Too few jobs with data center despite big tax breaks, consumption of resources
Editor:
Several years ago, the Genesee County Economic Development Center (GCEDC) decided to place an industrial park next to the Iroquois National Wildlife Refuge and the Tonawanda Seneca Nation’s Reservation Territory, right on the border of its biodiverse old-growth Big Woods.
The GCEDC said it would create 9,000 good-paying jobs. But to date, they have created zero.
Recently, Stream Data Centers is proposing to build a 2.2 million square foot, 500 megawatt data center. And how many jobs would they create? 125. And how much in tax breaks are they asking for? $810 million. Which translates into roughly $6.4 million per job.
This is so outrageous that even our state environmental conservation agency has put GCEDC on notice.
In a recent letter to GCEDC, DEC set forth rigorous and meaningful requirements for GCEDC’s environmental review of the monster data center.
For the first time, the DEC is directing GCEDC to conduct a Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) for the STAMP site as a whole and for data centers specifically. This guidance represents a meaningful turning point for environmental review at STAMP and answers the Nation’s decade-long call for a robust SEIS for STAMP.
Moreover, DEC points out numerous gaps of information and inconsistencies in the plans that STREAM has submitted so far, and raised numerous important additional details that STREAM and GCEDC will have to provide in order to complete SEQR review.
And: DEC states that GCEDC must analyze how a massive data center providing just 125 jobs (they say 120, the number listed in the original application) jobs is consistent with the original goal of the STAMP site to provide 9,000 jobs.
Well done, DEC! I’m glad to see the agency calling out GCEDC for their failed promises and challenging them to justify how building an environmentally harmful, energy wasting data center using taxpayer subsidies is good for the public.
Nationwide opposition to data centers is growing. According to datacenterwatch.org, $64 billion of data center projects have been blocked or delayed.
Nobody wants them in their back yard and yet the GCEDC and other organizations are offering huge incentives for the companies to bring data centers to their communities.
Most of these communities are rural and important agricultural areas.
We oppose this monster data center and ask GCEDC to rethink STAMP. Why not build a Monarch Butterfly Sanctuary and a native plant nursery?
People are wanting more native plants and more protection of our food and water sources.
Join the Allies of the Tonawanda Seneca Nation alliesoftsn.weebly.com and tell GCEDC and Stream absolutely not!
Evelyn Wackett
Buffalo













The Bishop Nursing Home in Medina, Rose Villa Nursing Home in Albion, the Rembrandt Nursing Home in Kendall are but a few of the Orleans County facilities that provided residential care for elderly and incapacitated patients from the 1930s to the 1970s.