Shawna’s Barn rebuilds after devastating fire, continues Christmas tradition in Medina

By Isabella Zasa, Staff Writer Posted 21 November 2026 at 8:55 am

‘We had so much love and support from the community, which helped make reopening possible’

Photos by Isabella Zasa: From left, Richard Monica, Shawna Baldwin and Chris Baldwin stand outside Shawna’s Barn, which they rebuilt with help from the community following the August 2025 fire.

MEDINA – After a fire destroyed three barns on their property in August 2025, Shawna and Chris Baldwin, along with their family friend and partner Richard Monica, faced the loss of their Christmas shop and the merchandise they had spent years collecting and creating. With help from family, friends and the community, they were able to rebuild and continue the seasonal tradition at Shawna’s Barn, located at 3502 Fruit Ave. in Medina.

Three of the barns at the Baldwins’ family home were destroyed, including a 250-year-old structure they had spent considerable time restoring. The fire also destroyed the building that housed the Christmas shop, along with the merchandise inside.

Despite the extensive damage, a few items managed to survive. Among them were two wooden angels, which remain on the property today. A plastic M&M character that now greets customers from the front porch and a Fisher-Price Little People Buffalo Bills set also made it through the fire.

“It’s amazing and strange some of the things that survived,” Shawna Baldwin said. “Those two angels were definitely watching over us.”

Provided photo: The aftermath of the August 2025 fire shows the remains of one of the barns destroyed on the Baldwins’ property. The wooden angel pictured survived the fire and now hangs on the couple’s front porch.

Following the fire, Shawna Baldwin said the community came together to help the family rebuild. When she decided she wanted to reopen the business, members of the local Amish community, her church, friends and family stepped in to offer their assistance.

“We had so much love and support from the community, which helped make reopening possible,” she said.

The fire marked a difficult chapter for a business that began in 2020 as a way for Shawna Baldwin to share her love of crafting and Christmas.

The idea to open the store took shape when the COVID-19 pandemic forced the cancellation of Niagara-Orleans BOCES’ annual craft show. Baldwin, who works as a secretary at BOCES, had previously sold her handmade items at the event.

Shawna Baldwin works on a lampshade at the store’s front counter. The shop features a variety of handmade and repurposed items created by the Baldwins and Richard Monica.

Rather than miss the opportunity to share her creations, Baldwin decided to welcome shoppers to her own barn. By following the state COVID-19 guidelines and restrictions in place at the time, she was able to safely open the space to customers.

The response was strong, and word of the shop quickly spread beyond the local community. Customers began traveling to the barn from throughout the region and beyond, including Syracuse, Canada and Dansville.

As interest continued to grow, the Baldwins expanded the barn, adding a porch and additional space for shoppers. Chris, Shawna and Monica, along with help from family and friends, worked to finish and decorate the space.

Much of the merchandise is handmade by the Baldwins and Monica, a retired art teacher who spent 34 years teaching in Spencerport .

Chris Baldwin, who is retired, creates many of the wooden items sold in the shop and helps maintain the property. Pieces of scrap wood left over from the barn’s construction were transformed into miniature villages, churches, lanterns and ornaments.

Shawna Baldwin displays a lamppost handmade by her husband, Chris. The entire piece is available for purchase at Shawna’s Barn.

Monica also contributes his artistic experience to the business, helping create many of the items and displays. He said Christmas is his favorite time of year, and he has eight Christmas trees in his own home.

He recalled one customer who initially entered the barn saying she did not like Christmas. After looking around, she left the store and came back to tell them they “know how to do Christmas.”

Monica said reactions like that make the work worthwhile.

“This is why we do what we do,” he said. “It’s a magical season.”

Shawna Baldwin and Richard Monica stand inside Shawna’s Barn, which features handcrafted and repurposed items, vintage decorations, antiques and more.

The barn features a variety of merchandise, including one-of-a-kind creations, vintage ornaments and antiques, handmade decorations, repurposed items, angels, snowmen, Santas, fresh wreaths and swags.

Among Shawna Baldwin’s favorite pieces is an antique cradle dating to the 1800s. The display features dolls and bears belonging to the late Nancy Berger and her mother, the late Mildred Wilson Baker. Berger owned The Personal Touch at 435 Main St. in Medina. Berger later worked with Baldwin at The Whole Nine Yards on Main Street.

Preparing for the Christmas season is a year-round effort. Monica said they begin making merchandise in January, with some handmade items taking nearly a year to complete.

Shawna’s Barn is open the last two weekends of November on Fridays and Saturdays from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. and Sundays from noon to 4 p.m. Additional information and updates are available on the business’s Facebook page by clicking here.