Number 4

“About the first of the next September (1816), myself and my wife and one child were taken sick, and until December following, we suffered everything but Death. Often during that time while myself and my wife were confined to our beds, our children were crying for food and neither of us had strength sufficient to enable us to get to the cupboard to help them.” (Jeremiah Brown, Ridgeway)

This account describes an illness encountered by the early settlers of Orleans County, they referred to it as “a fever and ague “(sounds like “ay-goo”). It was a miserable, debilitating condition which affected everybody, even the strongest person. It persisted for months and was recurrent.

“Our children, then four in number, had their full share of fever and ague. It was painful to see the little ones draw up to the fire while suffering the chill, then see them retire to their beds, tormented by the raging thirst and fever following the chills, while their mother could do little for them, except to supply their frequent requests for water.” (Asa Sanford, Barre)

In Albion, Lansing Bailey was sorely afflicted: his wife and brother died of the fever and ague in August 1813. After his wife’s funeral, some friends who lived on the Ridge took the children home with them. Bailey returned to his “desolate house to spend one of the loneliest nights I ever knew.”

The illness was thought to be part of the acclimating process, or “a penalty to Nature.” It occurred “whenever an opening was made in the forest; or the earth was turned over for the first time to the hot rays of the summer sun.”

Asa Sanford ascribed it to “clearing trees and building dams.” In 1817, Henry McCall and Robert Perry built a dam and mills at Sandy Creek to serve the twenty families living there. The dam raised the water to cover eighteen to twenty acres.

“The water killed the timber, and a terrible sickness followed among the inhabitants, about one quarter of whom died in one season. The well persons were not numerous enough to take care of the sick and bury the dead, and settlers from other neighborhoods came there and helped the needy ones. The mill dam was taken down and the sickness disappeared.”

We now understand that this was a malarial-type illness, caused by the mosquitoes who thrived in those water-logged areas. Those who had access to a doctor were prescribed “quinine and the blue pill” but that many people “just let it work itself off the natural way.” Adin Manly mentioned that some early Kendall residents drank whiskey to keep off the fever and ague.

Dr. White, who attended Lansing Bailey told Bailey that he could prescribe something that would stop it, but that he would be well advised not to take it. Bailey said that he would take it on his own responsibility. Dr. White gave him arsenic, Bailey took it.

“It stopped the ague, but I did not get well for a long time.”

Jeremiah Brown observed that “our county was very unhealthy until 1828.”

Asa Sanford recalled that “as the county was cleared up and the lowlands drained of their surface water, the people suffered less from ague.”

(Source: Pioneer History of Orleans County, Arad Thomas, 1872)

Albion hosted two trials in the kidnapping of William Morgan, who threatened to share secrets of Freemasons

Posted 19 January 2025 at 3:49 pm

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, Number 3

This is a sketch of the first courthouse building in Albion as it appeared in 1840. (Landmarks of Orleans County)

Dewitt Clinton was Governor of New York State, serving the first year of his second term of office, when the 48th Legislative Session passed the Act which formed Orleans as a “separate and distinct county of the state of New York”, on April 15, 1825.

Law and order were primary concerns of this Act. It specified that two terms of the “court of common pleas and general sessions of the peace” were to be held in Gaines. Commissioners appointed by the act were instructed to locate a site for a courthouse and jail before the second Monday in June 1825. An election for sheriff, clerk and coroners was to be held on the second Tuesday of May 1825.

The first case was held in Gaines on October 13, 1825, at the Mansion House, a hotel owned by Selah Bronson. Samuel Miner was charged with assault and battery and was sentenced to 30 days in jail.

The first courthouse in the county was built in Albion in 1827 on land donated by Nehemiah Ingersoll. Ingersoll is credited with naming the county and with strategizing the selection of Albion as the county seat in 1826. Located on the site of the current County Jail, the courthouse was a brick building with a white cupola and pillars. The County Clerk’s office was on the first floor, while the jail was in the basement.

At that time, the Free and Accepted Masons were an influential fraternal organization. Many of the early settlers were members and they established lodges shortly after they took up residence, in Ridgeway and Gaines.

In 1826, William Morgan, a disenchanted mason originally from Canada, threatened to publish a book exposing details of the Freemasons closely guarded secret rites. This caused a great furor and added to dissension which had already been brewing among members.

After several incidents, Morgan was arrested and jailed in Canandaigua. His release was organized by Masonic members, on condition that he return to Canada. Following his release, he was immediately escorted to a waiting carriage which then transported him north to Rochester and west along Route 104 to Niagara Falls and freedom in Canada. In all, this hurried journey required three carriage changes, five drivers, seven teams of horses and many assistants.

After some time, it became apparent that William Morgan was missing. He was never seen again after that carriage ride, nor was his body ever found. Speculation was rampant, an investigation was ordered. A total of twenty Grand Jury investigations and fifteen trials ensued.

Two of the trials took place in Albion. The first case against Avery Downer, a teacher from Gaines, was dismissed. The second case, against Elihu Mather, lasted ten days, and was held in November 1829. Hon. Addison Gardiner, Circuit Judge of the 8th Circuit presided.

Mather was charged with conspiracy to kidnap and abduct William Morgan. Detailed accounts of the trial were reported by the Orleans Telegraph and published in newspapers throughout the state, in Canada and in Vermont. (Click here to see historic newspapers in New York State. )

The counsel for the defendant, William H. Adams, addressed the jury for four hours. He did not deny that Mather drove the carriage but argued that he did so innocently, without knowing that any illegal act was contemplated. He argued that there was no proof that Morgan was in the carriage and if he was, there was no proof that he was held by force. The jury returned a verdict of “Not Guilty”.

Several of the others accused were found guilty of kidnapping Morgan, but nobody was charged with his murder, all of which further fueled anti-Masonic sentiment and led to the formation of the Anti-Masonic Party in 1831.

Orleans County could have been named for Adams or Jackson, who both became presidents

Posted 12 January 2025 at 3:32 pm

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, Number 2

This genial looking gentleman, Nehemiah Ingersoll, 1788-1868 is credited with the naming of Orleans County.

ALBION – Imagine that you are a new settler in this area. What would you name the town you live in, or this county?

We take the place names where we live for granted, but two hundred years ago these names were purposefully selected and had resonance for the people who lived here.

We can see why the early settlers were so conscious of their role in history – not only did they purchase the land, stake their claims here with hard labor and make the land productive, but they also had the opportunity to name the land.

On September 14, 1824, a petition was presented to “the Honorable, the Representative of Genesee County” requesting the creation of this county from the north part of Genesee County. The petition refers to the new county as “Adams,” referring to John Quincy Adams, a leading Presidential candidate at the time.

Naturally, the supporters of his opponent, Andrew Jackson, protested and wanted the county to be named “Jackson.” We can well relate to this dilemma.

Nehemiah Ingersoll is credited with championing the name “Orleans” as a compromise, though one source credits Oran Follett, a Genesee County legislator, with this honor. “Orleans” could be construed as an honor to the Duc D’Orleans – or, more likely, a compliment to General Jackson on his victory against the British in New Orleans in 1815.

Incidentally, John Quincy Adams was elected President in 1825, Andrew Jackson won the following Presidential election in 1829.

By the time the name of the county came to be selected, several naming rights decisions had already been made. Eight of the ten towns had been formed and named:

1803 – Town of Murray: named for John Murray, a large landowner in the area.

1812 – Town of Ridgeway: named for Ridge Road

1816 – Town of Gaines: named for General Edmund Gaines who defended the area in the War of 1812

1818  – Town of Barre: named by Judge John Lee (Lee Rd.) for his birthplace, Barre, Massachusetts.

1818 – Town of Shelby: named for Gov. Isaac Shelby, a Revolutionary war soldier.

1821 – Town of Clarendon: originally named Farwell’s Mills for Eldredge Farwell, an early settler, named for Clarendon Vt., hometown of Farwell’s wife.

1822 – Town of Carlton: at first named Oak Orchard, it was changed to Carlton in 1825, for Governor Guy Carlton of Quebec.

1822 – Town of Yates: originally called Northton, the name was changed in 1823 to honor Hon. Joseph C. Yates, Governor of New York State.

The towns formed following the formation of the county were:

1837 – Town of Kendall: named for Amos Kendall, Postmaster General of the United States.

1875 – Town of Albion: set off from the town of Barre and named for Albion, the county seat.

Basically, the names selected were chosen to honor a hometown, a prominent businessman or an elected politician.

Just as a matter of speculation, which name would you prefer: Adams County, Jackson County or Orleans County? Would the selection of either Adams or Jackson have changed the course of history here?

Orleans County celebrates bicentennial in 2025

Posted 5 January 2025 at 2:10 pm

Pioneer residents contended with heavy forest, sickness, war and brutal winter cold

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, Number 1

The remarkable photograph above, taken on June 19th, 1869, shows the hardy pioneers who settled Orleans County.

The records of the Eleventh Annual Meeting of the Pioneer Association held at the Orleans County Courthouse in Albion on that date noted that Mr. George P. Hopkins, photograph artist of Albion, invited the members to have a group photo taken. The invitation was accepted, the meeting adjourned until 1:30 in the afternoon to afford time to take the picture and then get dinner.

On April 15, 2025, Orleans County will mark 200 years since its political formation.

As we have seen in previous columns, this area has been inhabited from time immemorial. Following a convoluted series of land transactions, by 1800 what we now refer to as Orleans County was owned by the Holland Land Company (the land west of Transit Road) and by the Pulteney Estate (the land east of Transit Road).

Attracted by the generous terms promised by the Holland Land Company for the purchase of fertile land, young men set forth with high hopes. According to the Pioneer History of Orleans County, the first settlement of white men in Orleans County was made in 1803 in the Town of Carlton by William and James Walsworth who came from Canada. James settled by the mouth of the Oak Orchard Creek, while William settled by the mouth of Johnson’s Creek.

Conditions were vastly different in Orleans County two hundred years ago:

“A dense and heavy forest of hard, huge trees covered the land…Pestilential fevers racked the nerves and prostrated the vigor…War was declared in 1812…then came the memorable cold season of 1816.”

In the aforementioned Pioneer History of Orleans County (PHOC), we are fortunate to have an excellent record – mostly first-hand – of the experiences of the first settlers of this area. Conscious of their achievements and their place in history, these early pioneer settlers formed the Pioneer Association of Orleans County which had its first meeting at the courthouse in Albion on September 10, 1859.

Article VII of their Constitution specified that “It shall be the duty of each member of the association to furnish in a form suitable for preservation, such facts and incidents in his early pioneer life, and in relation to the first settlements of this country, as he may deem of sufficient interest to be preserved.” They wanted to have their stories recognized and indeed their stories are heartfelt, poignant and captivating.

These accounts formed the basis for the book Pioneer History of Orleans County by Arad Thomas, which was published in Albion in 1871, required reading for any person interested in local history, always available from your local library.

These photos show original Pioneer History record books and a title page from one volume.

The records of the Pioneer Association were meticulously maintained in three volumes. One volume contains the meeting Minutes from 1859-1905, the others contain transcriptions of the firsthand accounts submitted by the settlers. These unique volumes were in the possession of the University of Rochester for many years but were acquired by local history collector Tom Taber at a sale. The Orleans County Legislature approved the acquisition of the volumes by the Orleans County Dept. of History in 2021 with funding from the Orleans County Bicentennial Fund.

Much has changed in 200 years, yet 200 years is but a blink in time. Anniversaries cause us to pause and reflect on changes and accomplishments, and hopefully to draw on the experiences of the past to inform the future.

A century ago, photographer from Shelby had knack for images of people and their pets

Posted 29 December 2024 at 8:47 pm

Now there’s a dog with an attitude! “Sloat’s Dog” presents a regal and commanding pose.  (Scott B. Dunlap Collection)

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 4, Number 40

SHELBY – It is the holiday season! We have been dealing with serious photographs all year long, stern looking men and somber women, buildings and street scenes galore. Time for some lighter fare!

Our submissions today are from the Scott B. Dunlap collection which we have previously used for postmortem and Powerline project photographs.

Born in 1898, Scott B. Dunlap of Dunlap Road in Shelby was a fourth-generation member of the family for whom the road is named. Armed with his new Kodak camera, Scott, who graduated from Medina High School in 1905, took unposed, relaxed photographs of family, friends and animals.

Most likely without intending to, he compiled a precious chronicle of life in rural America in the early 1900s, in those years just before automobiles replaced the horse and buggy. In 2008, Scott B. Dunlap, Jr. donated this collection of over two hundred of his father’s glass plate negatives to the Medina Historical Society.

“Sloat’s Dog” with his snout in the air, cannot but make one smile. It appears that Sloat had another dog, an equally well-fed and imperious canine.

“Sloat’s Dog” #2 (Scott B. Dunlap collection)

According to the 1900 Census, Francis Sloat, a farmer, and his wife, Mary (Dutton), lived in Shelby. Sloat later moved to Corfu, died in 1921 and is buried in Millville Cemetery.

“Dunk’s children” (Scott B. Dunlap collection)

What a visual treasure! The horse is old and calm, the girls are dressed up for the occasion, in matching dresses and hats. The younger girl, on the left, is clutching part of the horse’s mane in her hand.

“Dunk” was Frank Dunkelberger, a farmer in Shelby. The 1900 Census lists his age as 30, his daughters Ruth and Rhea were 6 and 4 at the time of the Census.

“Remson’s children” (Scott B. Dunlap collection)

Upon investigation, these children with the white cat and a sheep may be Seth Ransom’s grandchildren, rather than Remson’s children, as labeled: Theron, Anita and J. Lawrence Caleb who lived on Southwoods Road in Shelby.

“Boy with two dogs” (Scott B. Dunlap collection)

Our last selection (it was difficult to choose) is of this young man, armed with a hunting rifle and two dogs. We were taken by the unsettling expression of the seated dog.

In addition to providing some levity, these photographs contain a treasure trove of attendant details which we can now zoom over and enlarge. Naturally, we relish the challenge of finding additional information on the subjects. Armed with the most basic descriptors “Sloat’s Dog” or “Remson’s Children” we were able to locate information in the Orleans County Genweb site and the New Century Atlas of Niagara and Orleans Counties, 1913.


https://orleans.nygenweb.net

https://www.historicmapworks.com/Atlas/US/7112/Orleans+County+1913/

Landauer’s Christmas catalog from 1967 promoted polyester clothing for partying, lounging

Posted 22 December 2024 at 11:43 am

Loungewear, Landauer’s of Albion Christmas catalog, 1967

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 4, Number 39

ALBION – We associate the colors red and green with Christmas: Santa’s red suit, green Christmas trees, red berries on holly.

At first glance, the color scheme of this Landauer’s Christmas catalog appears jarring. But realizing that the catalog is from 1967 explains the teal, magenta and mustard colors. At the time, Landauer’s was the main department store in Albion.

This catalog lists items of clothing sold and worn just 63 years ago, still remembered (and owned?) by some, no doubt. But in terms of fashions, fabrics, colors and descriptions, this clothing might as well be from the crinoline era.

The clothing items shown above were listed as suitable “For Partying or Lounging” and, it is interesting to note that the colors are more seasonal than those shown on the cover.

The first item on the left, 2B, is a Lounger culotte of 80% Arnel® triacetate, 20% nylon. Three quarter sleeves. Styled by Lazy U. Washable. Colors: orange or lime $23.

Landauer’s Christmas catalog, 1967

Item 2C: Floral patterned quilt duster of Honan acetate crepe. Kodel® polyester fiberfill. Blue or gold. $16

Item 2D:  A long robe version of Item 2C

Item 2E:  Luxuriant “Radiant Fleece” duster of 80% Arnel Triacetate and 20% nylon with the look of velour. Front panel with embroidered grosgrain ribbon, concealed gripper closing. Colors: Tangerine, Kelly green, desert rose. $16

The colors are vibrant, the styles are non-restrictive, and the fabric is easy-care synthetic. Production of natural fabrics had declined during World War II due to the focus on the war effort. Synthetic fibers were developed in the 1950s to meet an increased demand for fabric. Tired of rationing and shortages, consumers were eager to buy new clothes. The new fabrics were popular as they were easy to wash, wrinkle-free, durable and affordable.

Of the fabrics listed in the above descriptions, Arnel® was a trademarked synthetic triacetate fabric developed in 1954 by the Celanese Corporation of America. It ceased production in 1984, due to increased toxicity standards for production and competition from newer polyesters.

Kodel® polyester was developed in 1958 by Eastman Chemical, a subsidiary of the Eastman Kodak Company. It felt like cotton but was more durable and less expensive to produce.

Ladies fashion also included Orlon® acrylic knits, “Fairfield She Shells”, cardigans and sweaters in vibrant colors – canary, lemonette, coquette pink, fresh grass and sprite green.

Men’s clothing, Launder’s of Albion catalog, 1967

With the heading “Handsome New Ideas for His World”, several pages feature coats and jackets for men and boys.

Item 22B: The fabulous Koratron® zip-out three season coat, lined with 100% Acrilon® acrylic tone tipped pile. Colors: black, navy, olive or British tan. $30.00

Koratron® was developed in 1956 by Joseph Koret who was working on creating a permanent crease product for men’s trousers. When coated with resin and baked at 325 degrees, the fabric permanently adopted creases as designed, while the remainder of the fabric remained wrinkle resistant.

The men’s dress shirts were made of Dacron® polyester and were “Sanforized®”, a pre-shrinking process developed by Sanford Cluett in 1930 that reduced shrinking after washing. Sport shirts were made from Ban-Lon® texturized nylon “that simply never needs ironing.”

Consumers in the 1960s embraced the convenience and versatility of clothing made from synthetic materials. The wash-and-wear, no-iron properties revolutionized laundry day. Sixty-three years later, we are more aware of the downside of the synthetic revolution  and it’s detrimental effects on the environment.