local history

Photo: Shadigee provided relief from the heat more than a century ago

Posted 29 June 2025 at 3:57 pm

Photographed at Shadigee: (from left) John J. Ryan, Rev. F.T. Latham, Mrs. Latham, Alberta D. Ryan, Mrs. LeRoy Skinner. Children seated: Lee Skinner, Howard Phillips, Gertrude Skinner and Clare Ryan.

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 24

YATES – When temperatures soar, we wonder how previous generations coped with the heat. Summer temperatures in the Buffalo region reached over 90-degrees then also: 95 degrees in 1911 and 1914; 93 degrees in 1913; 91 degrees in 1912.

Shadigee, in the Town of Yates, was a popular summer destination for those who lived in the western end of Orleans County. It first developed as a business port. According to the historic marker at the site, the Yates Pier was built in 1850 to facilitate the shipping of lumber and grain. The Shadigee Hotel, a popular resort, was built in 1860. It was located on the site now occupied by the water treatment plant.

Jeddo photographer, William Eaton, captured this crisp postcard photo of a group enjoying the outdoors. John J. Ryan was a lawyer in Medina. He and Leroy Skinner had an office on the second floor of the Cook Block, Medina. The practice was subsequently continued by Bernard Hart and Thomas C. Mack.

The Ryans resided at 411 West Center St. in Medina, the Skinners lived at 238 West Center. Rev. A.J. Latham was a minister at the Baptist Church.

The presence of the children in the photograph helps pinpoint the date. According to the 1915 Census, Lee Skinner was 10, his sister Gertrude and Clara Ryan were both aged 7. Those ages seem to match, so we can assume that the photo was taken from 1914-1916.

The basket of apples on the ground indicates that the photo was taken later in the season, early September, perhaps. Clutching their dolls, the girls pose happily, while the boys assiduously ignore the camera. Some things never change!

Fundraising trivia game from mid-1980s gives snapshot of Holley businesses

Posted 23 June 2025 at 9:20 am

This is the cover of Trifles trivia game, left, and the playing board from the game, right.

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, Number 23

HOLLEY – Where is Garrand’s Quarry?

Name the postmaster of Holley in 1985?

What was the reason for the formation of the Holley School Boosters?

These Holley area questions are from a trivia game recently brought to our attention by Melissa Ierlan, Town of Clarendon Historian. Marketed under the name  “Trifles: a Unique Educational Trivia Game Customized for Your Community,” this board game was marketed in the mid-1980s as a fundraiser for the Holley Sports Boosters and the Holley Music Boosters.

Designed to be played by two or more players, the box contains a sturdy board, a rules sheet, tokens, dice, discs, a box of question and answer cards, and a set of category questions and answers.

The names of contributing local businesses appear on square tiles on the perimeter of the board. Players who answer General Knowledge trivia questions correctly can place colored discs on the tiles.

A player who has three or more discs on each of the four sides of the board or six discs on any one side of the board qualifies to enter the circle. The Master Position is at the end where the player must answer correctly a question from the Etc. category to be the winner.

The General Knowledge questions are wide-ranging and varied, while the “Etc.” questions are locally oriented.

Trifles was manufactured by Henco in Selmer, TN and was the creation of Tom Hendrix, a versatile entrepreneur who had honed his salesmanship skills as a door-to door Bible salesman. He and his wife, Sherry, started Henco with a $3,500 loan, in a small building in Selmer. The company went national, with nearly 1,000 employees on the payroll in its heyday of helping schools raise money through selling items that Henco manufactured.

Regardless of how much money was raised by sales at the time, this game is a gem forty years later. Kudos to whoever prepared the questions and answers for the “Etc.” category back then. They are now a rich resource of Holley/Murray/Clarendon area facts, and would be perfect for family get-togethers and campfire conversations.

The list of the local businesses, farmers,  and professionals who subscribed captures the essence of Holley at that point in time. How many of them do you remember?

A quick eBay search indicates that the resale value of the game is only about $25, but its local significance will only increase the passage of time.

Holley area sponsors of the Trifles trivia game from 1984-85 incude:

  • Assembly of God Church
  • Bowen Trucking, Inc.
  • Brockport Ford Tractor
  • Burgio Tire World
  • Country Garden Florist
  • Danny’s Small Engine Repair
  • Dave’s Antenna Satellite Communications
  • Danco Home Improvements
  • Deerfield Country Club
  • DeNe’s Cake Shop
  • Disciples United Methodist Church
  • Domenico’s Italian Imports & Deli
  • Drennan Service
  • Ed Blissett Nursery
  • Edward Fuirerer & Sons, Builders
  • Fingland Electric
  • First Baptist Church
  • First Presbyterian Church
  • Fissler Collision
  • 5 Point Collision
  • Gordis Hardware
  • Grenadier Kennels
  • Hendel Farms
  • Herring Development Corp.
  • Holley Cold Storage
  • Holley Lime Company
  • Holley Mower Service
  • Holley Pharmacy
  • Holley Ridge Stables
  • Holley Super Duper
  • Hurd’s Orchard Apple Shed
  • Jerry L. Wagner, Contractor
  • Jim Albright, Remodeling
  • J.P’s Farm Market
  • Lake Country Pennysaver
  • Lester, Rubenstein & Pellegrino, Attorneys
  • Liftec Systems
  • Lisa’s Dance Boutique
  • Lutes Model Dome
  • Marine Midland Holley Staff
  • Maxon Farms
  • Merrill- Grinnell Funeral Service
  • Muesey’s Grocery of Clarendon
  • Murray Superette Busy Mart
  • Personality Plus Hairstyles
  • P.J.’s Dolls
  • Rayburn’s Jewelers
  • Rockafellow & Son Farms
  • Ron’s Satellite Sales
  • Ryan’s Ceramic Studio
  • Salyers Archery & Range
  • 7 Brothers Catering Service
  • Seward Candies
  • Shepherd’s Mill Lumber
  • St. Mary’s Roman Catholic Church
  • St. Paul’s Episcopal Church
  • Squicks – Public Square
  • Stockham Lumber Co.
  • Sugar’s Bikeology Shop
  • Territory Wholesale Supply
  • Transit Sportsman’s Supplies
  • Thomas Young, Attorney-at-Law

One-room schoolhouse will host history talks for county’s bicentennial

Posted 16 June 2025 at 7:18 am

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 22

GAINES – The Orleans County Historical Association has scheduled an ambitious monthly series of History Talks in celebration of the county’s bicentennial.

The programs are on Wednesdays and begin at 7 p.m. They are presented in a unique setting: the restored one-room cobblestone schoolhouse at 3286 Gaines Basin Rd., Albion. That school was built in 1832 and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

The schedule is as follows:

Dennis Upton portrays Joseph Ellicott, a major influencer in the development of Western New York.

• June 25: Dennis Upton will present a first person portrayal of  Joseph Ellicott (1760-1826). The name Ellicott is familiar to us – Ellicott Creek, Ellicottville etc. but we never question how these placenames originated. As the person who surveyed the area and sold the land, Joseph Ellicott had a profound and lasting impact on the early development of Western New York. Ellicott was also instrumental in the development and routing of the Erie Canal.

• July 30: “The Haudenosaunee Confederacy” – Kae Woodruff Wilbert will discuss the history of the six Indigenous nations whose traditional lands encompass New York State.

• Aug. 27: Amy Machamer, owner of Hurd Orchards in Holley, will discuss “Orleans County Fruit Culture as Living History.”

• Sept. 24: Doug Miller, retired history teacher, will discuss how multiple religious ideas and beliefs developed and spread along the Erie Canal in the early 19th century in a talk titled “The Erie Canal & The Burned Over District; History is not Accidental.”

• Oct. 29: The county’s historic markers capture the stories of people, place and events of significance. Catherine Cooper, Orleans County historian, will present the newly reissued edition of the book, Historic Markers of Orleans County, which includes the markers added in the last 24 years.

There is no admission charge for these programs. Donations are gratefully accepted.

Albion man wrote patriotic song, ‘Keep on Flying,’ during World War II

Posted 9 June 2025 at 9:39 am

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, Number 21

Cover of sheet music for this Chapman/Melville composition

ALBION – We continue our survey of musicians in Orleans County with an introduction to Archie Chapman who composed stirring lyrics of encouragement in 1942 for members of the US Army Air Forces serving in World War II with his composition, “Keep on Flying.”

Archibald Samuel Chapman was born in 1893 in the village of St. Faith’s, Norfolk County, in England. He served as a gunner in the Royal Field Artillery, Territorial Forces, in World War 1 and was awarded a British War Medal and a Victory Medal.

He was one of the many immigrants from Norfolk who settled in Orleans County. His sister Emma and her husband Ernest Mayes had been living in Gaines since 1912. Archie came to the US in January 1920. Eliza Ann Spark joined him in August of that year and they were married in Albion on August 31, 1920.

They operated a farm on Allen Road for twenty years. Archie later worked at the Grower’s Cold Storage in Waterport, at Hunt’s Foods Inc. and retired in 1957.


“KEEP ON FLYING”

(We’ll build the ships for you)

Dawn, a new day is breaking, war is now fought in the sky

Caissons now will go a-rolling, guarded by the ships that fly.

We have the men to build them, we have the money too,

So, keep ‘em flying soldier, we’ll roll ‘em out to you.

Chorus

Keep on flying, Keep on flying, up there in the sky

Keep on flying, keep on flying, soldiers keep ‘em high

You do the flying, we’ll do the rest

We’ll build the planes and give you the best.

War, that was forced upon us by an unworthy foe,

Band us all as one together, onward to fight we go.

Danger and death before us, peace and victory too

Just keep ‘em flying soldier, we’ll roll them out to you.


A naturalized citizen, Archie was very invested in his community. He was an Albion village trustee, a member of the Albion Masonic Lodge, the Chamber of Commerce, the Zoning Board of Appeals, the Orleans County Democratic Committee and was involved in scouting. He was a past president of the Active Hose Company of the Albion Fire Dept. and of the Orleans County Fair Assn.

He also played in the Albion Sheret Post American Legion Band. Band director, W.J. Melville

composed the music for “Keep on Flying.” The two collaborated on several other compositions: “There’s an Angel Watching Buddy” and “The Sheret Post March.”

In addition to composing verse and lyrics, Archie painted watercolors.

Following their active lives in Albion, Archie and Eliza chose to return to the village of St. Faith’s in Norfolk. According to a Democrat & Chronicle article, they sold their home, furniture and car and set sail to England from Hoboken on July 13, 1962, having visited their daughter and son-in-law in New Jersey. Archie died in Norfolk in 1977 at the age of 83.

The sheet music for “Keep on Flying” is the only Chapman composition in the Orleans County Dept. of History collection. We would welcome any of the others, especially “The Sheret Post March.”

2 families, Donatelli and Coppa, performed in popular local bands about a century ago

Posted 1 June 2025 at 11:44 am

Front row, from left: Charles D’Amico, Mike Donatelli, Isodore DiLodovico, Casper Pilato, Pete Johnson, missing name, Sam DeLuca and Allen Briggs. Back row: Fortunato Sidari, Frank N. Monacelli, Joe Donatelli, Tony Acri, Horace Monacelli, Ralph DiGiiulio and Victor Penasack.

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 20

Two bands, both of Italian descent, provided musical entertainment locally through the 1940s.

Brothers Mike and Joe Donatelli of Albion organized the Donatelli Band (or Donatelli’s Band) in 1912. Mike directed the band for over 25 years. The brothers operated a barber shop over what was then Landauer’s Store. The band played at weddings, local events and concerts, at the annual County Fair in Albion and on July 4th at Lakeside Park.

In the 1920s and 1930s, they entertained many music lovers who attended concerts hosted by the Sheret Post and the American Legion Post in Albion. Baritone, Fortunato Sidari was especially popular with audiences.

In Medina, the popular Coppa Family Band and Orchestra was formed in the late 1920s.

Joseph Coppa, the father, operated a shoe repair business on Main Street in Medina, but music was his true passion. He sold musical instruments at the store and also taught music.

He also provided musical instruction to his children and was an exacting taskmaster, as his son, Andy, recalled in an Oral History interview. Each of the Coppa children played in the family band: Andy, drums; Christine, piano; Mary, saxophone; Margaret, violin. Victoria, who played the trumpet, sadly died of tuberculosis at the age of 23 in 1943.

The Coppa Family Band played at carnivals and social events, old-time dances and square dances for which they were paid $5 to $7 per night. Andy recalled playing at Leo Foss’ Chicken Coop and Robinson’s Barn, where the dance was held in the hay loft, above the cow house. But the rustic venues did not seem to detract from the enjoyment, Andy recalled:

“Oh! Everybody had a grand time there. People brought box lunches and mixed them up, Whoever you danced with, you sat with and mingled and everybody had a grand time.”

Historical Association sets schedule for summer cemetery tours

Staff Reports Posted 26 May 2025 at 8:52 am

File photo by Tom Rivers:  The Kendall community observed Memorial Day on May 30, 2018 at Greenwood Cemetery. The Orleans County Historical Association included Greenwood Cemetery in this summer’s cemetery tours. The cemetery is on Route 18, across from the Dollar General store.

The Orleans County Historical Association has announced the schedule of cemetery tours this summer.

The tours are conducted every Sunday at 6 p.m. during the month of August. The cemeteries on this year’s tours are:

  • August 3 – Mount Albion Cemetery (Route 31, Albion) with Bill Lattin, retired Orleans County Historian and Sue Starkweather Miller, Village of Albion Historian.
  • August 10 – Robinson Cemetery (Rt. 237 & Glidden Rd, Clarendon) with Melissa Ierlan, Clarendon Historian.
  • August 17 – Millville Cemetery (East Shelby Road, Medina) with Alice Zacher and Mary Zelazny.
  • August 24 – Greenwood Cemetery (Rt. 237 & Rt. 18, Kendall) with Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian.
  • August 31 – St. Joseph’s Cemetery (E. Avenue, Albion) with Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian and Sue Starkweather Miller, Village of Albion Historian.

Go to orleanshistory.org for information on the tours as well as historical talks.

Historian shares letters from two WWI soldiers from Orleans County

Posted 25 May 2025 at 8:30 am

Charles W. Wogatzke was first casualty from Kendall; Edward H. Barron of Holley was wounded and had arm amputated

Marines at the Battle of Belleau Wood, France, 1918, in this artwork created by Georges Scott. This illustration “American Marines in Belleau Wood (1918)” was originally published in the French Magazine “Illustrations.”

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 19

On Memorial Day, we pause to mourn those who died while serving in the United States Armed Forces. So many young men, their stories forgotten.

Here are the World War I stories of two young Orleans County men: Edward H. Barron of Holley and Charles Wogatzke of Kendall.

Their letters provide a glimpse into their characters as they adjust to the cruel reality of war with humor and courage.


HOLLEY MAN RETURNS HOME

Edward H. Barron Loses Arm in France and Will Be Discharged

HOLLEY, July 26 – Mrs. Eugene Weirs of this place is in receipt of two letters regarding her son Edward H. Barron, who was reported seriously injured in the casualty list in the early part of June

One of the letters is from the Hospital and Home Service, Paris, in which it is stated that his arm was so badly injured, it had to be amputated. The other letter is written for Private Barron by the mother of one of the nurses in the hospital in Paris:

Dear Mother: Just a few lines to let you know that I am improving nicely and hope to be out of bed soon. I took a walk this morning in a rolling chair. My legs are all right, but about my wounds, I am sorry to tell you that they were obliged to take off my right arm which means discharge from service. So, you see that I shall be home soon. Everything has a good side. If I had had an ordinary wound, I should have had to remain whereas without my arm I shall only be good to come back to you.

I tried to write to you with my left hand but am afraid that you would not have been able to read it. The lady who is writing this letter is the mother of one of my nurses; both Parisian ladies who lived in New York a long time.

Edward H. Barron enlisted on May 4, 1917. He served in the Marine Corps and was wounded in France at the Battle of Belleau Wood in June, 1918. He was discharged on May 8, 1919.

Later employed as a clerk at the Veterans Hospital in Buffalo, he was a life member of the Disabled American Veterans, Dr. Martin F. Nolan Chapter 50 of North Tonawanda. He died in 1954 at the age of 55.


KENDALL BOY WRITES OF EXPERIENCES IN THE TRENCHES

Excerpts from a letter written by Charles Wogatzke of Kendall:

Dear Friends:

Saturday, July 20, 1918

Pvt. Charles W. Wogatzke of Kendall

…. We are back from the trenches for ten days rest and to get cleaned up again. We needed it very bad for the cooties were so thick. This seems to be a great country for rats and mice: the trenches are full of them……It is mostly barbed wire entanglements through here and it looks pretty rough. The ground is full of shell holes.

…. Well, how did you spend the Fourth out there? We spent ours in the trenches. Fritz sent over all kinds of fireworks for us, some lively night, believe me, but we played fair with him and sent over just as many to him. We have two friends, that is our rifle and gas mask, which we have to carry with us all the time. I remember one night; we had just laid down and fell to sleep when the guard hollers “Gas” and you had ought to see us get those masks on! For it doesn’t take but a very little to put a man out of business.

I am a rifleman and bayonet fighter; that’s my business now. How would you like that job?

My watch runs fine and I am very glad that you got that kind instead of a wrist watch. The boys have most all got wrist watches and most of them have broken them, and another thing, they make a very good target for a sniper for you can see them for a good ways at night.

Well, I guess I have told you all the news, and as it is getting late will have to stop writing at this time…..

From your Friend,

Charles Wogatzke   


This scrapbook was donated to the Orleans County Department of History.

Charles Wogatzke was the Town of Kendall’s first casualty of World War I. Born in Dec. 1890, he was the son of Albert H. and Martha A. Wogatzke who had immigrated from Germany in 1887.

According to enlistment records, Charles was of medium build with brown hair and blue eyes. He was employed as a laborer with the New York Central Railroad. Drafted in Albion on February 25, 1918, he was assigned to the 306th Infantry Regiment, 77th Division and was sent overseas on April 16, 1918. He was killed in action on August 12, 1918, and is buried in the Oisne-Aisne American Cemetery in Picardie, France.

These letters were published in the Holley Standard newspaper and collected in a scrapbook, later donated to the Orleans County Dept. of History collection.

OCHA talks will highlight bicentennial of county, Erie Canal

Posted 23 May 2025 at 11:22 am

Series starts May 28 featuring first Norwegian settlement in U.S. at Kendall

Press Release, Orleans County Historical Association

Provided photo: A historical marker at the intersection of Norway Road and Bald Eagle Drive  in Kendall highlights the Norway Colony.

GAINES – The Orleans County Historical Association once again welcomes the community to their monthly history talks.

The talks are held from May through October on the last Wednesday of the month at 7 p.m. in the Gaines Basin Cobblestone Schoolhouse on 3286 Gaines Basin Rd. The talks are free and donations are gladly accepted.

This year’s presentations will spotlight the 200th anniversary of Orleans County and the Erie Canal.  The schedule includes:

  • May 28: “The First Norwegian Settlement in the U.S. – Kendall, NY (1825)” – Dee Robinson, retired Gaines town historian, will share the fascinating history of how the Norwegians came to the United States and made their way to Kendall, settling on Norway Road.
  • June 25: “The Life of Joseph Ellicott, Surveyor of the Wilderness” – You won’t want to miss Dennis Upton, a storyteller and re-enactor as he brings to life the story of Joseph Ellicott who was an agent of the Holland Land Company and helped to survey and sell land in Western New York as well as advocate for the Erie Canal.
  • July 30: “The Haudenosaunee Confederacy” – The Confederacy consists of six Indigenous nations whose traditional lands encompass New York State. Guest speaker Kae Woodruff Wilbert will share their history in New York State and Orleans County.
  • August 27: “Orleans County Fruit Culture as Living History” – Guest speaker Amy Machamer, Owner of Hurd Orchards, will share her experiences and insights about the rich and unique fruit culture of Orleans County.
  • September 24: “The Erie Canal & The Burned Over District; History is not Accidental” – Retired history teacher Doug Miller will share how multiple religious ideas and beliefs, of which some were uniquely formed, developed and spread along the Erie Canal in the early 19th century.
  • October 29: “New York State Historical Markers” – Orleans County Historian Catherine Cooper has updated the 2001 Orleans County historical markers book and will share information on some of the new markers that have been installed in the County during the last 24 years.

Sweet Adelines chorus from half century ago crooned many classics

Posted 12 May 2025 at 12:36 pm

Members of the Ontario Shores Sweet Adelines photographed in November 1976. Front row, from left: Edna Walck, Bonnie Powley, Marcia Housel (musical director), Betty Cole and Penny Powley. Second row: Pat Balcerzak, Joan Arnold, Pat Few, Phyllis McCarthy, Mary Lee Knights, Sylvia Allen and Theda Powley. Third row: Kathy Stahl, Audrey Lamb, Carol Lenhardt, Linda Rau, Janet Walck, Jean Gates and Helen James. Members absent from the photo: Claire Simons, Jan White, Elaine Jamele, Mary Lou Zimmerman, Kathy Hartway, Sue Wingfield and Janine Holbrook.

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 18

MIDDLEPORT – Ladies who liked to sing, harmonize and socialize formed a local chapter of the Sweet Adelines in 1972.

Named for a barbershop song popular in the early 1900s, the Sweet Adelines started in Tulsa, Oklahoma in 1945 with a small group of women who liked to sing. It grew into an international, educational and social organization which promotes the folk-art style of singing four-part harmony, barbershop style.

The local chapter, named the Ontario Shores Sweet Adelines Chorus of Middleport received its international charter in February 1976. It included Niagara and Orleans counties and was part of Region 16 which covered New York State to Kingston, Ontario. Ontario Shores members at that time hailed from Holley, Lyndonville, Medina, Barker, Middleport and Newfane.

Marcia Housel of Lyndonville, a founding charter member, was the group’s music director for 16 years. An ardent proponent of the power of group singing, she believed that it provided “a real lift.” In a November 1974 interview, she explained that the Sweet Adelines repertoire focused on familiar tunes “music you can hum along to,” show tunes, patriotic songs and the “old classics” such as “Down by the Riverside.”

The newly formed Sweet Adelines presented their first annual show on November 6, 1976, at the Roy-Hart School auditorium in Middleport. The theme was “From Bonnets to Bellbottoms” and featured early and contemporary music.

Thus began a busy schedule of shows, competitions and performances at civic events and of course weekly rehearsals. A professional choreographer instructed the group in facial expression, mime acting, characterization and dance.

In 1984, Ann Gemerek of Holley was the director of the Christmas entertainment presented at the Carl I. Bergerson auditorium in Albion.

In 1985, a double quartet from Ontario Shores performed for the 700 members attending the Region 16 annual Music School event held at the Ramada Inn in Niagara Falls. They included: Jan Pritchard and Jean Gates of Medina; Janet Walck, Lyndonville; Joyce Compson and Mary Brocksopp of Holley; Laurie Costello, Brockport, Pat Few and Marie Krockenberger of Lockport.

The group’s activities were chronicled in the Medina Journal Register newspaper through the late 1980s. Carol Oschmann of Kendall was awarded the “Sweet Adeline of the Year” in 1987. Rosanne Mauragis became a new member in 1987 and Bonnie Orgar joined in 1988.

Cindy Parada’s mother, Elaine Jamele, was a member of the Sweet Adelines for many years. Cindy recalls: “Mom loved being a member of the Sweet Adelines! They just had so much fun. She joined with her best friend, Linda Rau. There was a great sense of camaraderie among the members. They sang music that they liked and wore fun costumes. It was theatrical, they enjoyed the thrill of performing but as a group which made it easier. Good times.”

It appears that the chapter discontinued in the early 1990s. We are sure that those ladies who loved to sing, harmonize and socialize kept photos, scrapbooks and other memorabilia of their Sweet Adeline adventures. The Orleans County Dept. of History would like to chronicle this aspect of our musical history, please contact Catherine.Cooper@orleanscountyny.gov. if you have material to donate.

Can any readers help us identify these happy harmonizers?

Albion native started first travel agency; ‘Ask Mr. Foster’ expanded to 75 locations

Posted 4 May 2025 at 9:02 am

With this succinct slogan, Albionite Ward G. Foster launched the first travel agency in Florida in 1888.

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 17

ALBION – “WARD G. FOSTER, 80, TRAVEL AGENT, DIES; His Slogan, ‘Ask Mr. Foster,’ Known to Tourists in All Parts of the World THE FIRM HAS 75 OFFICES A Woman in Charge of Each, After Long Training at Headquarters Here” – New York Times headline, March 18, 1940

This New York Times obituary headline from March 18, 1940, summarizes the career of Ward Grenelle Foster who died on March 17, 1940. Born in Albion on May 6, 1860, he was the son of Carlton T. Foster and Charlotte Corday Foster.

According to the 1879 Orleans County Directory, Ward’s father was a “hatter & furrier” with a store at the corner of North Main and West Bank streets. The family home was listed as 36 West State St.

Ward G. Foster established the first travel agency.

Ward attended the Albion Academy. He married Harriet Brainerd in 1884, and the couple moved to St. Augustine, Florida, which was then just beginning to realize its potential for tourism. Foster was employed as a timekeeper on the construction of Henry Flagler’s luxury resort in St. Augustine, the Ponce de Leon Hotel.

In 1888, the Fosters opened a gift, book and stationery shop across the street from the hotel. Foster had earned a reputation for being knowledgeable about the area’s activities and amenities as well as about transportation lines and timetables. Guests at the hotel were directed to his store with the instructions “Ask Mr. Foster” who graciously answered their queries.

Recognizing the potential of this market, Foster took over the advertising of a popular local publication “The Standard Guide to St. Augustine.” He added the statement: “Ask Mr. Foster for Further Advice” on every page and soon he was busy dispensing travel information and had unwittingly started the first travel agency.

Tourism in Florida expanded rapidly. Ward opened “Ask Mr. Foster” travel offices in Jacksonville and Palm Beach. In 1902, he opened an office in Washington D.C. By 1937 the “Ask Mr. Foster” travel service operated 70 Information Offices in 52 cities throughout the U.S. and Canada.

As the New York Times headline indicated, a unique feature of the Ask Mr. Foster offices was that they were managed by women. Foster recognized that gracious service, empathy and a sincere spirit of helpfulness in dealing with customers were key components for the success of his enterprise and he believed that women were more likely to possess those characteristics. The goodwill generated by such a service, he felt, would guarantee return visits and word-of-mouth promotion.

Naturally, this business model was successful. In 1936 over 400,000 customers received information, planned trips and tours, purchased tickets, and made hotel and transportation reservations, all free of charge.

The “Ask Mr. Foster” Travel Service Office is shown at the R.C.A. Building, Rockefeller Center, New York.

Foster sold the business in 1938 to a group which incorporated as the “Ask Mr. Foster Travel Service.” Though the business struggled during the war years, it rallied and in 1957, two of the stockholders bought the company for $157,000.

In 1972, Peter Ueberroth purchased the business for $1 million.

A complex series of corporate purchases ensued. Carlson Companies, Inc., acquired the business in 1979. In 1990, the name “Ask Mr. Foster” was retired and integrated into the Carlson Travel Network. This eventually became part of the Travel Leader’s Group corporation which evolved into the Internova Travel Group in 2020.

Internova, now one of the travel industry’s largest travel service companies, focuses exclusively on leisure, luxury and corporate clients. To this day, the company proudly traces its roots and ethos of service back to Ask Mr. Foster Travel.

Historic marker notes famous case of Charles Stielow, falsely accused of murder in Shelby

A historic marker highlights Charles Stielow, who was on death row after being falsely accused of murder. A book, “Slaughter on a Snowy Morn,” was published on 2010, detailing the case.

Posted 27 April 2025 at 8:34 am

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 16

SHELBY – April 24-27 has been designated as National Historic Sign weekend. The Historic Marker Database site lists 143 signs in Orleans County. This sign is located on Salt Works Road in West Shelby. It was erected in 2014 through the efforts of Nicholas Culver.

An innocent man was found guilty of murder and was sentenced to death by electrocution. He bade a tearful farewell to his family and was escorted to Death Row. He narrowly avoided execution several times and was exonerated after three long years.

 The plot of a TV drama? Regrettably not, but an all too real nightmare endured by a Shelby family.

The reference, of course, is to the Charles F. Stielow case. He was convicted in Albion in 1915 of the murders of George Phelps and Margaret Woolcott in Shelby. An overwhelming combination of circumstances conspired against Stielow – prejudice against immigrants, unscrupulous investigators, a  “confession” obtained by coercion and threats, a charlatan “expert” witness.

A thorough account of this dramatic case may be found in the book “Slaughter on a Snowy Morn” written by Colin Evans and published in 2010. It is a book that never fails to elicit a passionate response from readers: the nightmarish sequence of events described, the familiarity of the setting, and the blatant corruption all contribute to its power.

Concluding a year of exploring aspects of Orleans County history in honor of the county’s Bicentennial, members of the Medina Tuesday Club met recently to discuss this book. One overlooked aspect – the actual cost of the trial – was referenced and seemed worthy of exploration.

In New York State, criminal prosecutions are county expenses, a fact that we rarely consider or just take for granted. In 1915, Orleans County was governed by a Board of Supervisors. A record of the Board’s meetings and decisions was published annually under the title “Proceedings of the Board of Supervisors.” A  primary source, these volumes form a core part of the Orleans County Dept. of History collection. The following material was sourced from the Proceedings for 1915, 1916 and 1917.

On Jan. 8, 1916, a committee appointed to tabulate the items of expense of the trial reported that the county had expended $12,649.97 at that point. The details of the expenses were listed:

  • Automobile Hire: $131
  • Barber: $11
  • Board & Meals: $606.21
  • Crier & Attendance Officers: $316.60
  • Coroner: $93.05
  • Coroner’s Physician: $64
  • Death Watch: $18
  • Detectives: $3,815.88
  • Defendant’s Witnesses: $44.30
  • Defendant’s Counsel: $1,379.19
  • Expert Witnesses: $1,189.26
  • Grand Jury: $438.70
  • Grand Jury Witness: $438.70
  • People’s Witnesses: $44.30
  • Sheriff’s Expenses: $250
  • Stenographer etc.: $1,763.40
  • Trial jurors: $1,746.20
  • Witness Allowance: $128

(Most likely, the Barber and Death Watch expenses occurred at Sing Sing on July 28, 1916, when Stielow came within hours of death. His head and legs were shaved in preparation for the attachment of electrodes. A Death Watch was maintained during what was expected to be his last night.)

On May 8, 1917, the Board of Supervisors approved $5,465.87 in payments to lawyers who acted as Counsel to the DA in the Stielow case: Thomas A. Kirby: $1,450, Frederic M. Thompson: $1,450, Harold A. Blake: $2,425 plus expenses of $140.87.

Additional expenses for $2,395.62 were submitted on January 18, 1917. Among these expenses were:

  • George W. Newton, detective services: $648.09
  • Byrne National Detective Bureau: $126.32
  • Expert testimony and expenses: $582.04
  • Automobile hire: $358.87
  • Stenographer and typing: $264.84
  • Photographer for DA, Patrick A. Grimes: $5.35

These expenses alone total $20,511.46 ($560,600 approx. in today’s cost). Additionally, on Jan.31, 1917, Gov. Whitman allocated a special appropriation of $25,000 for a reinvestigation of the case. Meanwhile, Stielow’s family, deprived of their breadwinner, were impoverished.

Charles F. Stielow was released, a free man, on May 9,1918. He received no compensation for his ordeal, nor did he seek it, he was just happy that it was over. He died at the age of 63 on Aug. 9, 1942 at his home on Church Street, Medina, having had some years to enjoy his favorite pastime – sitting on his front porch and smoking his pipe. He and his wife, Laura, are buried at the Pioneer Cemetery in Akron, NY.

Soldier from Orleans County was at Ford’s Theater when Lincoln was shot

Posted 20 April 2025 at 12:37 pm

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 15

Corporal John H. Stevens of Knowlesville, a member of the 151st Regiment, had the distinction of several interactions with President Lincoln.

While we were busy celebrating the Bicentennial of Orleans County on April 15, we overlooked April 14, 1865, the assassination of Abraham Lincoln, 160 years eariler. Remarkably, one young man from Orleans County was among the audience of approximately 1,700 in attendance that night at Ford’s Theater in Washington, D.C.

John H. Stevens was born in Knowlesville on Sept. 23, 1839, the son of Andrew Stevens and Sophronia Harding. Andrew Stevens had moved to the area in 1816 and was one of the earliest settlers in what was then a wilderness. A farmer, he benefitted greatly from the opening of the Erie Canal.

In the summer of 1862, additional recruits were needed for the Union cause. Captain Hezekiah Bowen of Medina received authority to recruit a company of riflemen. John Stevens was one of the one hundred who quickly enlisted, mostly sons of well-to-do farmers. They were nicknamed the “Top Buggy Company,” since many of them could afford to take their young ladies out in top-buggies, then considered an item of luxury.

They bought their own guns, Sharp’s Rifles, each paying over forty dollars apiece for them. The ladies of Ridgeway presented them with a silk flag embroidered “Bowen’s Ind. Rifles.”

Stevens was mustered in as a Corporal of Company A, 151st N.Y. Volunteer Infantry on October 22, 1862. He was wounded at the Battle of Mine Run, Va.  on November 27, 1863, receiving a bullet wound to his right thigh. Following his recovery, he was placed on duty at the Medical Purveyor’s store in Baltimore on March 4, 1864.

In June of that year, Stevens received a ticket to attend the Republican National Convention from Senator E.D. Morgan of New York. Stevens was present when Lincoln was nominated for the second time.

Stevens voted for Lincoln twice, on Nov. 6, 1860, and Nov. 8, 1864.

He was transferred to work at the Medical Bureau of the Provost Marshal General’s Office in September 1864. He attended church on Thanksgiving Day, 1864, sat in Senator Morgan’s pew and at the end of the service, walked down the aisle alongside President Lincon.

On January 1, 1865, Stevens attended the Annual Meeting of the Christian Commission, listened to a speech given by Lincoln and afterwards, shook his hand.

John H. Stevens in later years

On Good Friday, April 14, 1865, Stevens was seated in the front center seat of the dress circle at Ford’s Theater. He saw Booth leap from the box after he shot the President. Stevens was unable to see Lincoln’s remains lying-in-state because of the crowds, but he did witness the funeral procession.

Stevens was discharged on May 11, 1865. He returned to Knowlesville, and married Alice Andrews in 1866. They had two children, George and Avery. Alice died in 1875. Avery died in 1881, aged 11. Stevens married Mary D. Clapp in 1876, they had two daughters, Florence and Mary.

Stevens was an active member of the G.A.R. and a member of the S.J. Hood Post 91 for many years. He attended reunions of the 151st Regiment and liked to recount his encounters with Lincoln.

Stevens died on February 15, 1919, at the age of 80, in the home in which he had been born, having fulfilled his wish of living to mark the centenary of that home which had been built by his father in 1816. He is buried in Tanner Cemetery in the Town of Ridgeway, NY.

Bell at Courthouse will be rung at noon on Tuesday for County Bicentennial

Photo from Orleans County Department of History: The bell in the County Courthouse was installed in 1860.

Posted 13 April 2025 at 1:35 pm

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 14

ALBION – Listen for the peal of the Courthouse Bell in Albion at noon on Tuesday April 15, 2025!

The bell will ring for one minute on that date, in celebration of the Orleans County Bicentennial. Churches throughout the county are encouraged to ring their bells also.

Albion’s Courthouse bell was installed in the dome in 1860, two years after the construction of the building. The cost of hanging it was $24.06. At one time it was used regularly to indicate when the Court was called to session.

It was rung on Armistice Day, November 11, 1918, by some boys who had gained access to the belfry, on January 19, 1959, to celebrate the Courthouse Centennial and again in 1976 for the country’s Bicentennial celebration.

According to a File Feature reference in the Journal-Register newspaper, the bell was next rung on August 20, 1985, by David Stevenson, an employee of the County’s Buildings and Grounds Dept. who had joked that he would ring the bell if his first grandchild was born on his birthday.

The ringing of the bell at noon on Tuesday, April 15 will mark the beginning of the Bicentennial event to mark the 200th anniversary of the formation of Orleans County on April 15, 1825.

The event will take place in the Courthouse, a fitting location, long recognized as “a central focus for the citizens of Orleans County,” to quote Irene Gibson, author of Historic Sites in Orleans County, New York. Hon. Sanford A. Church will launch the event which will feature Proclamations and remarks by legislators and historians, followed by cake, of course.

Seating is still available. Descendants of the early settlers are encouraged to attend. The event may be viewed remotely on the Orleans County Tourism Facebook page (click here).

Descendants of Orleans County pioneers urged to attend Bicentennial celebration on April 15

Posted 30 March 2025 at 8:25 pm

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian 

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 13

ALBION – The original handwritten volumes of the Pioneer Association records include several photographs. Shown in the top photo are Martin Evarts (1817-1873) and his wife, Charlotte Burnham Evarts who died in 1862. Martin was a farmer in Clarendon and Town Supervisor in 1863.

Members of the D.A.R. and the S.A.R. proudly trace their lineage back to an ancestor who “aided in achieving American independence.” So too, descendants of the early settlers of Orleans County trace their genealogy back to those hardy pioneers and can now chronicle up to nine generations of continuous residence in the county.

The Orleans County Bicentennial Committee invites these descendants to attend the Bicentennial Celebration of the formation of the county which will take place at the Courthouse in Albion on April 15, beginning at 11:45 a.m. So that we may ensure seating for all, please complete the brief registration form at https://www.orleanscountytourism.com/bicentennial.

Members of the Pioneer Association of Orleans County photographed in Albion on June 19, 1869.

On June 19, 1869, those in attendance at the Eleventh Annual Meeting of the Pioneer Association of Orleans County, held at the Courthouse in Albion, assembled for a group photo. The Bicentennial Committee plans to echo this now iconic photograph by taking a group photograph of those in attendance immediately following the event.

We are interested in learning about your connections to those early settlers – please email Catherine.Cooper@orleanscountyny.gov.

In 1979, community created keepsake of favorite recipes

A treasury of recipes was compiled by the Orleans County Historical Association in 1979.

Posted 23 March 2025 at 3:02 pm

By Catherine Cooper, Orleans County Historian 

“Illuminating Orleans” – Volume 5, No. 12

ALBION – “Tucked among the keepsakes that reflect the earlier years of this unique county are the recipes found in this treasury. Some are copied, some created, some from yesteryear and some from today. All with a special touch from a special person – the one who so generously shared their favorite recipe.”

“Favorite Recipes of Orleans County” is a spiral bound community cookbook produced in 1979 by the Orleans County Historical Association. It was printed in Albion by the Eddy Printing Company. Mary Shuler and Millie Scofield were co-chairwomen.

A hefty tome, with over 300 pages, it is double the size of a regular community cookbook. It includes the staple community cookbook recipes one would expect but also includes heirloom recipes from grandmothers and great-grandmothers, thus linking back to the early years of the county.

Mrs. Charles Defendorf (Rose Hart) submitted a recipe for Salt Raising Bread which was passed down from her great grandmother, Matilda West, 1826-1899. It begins:

“Start bread at night. Scald 2tbsp. of cornmeal and ½ tsp each of salt, sugar, and soda in 1 cup sweet milk. Cover and set in warm place overnight…..”

A recipe for Gingerbread submitted by Doris Bannister is traced back to a descendant of John Proctor, “the Paul Revere of the Ridge” who, in 1813, alerted the residents along Ridge Rd. that “the British were coming.”

A recipe for Corn Bread which includes yeast, mashed potato and cornmeal is traced back to the Matthew Dunham family, the earliest settlers in the Lakeside area of the Town of Carlton.

A recipe for Homemade Ale copied from the Journals of Samuel Brent, Canterbury, England, dates to 1829. It was submitted by his great-granddaughter, Betty Hurd.

Not surprisingly, there are many variations of apple recipes: Apple Grunt, Apple John, Apple Roll, Elegant Apple Pie, French Apple Pie, Apple Cake, Apple Chip Cake, Applesauce Cake, Apple Pie Cake, Apple Pudding Cake, Glazed German Apple Bread, Apple Stuffed Pork Chops, and Squirrel in Apple Bake.

Several recipes reflect the strong English heritage of the county’s population: Grandma’s English Trifle, English mincemeat and 19th Century Whig Rolls.

So many recipes with intriguing names: Taylor Duff, Tell Your Neighbor Cake, Seafoam Salad, Pickled Seckel Pears and The Old Stand By, to mention but a few.

Interspersed with the recipes are nuggets of local history such as: how Troutburg got its name, the Orleans Meat Processing Company in Albion, canning in Holley, the cheese factories. A section on Remedies includes instructions on how to make soap using potash, lard, and rosin, how to remove wrinkles, make a liniment or a mustard plaster.

“Favorite Recipes of Orleans County” is a heartfelt homage to the families who have lived in Orleans County and to the cooks who sustained them. If you don’t own a copy, keep an eye out at yard sales and book sales. If you are lucky, you may even find an edited version, with the former owner’s comments critiquing the recipes!